Mysteries :  The Official GrahamHancock.com forums
For serious discussion of the controversies, approaches and enigmas surrounding the origins and development of the human species and of human civilization. (NB: for more ‘out there’ posts we point you in the direction of the ‘Paranormal & Supernatural’ Message Board). 
I will be first to admit that Sitchin is suspect in some of his historical assay..allong with interperetation of script.

Yet..the chapter....' Forging the Pharaohs name'..in his book..'The Stairway to Heaven' is laid out reasonably.

have read a few accounts by third party's who explain what critics of this period were really saying.

they try to explain Birches suspiscions..Gardiners...others.

spin exists..to defer the accounts of suspiscion..to make their comments actually support Vyse in the end.

Myself..have a gut feeling Vyse did commit fraud.

its the flow of information..the info Vyse recorded in journals..and the time element attached.

how suspiscious is it when others have been inside pyramids..found nothing in the way of confirmation script...
then Vyse appears in a time period of competition and public fame...and finds confirmatory script...in 3 pyramids.

Vyse is hailed for his second discovery..promoted to rank of general....
then amazingly Vyse and Perring produce Pharaoh Zosers name ..of course...written in Red Paint.

The timing of the Red Paint cartouche script..with the appearence and accessability of Vyse and Perring to notaries of the day...
with the script error matching exactly the script errors in the recent or period Egyptian script books is highly suspiscious.

several individuals back in England baulked immediately at the script conveyance..allong with time marker allotment connected to claimed bones and coffin remains.

I reread ' Forging the Pharaohs name' several times....

the revelations..being produced in certain time intervals.in connection to ongoing projects by others...hints that Vyse was time managing his endplay.

for me..the one damming aspect is the direction of several of the cartouches...they are made directionally..as per the limitation of the script writters reach..and make no sense..in regards to a Pharoah who wishes to convey his ownership...nor a scribe of the period assigned to do so properly.

the script appears...incorrect in form...positionally out of sync in handling as per origen.

in one case...the vault is blown open...and script occurs at the far end of the vault...and is directionally inconsistant.

Sitchin may be way off the mark on much of his discourse as per Humanities conveyance of all things ancient...

yet his slueth workings in Stairway to Heaven are reasonable..and point form..forward and back the suspiscion that Vyse commited fraud.

what views have you on this?

Brad

Options: ReplyQuote


Subject Views Written By Posted
Did Col Vyse commit fraud? 1 Thunderbird 08/04/2003 03:48PM
Life is strange.... 1 jeff7 08/04/2003 05:13PM
Re: Life is strange.... 0 Zosimos 08/04/2003 09:41PM
Re: Ra-ufu...Snafu! 0 Thunderbird 08/05/2003 10:39PM
Re: Ra-ufu...Snafu! 0 Nejc 08/06/2003 10:16PM
Re: Ra-ufu...Snafu! 0 Nejc 08/08/2003 06:35AM
C14-dating 1 G. VDC 08/04/2003 11:07PM
Re: Whats Hawass doing!! 0 Thunderbird 08/05/2003 03:15PM
Re: Whats Hawass doing!! 0 Nejc 08/06/2003 07:29PM
Re: Whats Hawass doing!! 0 warhammer 08/19/2003 03:39AM
Re: Did Col Vyse commit fraud? 1 ken b 08/05/2003 12:16AM
Re: Did Col Vyse commit fraud? 1 Jerome 08/05/2003 04:06AM
Re: Did Col Vyse commit fraud? 0 lotuskid 08/09/2003 05:25AM
Re: Did Col Vyse commit fraud? 0 Atlantida 08/09/2003 05:48PM
Re: Did Col Vyse commit fraud? 1 lotuskid 08/09/2003 09:09PM


Sorry, only registered users may post in this forum.