Mysteries :  The Official GrahamHancock.com forums
For serious discussion of the controversies, approaches and enigmas surrounding the origins and development of the human species and of human civilization. (NB: for more ‘out there’ posts we point you in the direction of the ‘Paranormal & Supernatural’ Message Board). 
Welcome! Log InRegister
Hi Scott,

By now I've had a chance to not only review your powerpoint and past postings, but the various responses to your work. I continue to think that what you have done is truly remarkable--remarkable enough for you to:

1. Realize fully what you have accomplished.

2. Accept the scientific responsibilities that come with your accomplishments.

Let's see if I have this right.

SC: As promised, here are a couple of links to my latest research which demonstrates that the Great Pyramid at Giza encodes a tilt of the Earth's axis c. 10,500BC.

RB: No, you have developed a geometric model which identifies different axes before and after c 10,500BC as measured by precission. One can interpret these axes as corresponding to a substantial change in tilt of the Earth that may have occurred at that time. The date c10,500BC has been associated by many scholars with specific events on Earth that include fire in the sky and cataclismic floods.

In effect, you have a model or theory that connects a possible specific shift in axis associated with these real world events. I think that this constitutes a real breakthrough in clarity and potential testability compared to previous, less detailed models.

Now the responsibility that comes with the accomplishment.

Your model is specific enough to be validated, both internally and externally. For internal validation, you need to identify the tolerances of your measurements, both in degrees and years--often expressed in 90% confidence intervals (+ or -).

For external validation, you need to indicate chronologies of events in various locations and best guess dates for these chronologies. One then measures the statistical association between 1. your predicted angle of tilt and precission date and 2. the location/date of these events.

I'm saying "you" here much as the Queen uses the Royal "we." It does not have to be you, Scott, personally. You can (and should) team with others to test your model externally. I suspect that others will test it even without being asked anyway!

The external validation in particular will transform your speculations into scientific facts once these associations have been established. You will not have to debate most aspects of interpretation, only improve your predictive validity. Most importantly, if the paradigm keepers in one domain of inquiry don't welcome you into their "club," others surely will. That's how you get your mainstream scientist "visa" stamped.

