Mysteries :  The Official GrahamHancock.com forums
For serious discussion of the controversies, approaches and enigmas surrounding the origins and development of the human species and of human civilization. (NB: for more ‘out there’ posts we point you in the direction of the ‘Paranormal & Supernatural’ Message Board). 
Welcome! Log InRegister
Thanos5150 wrote:

> Sitchin has re-interpreted existing translations,
> ergo it is not possible that anyone before this could have
> agreed or disagreed with him and other than Heiser no scholar
> since has taken on the task. This is not to say Sitchin is
> right, as I have made clear, but to say that every other
> Semitic language scholar of the last 120yrs "disagrees" with
> Sitchin is dishonest as the fact is only one has bothered to
> look at his work.

Not quite. Others have as well, including Piotr Michalowski (incidentally a contributor to the Electronic Text Corpus of Sumerian Literature - see my previous post), who repeatedly uses terms such as 'nonsense' and 'rubbish' to describe Sitchin's work.


Options: ReplyQuote


Subject Views Written By Posted
Zecharia Sitchin’s Research Just a Matter of Interpretation Says Fortean Author 826 mookie49 12-Nov-13 00:05
Re: Zecharia Sitchin’s Research Just a Matter of Interpretation Says Fortean Author 714 Martin Stower 12-Nov-13 00:28
Re: Zecharia Sitchin’s Research Just a Matter of Interpretation Says Fortean Author 475 Thanos5150 12-Nov-13 01:18
Re: Zecharia Sitchin’s Research Just a Matter of Interpretation... 416 cladking 12-Nov-13 01:27
Re: Zecharia Sitchin’s Research Just a Matter of Interpretation Says Fortean Author 483 Merrell 12-Nov-13 09:45
Re: Zecharia Sitchin’s Research Just a Matter of Interpretation Says Fortean Author 456 Thanos5150 12-Nov-13 23:21
Re: Zecharia Sitchin’s Research Just a Matter of Interpretation Says Fortean Author 467 Merrell 13-Nov-13 09:08
Re: Zecharia Sitchin’s Research Just a Matter of Interpretation Says Fortean Author 444 Thanos5150 13-Nov-13 16:19
Re: Zecharia Sitchin’s Research Just a Matter of Interpretation Says Fortean Author 439 Merrell 13-Nov-13 16:40
Re: Zecharia Sitchin’s Research Just a Matter of Interpretation Says Fortean Author 479 Thanos5150 14-Nov-13 00:32
Re: Zecharia Sitchin’s Research Just a Matter of Interpretation Says Fortean Author 445 Merrell 14-Nov-13 10:37
Re:Sitchin’s Research Just a Matter of Interpretation Says Fortean Author 464 jamesglory 16-Nov-13 06:23
Re: Zecharia Sitchin’s Research Just a Matter of Interpretation Says Fortean Author 412 Martin Stower 12-Nov-13 15:05
Re: Zecharia Sitchin’s Research Just a Matter of Interpretation Says Fortean Author 461 Thanos5150 12-Nov-13 20:31
Re: Zecharia Sitchin’s Research Just a Matter of Interpretation... 516 cladking 12-Nov-13 20:58
Re: Zecharia Sitchin’s Research Just a Matter of Interpretation... 497 NetWorkAngel 12-Nov-13 21:57
Re: Zecharia Sitchin’s Research Just a Matter of Interpretation... 441 Martin Stower 13-Nov-13 01:20
Re: Zecharia Sitchin’s Research Just a Matter of Interpretation... 363 Thanos5150 13-Nov-13 02:11
Re: Zecharia Sitchin’s Research Just a Matter of Interpretation... 468 Martin Stower 14-Nov-13 00:21
Re: Zecharia Sitchin’s Research Just a Matter of Interpretation... 523 cladking 13-Nov-13 21:52
Re: Zecharia Sitchin’s Research Just a Matter of Interpretation Says Fortean Author 662 Merrell 12-Nov-13 23:44
Re: Zecharia Sitchin’s Research Just a Matter of Interpretation Says Fortean Author 502 Thanos5150 13-Nov-13 01:17
Re:ET - Matter of Interpretation 392 Thunderbird 13-Nov-13 20:46
Re:ET - Matter of Interpretation 476 Thanos5150 14-Nov-13 00:41
