Mysteries :  The Official GrahamHancock.com forums
For serious discussion of the controversies, approaches and enigmas surrounding the origins and development of the human species and of human civilization. (NB: for more ‘out there’ posts we point you in the direction of the ‘Paranormal & Supernatural’ Message Board). 
Welcome! Log InRegister
Graham,

Perhaps Garrett would agree to edited highlights of your private discussions that pertain directly to C14 dating? (the editing process agreed upon by both of you - thus maintaining an editorial control over publication)

Open debate can be heated enough BUT private debates in my experience are even worse and can include very colourful language and colourful accusations which I suppose is undesirable on this message board considering recent sentiments of the message board readers.

Perhaps in a few private emails you can thrash out an agreement on what should be included and what should not be included. This way the C14 debate can have a basis for continuation. Perhaps you could even include an agreed upon third party in order to oversee the process and guarantee that both sides are fairly treated.

If Garrett does not agree to this then I would still understand. Private email is intended to be exactly that. But perhaps his concerns over his privacy can be dealt with by agreement over the content of publication.

Options: ReplyQuote


Subject Views Written By Posted
Debate 394 Garrett Fagan 29-Nov-00 22:05
RE: Debate 283 Graham Hancock 30-Nov-00 01:37
RE: Debate 179 Geoff Stocks 30-Nov-00 01:56
RE: Debate 182 jameske 30-Nov-00 03:39
RE: Debate 169 Garrett Fagan 30-Nov-00 04:04
RE: Debate 199 Graham Hancock 30-Nov-00 11:32
RE: Debate 169 Dr E 30-Nov-00 11:52
WEAR SPECTACLES 169 Bryan 30-Nov-00 12:56
RE: WEAR SPECTACLES 161 Sharif 30-Nov-00 13:16
RE: WEAR SPECTACLES 178 Dr E 30-Nov-00 13:59
RE: WEAR SPECTACLES 230 Bryan 30-Nov-00 15:18
RE: WEAR SPECTACLES 153 Dr E 30-Nov-00 18:04
RE: Debate 210 Mark 30-Nov-00 09:57
RE: Debate 141 Geoff Stocks 30-Nov-00 19:54
RE: Debate 170 jameske 30-Nov-00 01:53


Sorry, only registered users may post in this forum.