Regards,

Ray


Options: ReplyQuote


Subject Views Written By Posted
Great Pyramid Axial Tilt Theory 464 Scott Creighton 23-Aug-07 01:41
Re: Great Pyramid Axial Tilt Theory 255 Ahatmose 23-Aug-07 03:10
Re: Great Pyramid Axial Tilt Theory 292 Broker 23-Aug-07 04:15
Special Thanks to Gary Osborn 314 Scott Creighton 23-Aug-07 11:20
Re: Special Thanks to Gary Osborn 273 P Mac 23-Aug-07 12:17
Re: Special Thanks to Gary Osborn 324 Scott Creighton 23-Aug-07 19:34
Re: Special Thanks to Gary Osborn 368 Gary Osborn 23-Aug-07 14:10
Re: Special Thanks to Gary Osborn 307 Joyeuse 23-Aug-07 15:28
Re: Special Thanks to Gary Osborn 311 Scott Creighton 23-Aug-07 19:30
Re: Special Thanks to Gary Osborn 280 Joyeuse 23-Aug-07 21:15
Re: Special Thanks to Gary Osborn 335 Joyeuse 23-Aug-07 15:25
Re: Special Thanks to Gary Osborn 287 Gary Osborn 23-Aug-07 15:36
Re: Special Thanks to Gary Osborn 300 Joyeuse 23-Aug-07 16:16
Re: Special Thanks to Gary Osborn 295 Gary Osborn 23-Aug-07 16:22
Re: Special Thanks to Gary Osborn 315 Joyeuse 23-Aug-07 16:45
Re: Special Thanks to Gary Osborn 265 Gary Osborn 23-Aug-07 16:58
Re: Great Pyramid Axial Tilt Theory 270 Scott Creighton 23-Aug-07 19:33
Re: Great Pyramid Axial Tilt Theory 287 Broker 24-Aug-07 02:25
Re: Great Pyramid Axial Tilt Theory 283 Kboldt 23-Aug-07 15:50
Re: Great Pyramid Axial Tilt Theory 250 Gary Osborn 23-Aug-07 16:01
Re: Great Pyramid Axial Tilt Theory 306 Kboldt 23-Aug-07 16:33
Re: Great Pyramid Axial Tilt Theory 290 Gary Osborn 23-Aug-07 20:22
Re: Great Pyramid Axial Tilt Theory 256 Kboldt 23-Aug-07 20:33
Re: Great Pyramid Axial Tilt Theory 216 Dale Robert Lerch 24-Aug-07 08:36
Re: Great Pyramid Axial Tilt Theory 277 P Mac 23-Aug-07 16:49
Re: Great Pyramid Axial Tilt Theory 313 Scott Creighton 23-Aug-07 19:37
Re: Great Pyramid Axial Tilt Theory 309 Gary Osborn 23-Aug-07 20:31
Re: Great Pyramid Axial Tilt Theory 302 Kboldt 23-Aug-07 20:49
Re: Great Pyramid Axial Tilt Theory 322 NetWorkAngel 24-Aug-07 20:54
Re: Great Pyramid Axial Tilt Theory 286 Scott Creighton 24-Aug-07 21:04
Re: Great Pyramid Axial Tilt Theory 176 NetWorkAngel 23-Aug-07 17:10
Re: Great Pyramid Axial Tilt Theory 282 Kboldt 23-Aug-07 17:26
Re: Great Pyramid Axial Tilt Theory 330 P Mac 23-Aug-07 17:35
Re: Great Pyramid Axial Tilt Theory 216 Scott Creighton 23-Aug-07 19:40
Re: Great Pyramid Axial Tilt Theory 257 Gary Osborn 23-Aug-07 20:08
A bit of clarification 270 Jon B 23-Aug-07 17:45
Re: A bit of clarification 228 Scott Creighton 23-Aug-07 20:00
Re: Great Pyramid Axial Tilt Theory 333 Scott Creighton 23-Aug-07 20:50
Re: Great Pyramid Axial Tilt Theory 342 mephisto 23-Aug-07 07:44
Re: Great Pyramid Axial Tilt Theory 259 Scott Creighton 23-Aug-07 20:03
Re: Great Pyramid Axial Tilt Theory 284 Gary Osborn 23-Aug-07 08:20
Re: Great Pyramid Axial Tilt Theory 302 Scott Creighton 23-Aug-07 20:04
Re: Great Pyramid Axial Tilt Theory 283 Gary Osborn 24-Aug-07 10:25
Re: Great Pyramid Axial Tilt Theory 288 Gary Osborn 24-Aug-07 11:13