Re: Zecharia Sitchin’s Research Just a Matter of Interpretation Says Fortean Author 426 Martin Stower 13-Nov-13 01:03
Re: Zecharia Sitchin’s Research Just a Matter of Interpretation Says Fortean Author 435 Thanos5150 13-Nov-13 01:53
Re: Zecharia Sitchin’s Research Just a Matter of Interpretation Says Fortean Author 462 Merrell 13-Nov-13 09:14
Re: Zecharia Sitchin’s Research Just a Matter of Interpretation Says Fortean Author 862 Thanos5150 13-Nov-13 16:59
Re: Zecharia Sitchin’s Research Just a Matter of Interpretation Says Fortean Author 454 Martin Stower 13-Nov-13 23:02
Re: Zecharia Sitchin’s Research Just a Matter of Interpretation Says Fortean Author 435 Thanos5150 14-Nov-13 01:13
Re: Zecharia Sitchin’s Research Just a Matter of Interpretation Says Fortean Author 483 Martin Stower 14-Nov-13 01:25
Re: Zecharia Sitchin’s Research Just a Matter of Interpretation Says Fortean Author 445 Thanos5150 14-Nov-13 01:57
Mod Note > Thanos5150 521 Dr. Troglodyte 14-Nov-13 16:36
Mod Warning #2 > Martin Stower 488 Dr. Troglodyte 14-Nov-13 16:33
Re: Zecharia Sitchin’s Research Just a Matter of Interpretation Says Fortean Author 513 Martin Stower 13-Nov-13 22:40
Re: Zecharia Sitchin’s Research Just a Matter of Interpretation Says Fortean Author 441 Thanos5150 14-Nov-13 00:46
Re: Zecharia Sitchin’s Research Just a Matter of Interpretation Says Fortean Author 430 Martin Stower 14-Nov-13 01:08
Re: Zecharia Sitchin’s Research Just a Matter of Interpretation Says Fortean Author 432 Thanos5150 14-Nov-13 01:31
Re: Zecharia Sitchin’s Research Just a Matter of Interpretation Says Fortean Author 403 Frank D 13-Nov-13 16:59
Re: Zecharia Sitchin’s Research Just a Matter of Interpretation Says Fortean Author 472 Scott Creighton 13-Nov-13 17:20
Re: Zecharia Sitchin’s Research Just a Matter of Interpretation Says... 452 cladking 13-Nov-13 22:15
Re:...Just a Matter of Interpretation Says Fortean Author 469 Raja 15-Nov-13 20:39
Zecharia Sitchin and Sumerian cuneiform 494 Merrell 12-Nov-13 09:39
Re: Zecharia Sitchin and Sumerian cuneiform 438 cladking 12-Nov-13 21:10
Re: Zecharia Sitchin and Sumerian cuneiform 414 Merrell 12-Nov-13 22:08
Re: Zecharia Sitchin and Sumerian cuneiform 366 cladking 13-Nov-13 22:28
Re: Zecharia Sitchin and Sumerian cuneiform 437 Sirfiroth 12-Nov-13 22:20
Re: Zecharia Sitchin and Sumerian cuneiform 458 cladking 13-Nov-13 22:35
Where are the Aliens? Where is Nibiru? 443 Eddie Larry 13-Nov-13 04:06
Re: Where are the Aliens? Where is Nibiru? 426 Thanos5150 13-Nov-13 05:32
Re: Where are the Aliens? Where is Nibiru? 444 Merrell 13-Nov-13 09:22
Re: Where are the Aliens? Where is Nibiru? 444 Thanos5150 13-Nov-13 17:13
Re: Where are the Aliens? Where is Nibiru? 452 Merrell 13-Nov-13 18:02
Re: Where are the Aliens? Where is Nibiru? 465 Thanos5150 14-Nov-13 00:30
Re: Where are the Aliens? Where is Nibiru? 627 Merrell 14-Nov-13 10:23
Re: Where are the Aliens? Where is Nibiru? 443 Thanos5150 14-Nov-13 17:08
Re: Where are the Aliens? Where is Nibiru? 500 Merrell 14-Nov-13 18:31
Re: Where are the Aliens? Where is Nibiru? 439 Thanos5150 14-Nov-13 19:12
Re: Where are the Aliens? Where is Nibiru? 431 Merrell 15-Nov-13 08:14
Re: Where are the Aliens? Where is Nibiru? 404 Eddie Larry 14-Nov-13 03:09
Re: Where are the Aliens? Where is Nibiru? 452 loveritas 13-Nov-13 05:49
Re: Where are the Aliens? Where is Nibiru? 458 Eddie Larry 14-Nov-13 03:18
Re: Newfound Star System Is Third-Closest to Sun 440 Thunderbird 14-Nov-13 02:40
Re: Newfound Star System Is Third-Closest to Sun 441 Eddie Larry 14-Nov-13 03:08
Just learned the other day 401 Ratcho 14-Nov-13 07:24
Re: Just learned the other day 435 Eddie Larry 15-Nov-13 03:13
I'll found that video for you 432 Ratcho 15-Nov-13 06:25
