Mysteries :  The Official GrahamHancock.com forums
For serious discussion of the controversies, approaches and enigmas surrounding the origins and development of the human species and of human civilization. (NB: for more ‘out there’ posts we point you in the direction of the ‘Paranormal & Supernatural’ Message Board). 
Welcome! Log InRegister
Hi John,
The sudden explosion of Egyptian culture and technology which you and others have previously documented appears to coincide if not be the direct result of the arrival of the so called "Dynastic Race" of Mesopotamians in Egypt circa 3,200BC. Their period of influence seems to abruptly end at Sakkara and other than the curiously out of place palace facade architecture found in the interior of Menkaure's pyramid they had all but long disappeared from Egyptian history by that time. Walter B. Emery was of the mind that the DR was not Sumerian and may have represented a mother-culture to both civilizations.

It is understood they were not the "invading" force as Petrie envisioned, but their influence is remarkable and of little doubt though rarely if ever acknowledged.

I would ask what are your thoughts about the Dynastic Race and their level of influence and do you see them as the instigators of pyramid building in Egypt, or to the point, the Giza complex? Also, the fact G3 does incorporate palace facade architecture, a style even by mainstream dating had been abandoned for almost 200yrs-is it possible this is telling evidence that G3 is potentially much older thereby giving a more likely date for the rest of Giza? One more if you can, but do you agree with Emery and if so what are your thoughts about where they might have come from?

I understand nearly all of us regard Giza to be much older regardless and for clarity I am trying to stay within the confines of mainstream dating so if their is anything you would like to add about how this all may fit in with alternative timelines that would be welcome as well.

Thanks,
Lee



Post Edited (21-Aug-12 03:35)

Options: ReplyQuote


Subject Views Written By Posted
John Anthony West: : GHMB Community Interview --Ask Anything 171 lukehancock 20-Aug-12 09:37
Just how bad is democracy? 51 Loki74 20-Aug-12 11:22
Re: John Anthony West: : GHMB Community Interview --Ask Anything 50 Archae Solenhofen 20-Aug-12 19:12
Re: John Anthony West: : GHMB Community Interview --Ask Anything 156 Thanos5150 21-Aug-12 03:04
Re: John Anthony West: : GHMB Community Interview --Ask Anything 39 BSinKY 21-Aug-12 19:05
Re: John Anthony West: : GHMB Community Interview --Ask Anything 41 myownmyth 21-Aug-12 20:20
Rogan-West Podcast link 38 lukehancock 22-Aug-12 04:41
Re: Rogan-West Podcast link 38 cladking 23-Aug-12 02:09
Re: John Anthony West: : GHMB Community Interview --Ask Anything 47 Nejc 21-Aug-12 21:38
Re: John Anthony West: : GHMB Community Interview --Ask Anything 45 Cain 22-Aug-12 02:02
Re: John Anthony West: : GHMB Community Interview --Ask Anything 40 cladking 22-Aug-12 04:25
Ayahuasca; Civilization Collapse 57 lukehancock 22-Aug-12 09:13
Is an unforeseen Golden Age drawing near, and what must happen to get there? 45 Chaser 22-Aug-12 09:14
Klaus Dona reveals Egyptian like artifacts found in Ecuador; 12,000 years ago! 271 Renown 22-Aug-12 10:20
Re: Klaus Dona reveals Egyptian like artifacts found in Ecuador; 12,000 years ago! 143 myownmyth 26-Aug-12 02:42
Re: John Anthony West: : GHMB Community Interview --Ask Anything 38 GabrielAPetrie 22-Aug-12 12:04
Re: Serent 37 gulsbo 22-Aug-12 20:47
Re: John Anthony West: : GHMB Community Interview --Ask Anything 45 gulsbo 22-Aug-12 20:51
Re: John Anthony West: : GHMB Community Interview --Ask Anything 46 Titus Livius 24-Aug-12 11:25
Re: John Anthony West: : GHMB Community Interview --Ask Anything 144 richarddullum 24-Aug-12 22:16
Re: John Anthony West: : GHMB Community Interview --Ask Anything 44 leapthenlook 28-Aug-12 00:00
Re: That Egyptian Grafitti 38 Sirius7237 28-Aug-12 00:57
Re: That Egyptian Grafitti 46 Sirius7237 28-Aug-12 00:58
Re: That Egyptian Grafitti 57 carolb 28-Aug-12 02:25
Re: That Egyptian Grafitti 51 Sirius7237 28-Aug-12 03:42
Fixing Time in the Kali Yuga 47 Absolutely Chloe 28-Aug-12 02:07
Questions closing soon 39 lukehancock 28-Aug-12 05:06
Re: Questions closing soon 41 Susan Doris 28-Aug-12 16:12
Re: John Anthony West: : GHMB Community Interview --Ask Anything 37 Cain 28-Aug-12 22:41
Re: John Anthony West: : GHMB Community Interview --Ask Anything 35 Bibhu Dev Misra 29-Aug-12 10:03
Re: John Anthony West: : GHMB Community Interview --Ask Anything 39 cladking 29-Aug-12 16:06
Re: John Anthony West: : GHMB Community Interview --Ask Anything 56 michael seabrook 29-Aug-12 23:58
Questions Closed 35 lukehancock 30-Aug-12 05:16
Answers now live 32 lukehancock 15-Sep-12 20:18
Re: Answers now live 41 Archae Solenhofen 15-Sep-12 21:55
Re: Answers now live 36 cladking 15-Sep-12 22:10
Re: Answers now live 40 richarddullum 16-Sep-12 06:03
Re: Answers now live 38 Archae Solenhofen 16-Sep-12 18:04
Re: Answers now live 41 Sirius7237 16-Sep-12 18:42
before you dearly depart... 31 Absolutely Chloe 16-Sep-12 21:02
Re: before you dearly depart... 40 cladking 16-Sep-12 22:00


Sorry, only registered users may post in this forum.