Re: Great Pyramid Axial Tilt Theory 196 P Mac 24-Aug-07 11:55
Re: Great Pyramid Axial Tilt Theory 301 Gary Osborn 24-Aug-07 13:26
Re: Great Pyramid Axial Tilt Theory 325 Sirfiroth 24-Aug-07 14:52
Re: Great Pyramid Axial Tilt Theory 292 Gary Osborn 24-Aug-07 15:02
Re: Great Pyramid Axial Tilt Theory 301 Sirfiroth 25-Aug-07 03:42
Re: Great Pyramid Axial Tilt Theory 251 Gary Osborn 26-Aug-07 12:21
Re: Great Pyramid Axial Tilt Theory 247 P Mac 24-Aug-07 11:45
Re: Great Pyramid Axial Tilt Theory 274 Gary Osborn 24-Aug-07 12:00
Re: Great Pyramid Axial Tilt Theory 262 magisterchessmutt 24-Aug-07 12:23
Re: Great Pyramid Axial Tilt Theory 310 Gary Osborn 24-Aug-07 14:10
Re: Great Pyramid Axial Tilt Theory 287 Scott Creighton 24-Aug-07 18:21
Re: Great Pyramid Axial Tilt Theory 247 Gary Osborn 24-Aug-07 19:18
Re: Great Pyramid Axial Tilt Theory 319 Ghia 23-Aug-07 08:40
Wow! 398 Ghia 23-Aug-07 09:06
Re: Wow! 323 Scott Creighton 23-Aug-07 20:06
Re: Wow! 309 Jackfrost 24-Aug-07 16:09
Re: Wow! 269 Scott Creighton 24-Aug-07 16:49
Re: Wow! 318 Saravuth 26-Aug-07 02:35
Re: Great Pyramid Axial Tilt Theory 155 Morph 23-Aug-07 09:07
Re: Great Pyramid Axial Tilt Theory 284 Ghia 23-Aug-07 09:12
Re: Great Pyramid Axial Tilt Theory 280 Morph 23-Aug-07 10:25
Re: Great Pyramid Axial Tilt Theory 257 Joyeuse 23-Aug-07 16:58
Re: Great Pyramid Axial Tilt Theory 306 mephisto 23-Aug-07 12:06
Re: Great Pyramid Axial Tilt Theory 357 Ahatmose 23-Aug-07 12:57
Re: Great Pyramid Axial Tilt Theory 304 Spiros 23-Aug-07 09:24
Re: Great Pyramid Axial Tilt Theory 273 Morph 23-Aug-07 13:30
Re: Great Pyramid Axial Tilt Theory 213 Gary Osborn 23-Aug-07 13:54
Re: Great Pyramid Axial Tilt Theory 294 Gary Osborn 23-Aug-07 14:19
Re: Great Pyramid Axial Tilt Theory 317 Morph 23-Aug-07 14:20
Re: Great Pyramid Axial Tilt Theory 288 Ahatmose 23-Aug-07 13:56
Re: Great Pyramid Axial Tilt Theory 286 Sirfiroth 23-Aug-07 13:31
Re: Great Pyramid Axial Tilt Theory 241 Scott Creighton 23-Aug-07 20:09
More fully... 321 Morph 23-Aug-07 13:53
Re: Great Pyramid Axial Tilt Theory 222 Ahatmose 23-Aug-07 14:08
Addendum: Great Pyramid Axial Tilt Theory 236 Ahatmose 23-Aug-07 14:19
Re: Great Pyramid Axial Tilt Theory 291 Gary Osborn 23-Aug-07 23:48
Re: Great Pyramid Axial Tilt Theory 278 Morph 23-Aug-07 14:13
Re: Great Pyramid Axial Tilt Theory 338 drrayeye 23-Aug-07 14:47
Re: Great Pyramid Axial Tilt Theory 277 Scott Creighton 23-Aug-07 20:18
Re: Great Pyramid Axial Tilt Theory 384 drrayeye 24-Aug-07 14:28
Re: Great Pyramid Axial Tilt Theory 270 Joyeuse 23-Aug-07 15:22
Re: Great Pyramid Axial Tilt Theory 291 Ahatmose 23-Aug-07 15:29
Re: Great Pyramid Axial Tilt Theory 249 Joyeuse 23-Aug-07 16:05
Re: Great Pyramid Axial Tilt Theory 325 NetWorkAngel 23-Aug-07 17:16
Re: Great Pyramid Axial Tilt Theory 333 Joyeuse 23-Aug-07 17:39
Re: Great Pyramid Axial Tilt Theory 295 NetWorkAngel 23-Aug-07 17:45
Re: Great Pyramid Axial Tilt Theory 263 Joyeuse 23-Aug-07 17:42