Re: I'll found that video for you 442 Eddie Larry 16-Nov-13 03:05
A mental exercise, just for argument's sake 420 mephisto 13-Nov-13 21:33
Re: A mental exercise, just for argument's sake 423 cladking 13-Nov-13 22:44
Re: A mental exercise, just for argument's sake 420 mephisto 14-Nov-13 22:23
Re: A mental exercise, just for argument's sake 452 cladking 14-Nov-13 22:36
Re: Zecharia Sitchin’s Research Just a Matter of Interpretation Says Fortean Aut 449 Archae Solenhofen 14-Nov-13 00:39
Re: Zecharia Sitchin’s Research Just a Matter of Interpretation Says Fortean Aut 429 spitfire888 14-Nov-13 04:04
Where's the good faith errors in Baalbek? 447 Ratcho 14-Nov-13 04:41
Re: Where's the good faith errors in Baalbek? 481 Archae Solenhofen 14-Nov-13 06:17
Re: Where's the good faith errors in Baalbek? 412 Thanos5150 14-Nov-13 07:36
Re: Where's the good faith errors in Baalbek? 439 Archae Solenhofen 14-Nov-13 08:25
Re: Where's the good faith errors in Baalbek? 428 Thanos5150 14-Nov-13 18:46
Re: Where's the good faith errors in Baalbek? 464 Archae Solenhofen 14-Nov-13 23:58
Re: Where's the good faith errors in Baalbek? 956 Thanos5150 14-Nov-13 06:44
Re: Where's the good faith errors in Baalbek? 417 Archae Solenhofen 14-Nov-13 07:37
Re: Where's the good faith errors in Baalbek? 444 Thanos5150 14-Nov-13 17:50
Re: Where's the good faith errors in Baalbek? 464 Archae Solenhofen 15-Nov-13 02:10
Re: Where's the good faith errors in Baalbek? 459 jamesglory 16-Nov-13 06:44
Re: Where's the good faith errors in Baalbek? 448 Ratcho 16-Nov-13 07:43
Re: Where's the good faith errors in Baalbek? 451 Archae Solenhofen 16-Nov-13 17:03
Re: Where's the good faith errors in Baalbek? 442 Thunderbird 16-Nov-13 18:00
Re: Where's the good faith errors in Baalbek? 729 Thanos5150 16-Nov-13 21:48
Re: Where's the good faith errors in Baalbek? 438 Archae Solenhofen 16-Nov-13 22:05
Re: Where's the good faith errors in Baalbek? 448 Archae Solenhofen 17-Nov-13 07:52
Apis bull sarchophagi... 429 Ratcho 17-Nov-13 08:15
Re: Apis bull sarchophagi... 471 Archae Solenhofen 17-Nov-13 08:37
Re: Apis bull sarchophagi... 378 Ratcho 17-Nov-13 20:33
Re: Apis bull sarchophagi... 436 Archae Solenhofen 18-Nov-13 16:57
Re: Apis bull sarchophagi... 457 cladking 18-Nov-13 21:48
Re: Apis bull sarchophagi... 411 Archae Solenhofen 18-Nov-13 22:44
Re: Apis bull sarchophagi... 420 cladking 19-Nov-13 00:36
Re: Apis bull sarchophagi... 419 Archae Solenhofen 19-Nov-13 07:47
Re: Apis bull sarchophagi... 454 cladking 19-Nov-13 19:04
Re: Apis bull sarchophagi... 567 Thanos5150 17-Nov-13 18:23
Re: Apis bull sarchophagi... 411 Archae Solenhofen 18-Nov-13 17:54
Alexander Column 466 Merrell 18-Nov-13 18:02
Re: Alexander Column 398 Archae Solenhofen 18-Nov-13 18:30
Re: Alexander Column 388 Merrell 18-Nov-13 20:32
Re: Alexander Column 463 Archae Solenhofen 18-Nov-13 21:26
Re: Where's the good faith errors in Baalbek? 453 Martin Stower 18-Nov-13 00:13
Re: Where's the good faith errors in Baalbek? 464 cladking 18-Nov-13 05:37
Re: Where's the good faith errors in Baalbek? 453 Ratcho 18-Nov-13 05:46
Re: Where's the good faith errors in Baalbek? 428 Martin Stower 18-Nov-13 20:13
Re: Where's the good faith errors in Baalbek? 423 cladking 18-Nov-13 22:01
Re: Where's the good faith errors in Baalbek? 505 Martin Stower 19-Nov-13 01:02
Re: Where's the good faith errors in Baalbek? 424 cladking 19-Nov-13 01:17
Re: Where's the good faith errors in Baalbek? 435 drrayeye 18-Nov-13 08:26
Re: Where's the good faith errors in Baalbek? 407 Merrell 18-Nov-13 23:33
Re: Zecharia Sitchin’s Research Just a Matter of Interpretation Says Fortean Author 510 Sukhwant 18-Nov-13 02:54


Sorry, only registered users may post in this forum.