Mysteries :  The Official GrahamHancock.com forums
For serious discussion of the controversies, approaches and enigmas surrounding the origins and development of the human species and of human civilization. (NB: for more ‘out there’ posts we point you in the direction of the ‘Paranormal & Supernatural’ Message Board). 
Welcome! Log InRegister
Garrett,

This sounds to me like an admission of complete defeat in response to the challenge on C14 dating. Unfortunately rather than respond to your detailed argument in support of this technique Graham appears to think he can divert attention by dragging up personal emails from over a year ago.

Nice try Graham but I think the fight didn't even last the distance. A knockout blow to Garrett in the first round methinks.

Best,

CSICOP

Options: ReplyQuote


Subject Views Written By Posted
Hancock's Challenge: A Response 486 Garrett Fagan 27-Nov-00 22:34
C-14 an academic joke!! 173 William John Meegan 27-Nov-00 23:52
RE: C-14 an academic joke!! 173 Garrett Fagan 28-Nov-00 00:05
RE: C-14 an academic joke!! 172 Garrett Fagan 28-Nov-00 00:11
Be more inventive than that: PLEASE 166 William John Meegan 28-Nov-00 00:55
RE: C-14 an academic joke!! 174 William John Meegan 28-Nov-00 00:50
RE: C-14 an academic joke!! 166 jameske 28-Nov-00 00:23
RE: C-14 an academic joke!! 174 oziris 28-Nov-00 02:10
RE: C-14 an academic joke!! 154 Bryan 28-Nov-00 02:18
RE: C-14 an academic joke!! 177 Brian A 28-Nov-00 14:50
RE: C-14 an academic joke!! 168 Bryan 28-Nov-00 14:58
RE: C-14 an academic joke!! 182 Brian A 28-Nov-00 14:48
To Brian 159 William John Meegan 28-Nov-00 15:35
RE: WJ Meegans sanity 164 CSICOPdivision2 28-Nov-00 16:53
CSICOP is a very rude child: a cry baby 127 William John Meegan 28-Nov-00 17:26
RE: CSICOP is a very rude child: a cry baby 159 Bryan 29-Nov-00 02:19
RE: To Brian 206 Brian A 29-Nov-00 17:41
To Brian: THE KABBALISTIC QUEST 201 William John Meegan 01-Dec-00 01:57
RE: Hancock's Challenge: A Response 208 Graham Hancock 28-Nov-00 02:24
RE: Hancock The Underdog 133 Mark 28-Nov-00 11:42
RE: Hancock's Challenge: A Response 171 Garrett Fagan 28-Nov-00 16:10
RE: Hancock's Challenge: A Response 211 Graham Hancock 28-Nov-00 19:10
RE: Hancock's Challenge: A Response 129 laura 28-Nov-00 21:27
RE: Hancock's Challenge: A Response 140 CSICOP 29-Nov-00 09:29
RE: Hancock's Challenge: A Response 214 Graham Hancock 29-Nov-00 10:37
RE: Hancock's Challenge: A Response 159 Garrett Fagan 29-Nov-00 15:02
RE: Hancock's Challenge: A Response 181 Graham Hancock 29-Nov-00 15:51
RE: Hancock's Challenge: A Response 162 Pilgrim333 28-Nov-00 05:22
RE: Hancock's Challenge: A Response 191 Sky 29-Nov-00 17:24
RE: Hancock's Challenge: A Response 165 Robert G. Bauval 28-Nov-00 07:40
RE: Hancock's Challenge: A Response 156 Christophe Leijnen 28-Nov-00 11:08
RE: Hancock's Challenge: A Response 162 R. Avry Wilson 28-Nov-00 11:55
RE: Hancock's Challenge: A Response 145 Mark 28-Nov-00 12:41
RE: Hancock's Challenge: A Response 167 R. Avry Wilson 28-Nov-00 13:43
RE: Hancock's Challenge: A Response 166 Mark 28-Nov-00 13:49
RE: Hancock's Challenge: A Response 178 Pilgrim333 29-Nov-00 01:12
RE: Hancock's Challenge: A Response 156 Garrett Fagan 29-Nov-00 15:49
RE: Hancock's Challenge: A Response 208 R. Avry Wilson 29-Nov-00 11:18


Sorry, only registered users may post in this forum.