oops pls read "can't" instead of can N/T 315 Joyeuse 23-Aug-07 17:44
Re: Great Pyramid Axial Tilt Theory 267 Scott Creighton 23-Aug-07 21:22
Re: Great Pyramid Axial Tilt Theory 287 Dale Robert Lerch 24-Aug-07 09:06
Re: Great Pyramid Axial Tilt Theory 243 Scott Creighton 24-Aug-07 13:46
Re: Great Pyramid Axial Tilt Theory 231 Joe Atlantis 23-Aug-07 19:25
Re: Great Pyramid Axial Tilt Theory 299 Scott Creighton 23-Aug-07 20:26
Re: Great Pyramid Axial Tilt Theory 320 Warwick 24-Aug-07 17:34
Re: Great Pyramid Axial Tilt Theory 348 Scott Creighton 24-Aug-07 17:42
Re: Great Pyramid Axial Tilt Theory 281 Warwick 24-Aug-07 18:11
Re: Great Pyramid Axial Tilt Theory 308 Kboldt 24-Aug-07 18:23
Re: Great Pyramid Axial Tilt Theory 331 Warwick 24-Aug-07 18:38
Re: Great Pyramid Axial Tilt Theory 321 Scott Creighton 24-Aug-07 18:39
Re: Great Pyramid Axial Tilt Theory 285 Warwick 25-Aug-07 17:21
Re: Great Pyramid Axial Tilt Theory 310 Scott Creighton 25-Aug-07 17:33
Re: Great Pyramid Axial Tilt Theory 277 Warwick 25-Aug-07 17:44
Re: Great Pyramid Axial Tilt Theory 329 Scott Creighton 25-Aug-07 17:57
Re: Great Pyramid Axial Tilt Theory 278 Warwick 26-Aug-07 17:26
Re: Great Pyramid Axial Tilt Theory 300 Broker 26-Aug-07 19:42
Re: Great Pyramid Axial Tilt Theory 260 Scott Creighton 26-Aug-07 20:52
Moderator Note 316 Ghia 26-Aug-07 23:31
Re: Moderator Note 283 Warwick 29-Aug-07 16:49
Re: Moderator Note 329 Ahatmose 29-Aug-07 17:21
Re: Moderator Note 286 Warwick 01-Sep-07 18:28
Re: Great Pyramid Axial Tilt Theory 217 Ahatmose 24-Aug-07 18:42
Re: Great Pyramid Axial Tilt Theory 196 caugusto 24-Aug-07 21:34
Re: Great Pyramid Axial Tilt Theory 262 Warwick 25-Aug-07 17:29
Re: Great Pyramid Axial Tilt Theory 284 Kboldt 24-Aug-07 18:04
Re: Great Pyramid Axial Tilt Theory 281 Gary Osborn 24-Aug-07 18:42
Re: Great Pyramid Axial Tilt Theory 317 Scott Creighton 24-Aug-07 18:49
Re: Great Pyramid Axial Tilt Theory 280 Kboldt 24-Aug-07 19:05
Re: Great Pyramid Axial Tilt Theory 245 Ahatmose 24-Aug-07 19:19
Re: Great Pyramid Axial Tilt Theory 281 Scott Creighton 24-Aug-07 19:29
Re: Great Pyramid Axial Tilt Theory 280 Ahatmose 24-Aug-07 20:16
Re: Great Pyramid Axial Tilt Theory 257 Gary Osborn 24-Aug-07 20:45
Re: Great Pyramid Axial Tilt Theory 316 Scott Creighton 24-Aug-07 20:53
More Chills... 186 Ghia 25-Aug-07 00:21
Re: More Chills... 286 P Mac 25-Aug-07 11:12
Re: More Chills... 262 Scott Creighton 25-Aug-07 12:31
Re: More Chills... 128 P Mac 25-Aug-07 13:30
Re: Great Pyramid Axial Tilt Theory 291 Kboldt 24-Aug-07 19:01
Re: Great Pyramid Axial Tilt Theory 290 Gary Osborn 24-Aug-07 19:29
Re: Great Pyramid Axial Tilt Theory 342 jnisbet 25-Aug-07 01:48
Re: Great Pyramid Axial Tilt Theory 289 Scott Creighton 25-Aug-07 11:00
A shadow beyond the doubt 297 drew 25-Aug-07 03:06
Re: A shadow beyond the doubt 280 jnisbet 25-Aug-07 03:41
Re: A shadow beyond the doubt 326 drew 25-Aug-07 12:43
