Regardless of the controversy on this point I have to say sorry but that last post you linked to sure nailed it as well as anyone who has ever visited Hall of Ma'at could have. Yes threads were continually shut down, ranks were always closed and even the moderator was fed information in rebuttal by a team of behind the scenes orthodox thinkers and then tried to post them off as their own. Certain posters were allowed unfair liberties in rebuttal and when we protested in kind we were either barred or the thread was closed. So carry on with your argument and remember your cronies at The Hall of Ma'at ( I still can't believe what a total misnomer this is) are counting on you.
And as to Scott I don't always agree with him BUT I DID NOT BAR HIM AS MA'AT DID !
aka King Menes