Mysteries :  The Official GrahamHancock.com forums
For serious discussion of the controversies, approaches and enigmas surrounding the origins and development of the human species and of human civilization. (NB: for more ‘out there’ posts we point you in the direction of the ‘Paranormal & Supernatural’ Message Board). 
Welcome! Log InRegister
Nice selective quotation. You've learned well from your models.

Anyway, Christophe Leijnen wrote:

> If H O is proven untrue (significantly) then one can reject
> HO and except H A, and viceversa. One cannot prove H O or H
> A, so neither hypothesis can be rejected. Untill one is
> proven to be true or untrue.

The basic problem with your reasoning is that history, really, cannot "prove" things to be untrue. If no evidence exists, one can always say (as Hancock and you do) that it might yet turn up. There is always possibility.

Using your methods, which are statistical and not historical, anything and everything are possible in history, hence my reductio ad absurdum example. If historical hypotheses have no evidence whatsoever to support them, there is no way to distinguish between the possibilities of Weslh unicorns, alien pyramid builders or lost civilizations. No evidence exists for any, so they are alike untestable.

GF

Options: ReplyQuote


Subject Views Written By Posted
a typical response of mr. Fagan 408 Christophe Leijnen 30-Nov-00 18:51
same message as above (sorry) 206 Christophe L. 30-Nov-00 19:03
RE: a typical response of mr. Fagan 221 Garrett Fagan 01-Dec-00 00:12
RE: a typical response of mr. Fagan 302 Geoff Stocks 01-Dec-00 02:38
RE: a typical response of mr. Fagan 181 Dr E 01-Dec-00 12:11
RE: a typical response of mr. Fagan 176 Geoff Stocks 01-Dec-00 20:43
RE: a typical response of mr. Fagan 228 Christophe L. 01-Dec-00 11:12
RE: a typical response of mr. Fagan 215 Garrett Fagan 01-Dec-00 20:38
RE: a typical response of mr. Fagan 211 R. Avry Wilson 01-Dec-00 13:25
RE: a typical response of mr. Fagan 189 Garrett Fagan 01-Dec-00 20:43
RE: a typical response of mr. Fagan 200 Geoff Stocks 01-Dec-00 20:47


Sorry, only registered users may post in this forum.