Re: A shadow beyond the doubt 287 P Mac 25-Aug-07 11:46
Re: Great Pyramid Axial Tilt Theory 286 Saravuth 25-Aug-07 14:34
please explain 262 Spiros 25-Aug-07 14:40
Re: please explain 310 Mr. Hunter 25-Aug-07 15:48
Re: please explain 306 magisterchessmutt 26-Aug-07 00:17
Re: please explain 287 Scott Creighton 25-Aug-07 17:11
the solution? 293 Spiros 25-Aug-07 18:53
Re: the solution? 308 Scott Creighton 25-Aug-07 20:49
Re: the solution? 241 Spiros 25-Aug-07 21:50
Re: the solution? 285 Scott Creighton 25-Aug-07 22:11
Re: the solution? 252 Gary Osborn 26-Aug-07 00:23
Re: the solution? 266 Scott Creighton 26-Aug-07 01:21
Re: the solution? 263 Dale Robert Lerch 26-Aug-07 07:47
Re: the solution? 284 Gary Osborn 30-Aug-07 20:28
Re: the solution? 313 Gary Osborn 26-Aug-07 12:37
Re: the solution? 236 Spiros 27-Aug-07 19:18
Re: the solution? 287 Gary Osborn 27-Aug-07 19:23
Question remains unanswered ... at least to me. 308 Ahatmose 26-Aug-07 02:04
Re: Question remains unanswered ... at least to me. 303 Scott Creighton 26-Aug-07 20:05
Re: Great Pyramid Axial Tilt Theory 309 Scott Creighton 25-Aug-07 17:17
Re: Great Pyramid Axial Tilt Theory 243 magisterchessmutt 26-Aug-07 01:52
Testing and validating the Giza axial tilt theory 358 drrayeye 26-Aug-07 20:29
Re: Testing and validating the Giza axial tilt theory 228 Scott Creighton 27-Aug-07 17:43
Re: Testing and validating the Giza axial tilt theory 311 Ahatmose 27-Aug-07 17:54
Firestone 357 drrayeye 27-Aug-07 20:10
Re: Great Pyramid Axial Tilt Theory 272 Richard Essame 27-Aug-07 02:59
Re: Great Pyramid Axial Tilt Theory 301 Ghia 27-Aug-07 03:12
Re: Great Pyramid Axial Tilt Theory 288 Richard Essame 27-Aug-07 06:38
Re: Great Pyramid Axial Tilt Theory 236 magisterchessmutt 27-Aug-07 05:00
Re: Great Pyramid Axial Tilt Theory 285 Richard Essame 27-Aug-07 06:04
Re: Great Pyramid Axial Tilt Theory 301 magisterchessmutt 27-Aug-07 06:24
Re: Great Pyramid Axial Tilt Theory 294 Richard Essame 27-Aug-07 07:12
Re: Great Pyramid Axial Tilt Theory 307 Ahatmose 27-Aug-07 14:19
Re: Great Pyramid Axial Tilt Theory 296 Scott Creighton 27-Aug-07 14:51
Re: Great Pyramid Axial Tilt Theory 315 Ahatmose 27-Aug-07 16:02
Addendum ... 327 Ahatmose 27-Aug-07 16:31
Re: Addendum ... 305 Scott Creighton 27-Aug-07 16:49
Re: Addendum ... 269 Ahatmose 27-Aug-07 17:00
Re: Addendum ... 307 Scott Creighton 27-Aug-07 17:30
Re: Great Pyramid Axial Tilt Theory 286 Richard Essame 27-Aug-07 19:28
This may help, Don 280 Cesar 27-Aug-07 22:18
Re: This may help, Don 286 Ghia 27-Aug-07 23:40
Re: This may help, Don 280 Scott Creighton 27-Aug-07 23:59
Re: This may help, Don 299 Cesar 28-Aug-07 02:40
Re: This may help, Don 268 Sirfiroth 28-Aug-07 02:51
Re: This may help, Don 277 Cesar 28-Aug-07 04:12
Re: This may help, Don 326 Sirfiroth 28-Aug-07 05:29
Re: This may help, Don 296 Ahatmose 28-Aug-07 02:15
Re: This may help, Don 329 Cesar 28-Aug-07 04:12
Re: This may help, Don 370 Scott Creighton 28-Aug-07 10:56
