Mysteries :  The Official GrahamHancock.com forums
For serious discussion of the controversies, approaches and enigmas surrounding the origins and development of the human species and of human civilization. (NB: for more ‘out there’ posts we point you in the direction of the ‘Paranormal & Supernatural’ Message Board). 
Welcome! Log InRegister
Hello all at GHMB

In the last times I have usually prefered to read posts rather than participating, but now I have decided to present a subject in a extended way in order to initiate a debate, if you deem it interesting. That’s why I have written an article, which you can read on the forum ("articles") section.

The intention of this article is to introduce a new insight into the traditional concept of civilization, facing the mainstream vision to a different approach based not on describing or interpreting historical facts, but on the actual human behaviour throughout the ages. In this article I explain that civilization is traditionally supposed to be a huge step in human development, as a result of material, scientific and technological evolution of human communities, from the primitive age of hunter-gatherers or early farmers to our complex 21st century world. This conventional view comes directly from the evolutionist paradigm of the triumph of the “civilized” man over the “savage” man. In short, civilization is usually considered as progress, since the modern man has a sophisticated life full of comfort, material goods and technology, yet sometimes ignoring the high price he has to pay for it.

However, my vision points out the fact that human condition (in terms of attitude or ethics) has not improved at all since the times of the ancient kings and emperors, as we are living in an unbalanced world with wars, opression, poverty, famine, corruption and all kind of odds. In this context, many people may feel confused as they don’t know the real destination of civilization, particulary when some trends indicate that the Western world is running to a situation of collapse. Thus, as some alternative authors have claimed, this would be not real civilization but barbarism in many aspects, because there are no spiritual values behind the egotistic crazy world of these days. Needless to say, it's obvious that primitive people may have violent behaviour too. So it's not about comparing cultures, but about focusing in the responsibility of the civilized world.

I know this approach embraces many fields of discussion, so I hope you may find some interesting ideas about this vision of history. I’m looking forward to hearing from your opinions.

Thank you in advance.

Options: ReplyQuote


Subject Views Written By Posted
The concept of civilization: an ethical insight 1760 Titus Livius 15-Sep-12 21:31
Re: The concept of civilization: an ethical insight 485 NorthernStar 16-Sep-12 04:53
Re: The concept of civilization: an ethical insight 384 Titus Livius 16-Sep-12 10:43
Re: The concept of civilization: an ethical insight 463 NorthernStar 16-Sep-12 21:47
Re: The concept of civilization: an ethical insight 407 Sirius7237 16-Sep-12 07:41
Re: The concept of civilization: an ethical insight 472 Titus Livius 16-Sep-12 10:50
Article Link 407 lukehancock 16-Sep-12 08:28
Re: The concept of civilization: an ethical insight 454 Eddie Larry 16-Sep-12 15:58
Re: The concept of civilization: an ethical insight 456 Titus Livius 16-Sep-12 17:48
Re: The concept of civilization: an ethical insight 417 Eddie Larry 17-Sep-12 03:51
Re: The concept of civilization: an ethical insight 438 Titus Livius 17-Sep-12 08:17
Re: The concept of civilization: an ethical insight 418 Eddie Larry 18-Sep-12 03:08
Re: The concept of civilization: an ethical insight 456 Titus Livius 18-Sep-12 08:11
Re: The concept of civilization: an ethical insight 437 Eddie Larry 19-Sep-12 02:49
Re: The concept of civilization: an ethical insight 451 Sirius7237 16-Sep-12 18:36
Re: The concept of civilization: an ethical insight 445 Eddie Larry 16-Sep-12 19:09
Re: The concept of civilization: an ethical insight 380 Sirius7237 16-Sep-12 19:34
Re: The concept of civilization: an ethical insight 457 Tom Hebert 16-Sep-12 18:38
Re: The concept of civilization: an ethical insight 404 Eddie Larry 16-Sep-12 19:11
Re: The concept of civilization: an ethical insight 450 Lothur 16-Sep-12 21:13
Re: The concept of civilization: an ethical insight 413 Titus Livius 17-Sep-12 08:05
Re: The concept of civilization: an ethical insight 436 Lothur 17-Sep-12 15:11
Re: The concept of civilization: an ethical insight 429 Titus Livius 17-Sep-12 17:36
Re: The concept of civilization: an ethical insight 432 Lothur 19-Sep-12 16:03
Re: The concept of civilization: an ethical insight 397 MJT 19-Sep-12 18:50
Re: The concept of civilization: an ethical insight 393 Lothur 20-Sep-12 15:47
Re: The concept of civilization: an ethical insight 402 MJT 20-Sep-12 18:00
Re: The concept of civilization: an ethical insight 413 Lothur 20-Sep-12 20:57
Re: The concept of civilization: an ethical insight 435 MJT 22-Sep-12 15:17
Re: The concept of civilization: an ethical insight 417 Lothur 25-Sep-12 19:26
Re: The concept of civilization: an ethical insight 400 MJT 25-Sep-12 23:35
Re: The concept of civilization: an ethical insight 414 Sirfiroth 17-Sep-12 22:16
Re: The concept of civilization: an ethical insight 380 MJT 18-Sep-12 00:50
Re: The concept of civilization: an ethical insight 421 richarddullum 17-Sep-12 01:59
Re: The concept of civilization: an ethical insight 376 Titus Livius 17-Sep-12 12:04
Re: The concept of civilization: an ethical insight 470 Vanya 18-Sep-12 22:40
Re: The concept of civilization: an ethical insight 416 Titus Livius 19-Sep-12 10:47
Re: The concept of civilization: an ethical insight 407 Vanya 19-Sep-12 12:23
In the name of civilization...what? 420 Titus Livius 21-Sep-12 08:27
Re: In the name of civilization...what? 443 Eddie Larry 22-Sep-12 00:25
Re: In the name of civilization...what? 405 Vanya 22-Sep-12 14:32
Re: The concept of civilization: an ethical insight 502 NetWorkAngel 22-Sep-12 20:44
Re: The concept of civilization: an ethical insight 417 Titus Livius 22-Sep-12 21:20
Re: The concept of civilization: an ethical insight 451 NetWorkAngel 22-Sep-12 22:30
Re: The concept of civilization: an ethical insight 456 cladking 22-Sep-12 23:33
Re: The concept of civilization: an ethical insight 380 matthewbellah 26-Feb-17 13:15
Re: The concept of civilization: an ethical insight 468 Titus Livius 02-Mar-17 10:16


Sorry, only registered users may post in this forum.