Re: This may help, Don 275 Cesar 28-Aug-07 21:44
The Impactor 243 Scott Creighton 28-Aug-07 22:17
Re: This may help, Don 223 Scott Creighton 29-Aug-07 11:38
Intriguing 331 Cesar 01-Sep-07 12:03
Re: Great Pyramid Axial Tilt Theory 342 LonelyAngel 27-Aug-07 18:37
Re: Great Pyramid Axial Tilt Theory 324 Scott Creighton 27-Aug-07 18:44
Re: Great Pyramid Axial Tilt Theory 332 LonelyAngel 28-Aug-07 17:57
Re: Great Pyramid Axial Tilt Theory 283 Deep1 28-Aug-07 18:52
Re: Great Pyramid Axial Tilt Theory 254 LonelyAngel 29-Aug-07 20:38
Re: Great Pyramid Axial Tilt Theory 266 Deep1 29-Aug-07 20:59
Re: Great Pyramid Axial Tilt Theory 296 Ahatmose 29-Aug-07 21:23
Re: Great Pyramid Axial Tilt Theory 264 LonelyAngel 30-Aug-07 16:24
Re: Great Pyramid Axial Tilt Theory 311 Scott Creighton 30-Aug-07 17:02
Re: Great Pyramid Axial Tilt Theory 287 LonelyAngel 30-Aug-07 17:43
Re: Great Pyramid Axial Tilt Theory 248 Gary Osborn 30-Aug-07 20:01
Re: Great Pyramid Axial Tilt Theory 292 Scott Creighton 30-Aug-07 21:17
Re: Great Pyramid Axial Tilt Theory 290 Gary Osborn 30-Aug-07 21:44
Re: Great Pyramid Axial Tilt Theory 270 LonelyAngel 30-Aug-07 21:57
Re: Great Pyramid Axial Tilt Theory 294 Gary Osborn 30-Aug-07 23:40
Re: Great Pyramid Axial Tilt Theory 302 Morph 31-Aug-07 11:39
Re: Great Pyramid Axial Tilt Theory 289 Scott Creighton 28-Aug-07 18:55
One major problem as I see it ... 262 Ahatmose 28-Aug-07 23:07
Re: One major problem as I see it ... 310 P Mac 29-Aug-07 00:02
Re: One major problem as I see it ... 238 magisterchessmutt 29-Aug-07 00:25
Re: One major problem as I see it ... 315 Richard Essame 29-Aug-07 00:33
Re: One major problem as I see it ... 305 Ahatmose 29-Aug-07 02:39
Re: One major problem as I see it ... 306 Richard Essame 29-Aug-07 03:04
Re: One major problem as I see it ... 344 Ahatmose 29-Aug-07 03:15
Re: One major problem as I see it ... 283 Richard Essame 29-Aug-07 05:24
Re: One major problem as I see it ... 234 Cesar 29-Aug-07 02:21
Re: One major problem as I see it ... 295 caugusto 29-Aug-07 04:40
Re: One major Solution? 291 Scott Creighton 29-Aug-07 09:56
Re: One major Solution? 349 Ahatmose 29-Aug-07 17:47
Re: One major Solution? 262 Richard Essame 30-Aug-07 00:16
Re: One major Solution? 296 Richard Essame 30-Aug-07 19:24
Re: One major Solution? 323 P Mac 31-Aug-07 12:44
Re: One major Solution? 277 Richard Essame 31-Aug-07 23:39
Re: One major Solution? 282 Scott Creighton 01-Sep-07 10:25
Re: One major Solution? 251 P Mac 01-Sep-07 16:13
Re: One major Solution? 297 P Mac 02-Sep-07 00:23
Re: One major Solution? 285 Ahatmose 02-Sep-07 01:50
Or another solution... 314 drew 29-Aug-07 21:35
Re: Or another solution... 251 Jackfrost 30-Aug-07 15:46
Re: Or another solution... 246 P Mac 30-Aug-07 16:39
Re: Or another solution... 283 Jackfrost 31-Aug-07 10:55
Re: Or another solution... 312 P Mac 31-Aug-07 16:01
Re: Or another solution... 317 Richard Essame 01-Sep-07 01:57


Sorry, only registered users may post in this forum.