Mysteries :  The Official GrahamHancock.com forums
For serious discussion of the controversies, approaches and enigmas surrounding the origins and development of the human species and of human civilization. (NB: for more ‘out there’ posts we point you in the direction of the ‘Paranormal & Supernatural’ Message Board). 
Welcome! Log InRegister
Manu Wrote:
-------------------------------------------------------
> Your 875.043 inch figure, which you derive from
> √π x 432,000 in your proposed premeditated
> design principle, is composed of the following sum
> of distances obtained from the filleted chamber:
>
> 230.4 inch + 412.143 inch + 232.5 inch.
>
> The 232.5 inch figure you got from the 2 inch
> variation of the K.C. roof above ground level.
>
> This is a good model, and I mean that, because it
> is easy to falsify. The 2 inch variation is not by
> design. I refer you, for example to
> [url=http://www.ronaldbirdsall.com/gizeh/petrie/ph
> oto/plate13.html]Plate 13, Petrie[/url], but the
> much better graphic is on page 113 of [i]The Great
> Pyramid: 2590 BC onwards. Operation
> Manual[/i](2019). Franck Monnier and David
> Lightbody. Somerset, UK: Haynes Publishing.
>
> Without the author's permission, I cannot post a
> photo of the illustration, but let me describe it
> for you at least: The mid section of the south
> wall is foreshortened by 5.4 cm due to sagging of
> the granite relative to the False Floor, the
> southeast corner is sagging by 3.3 cm at the base
> and the ceiling immediately above sags by 1.7 cm,
> the southwest corner sags by 3 cm at the base; all
> due to sinking. This caused rafter fissuring and
> cracks on the south side of the ceiling and south
> wall. This damage prompted the making of a canal
> leading to Davidson's chamber and whoever made
> that canal knew where the granite rafters were,
> because they were avoided. That means the damage
> occurred at the time of the construction of the
> Great Pyramid.
>
> All this means that your reverse engineering of π
> back to 875.043 won't work. You will have to
> settle for an error margin and abandon fractional
> inch.

Ok i get what your saying, and i was pushing the the boat out on the 875.043" measure, but in my opinion there is no reason why they could not have purposely designed it to read 875.14" giving the sqrt of Pi at 22/7 in that equation.

Of course it's a reversed sum, but it fits within the margin of error for those stated findings of Petrie in that it holds to the possibility that it could be a design intention , and no i won't abandon working with the inch as that unit has been found to correlate to units used in the Indus Valley of the period the great pyramid was built. are you suggesting i use the same units from the Rhind mathematical papyrus and others that are dated to be some Two Thousand years after the great pyramid was built.

Again, we just don't have enough evidence to say they didn't use a unit equivalent to our modern inch , a lot of stuff can go missing in two thousand years.

DPP

Options: ReplyQuote


Subject Views Written By Posted
G1 Sarcophagus and Phi 701 gjb 07-Jul-20 06:00
Re: G1 Sarcophagus and Phi 78 Dr. Troglodyte 07-Jul-20 20:14
Re: G1 Sarcophagus and Phi 50 thinkitover 07-Jul-20 22:02
Re: G1 Sarcophagus and Phi 65 gjb 07-Jul-20 22:37
Re: G1 Sarcophagus and Phi 55 Dr. Troglodyte 08-Jul-20 17:29
Re: G1 Sarcophagus and Phi 30 spaceyhippie 17-Jul-20 19:17
Re: G1 Sarcophagus and Phi 25 thinkitover 18-Jul-20 20:15
Re: G1 Sarcophagus and Phi 37 Mercurial 19-Jul-20 07:55
Re: G1 Sarcophagus and Phi 25 thinkitover 20-Jul-20 02:20
Re: G1 Sarcophagus and Phi 22 Mercurial 23-Jul-20 11:04
Re: G1 Sarcophagus and Phi 17 molder 23-Jul-20 22:16
Re: G1 Sarcophagus and Phi 12 Mercurial 25-Jul-20 18:15
Re: G1 Sarcophagus and Phi 29 thinkitover 23-Jul-20 22:20
Re: G1 Sarcophagus and Phi 14 Mercurial 25-Jul-20 18:25
Re: G1 Sarcophagus and Phi 55 gjb 23-Jul-20 14:47
Re: G1 Sarcophagus and Phi 28 Mercurial 25-Jul-20 18:32
Re: G1 Sarcophagus and Phi 34 gjb 26-Jul-20 02:01
Re: G1 Sarcophagus and Phi 18 Mercurial 27-Jul-20 07:22
Re: G1 Sarcophagus and Phi 13 thinkitover 27-Jul-20 09:51
The Implications of Approximating Phi 22 thinkitover 26-Jul-20 01:39
Re: The Implications of Approximating Phi 21 Mercurial 27-Jul-20 11:06
Re: The Implications of Approximating Phi 32 thinkitover 27-Jul-20 22:10
Re: G1 Sarcophagus and Phi 41 Manu 10-Jul-20 01:10
Re: G1 Sarcophagus and Phi 39 Dr. Troglodyte 10-Jul-20 20:29
Re: G1 Sarcophagus and Phi 34 DUNE 10-Jul-20 21:25
Re: G1 Sarcophagus and Phi 45 Manu 10-Jul-20 21:58
Re: G1 Sarcophagus and Phi 27 thinkitover 10-Jul-20 23:57
Re: G1 Sarcophagus and Phi 29 PB Bytes 15-Jul-20 14:23
A sketch comparison 30 PB Bytes 15-Jul-20 15:34
Re: G1 Sarcophagus and Phi 34 Dr. Troglodyte 11-Jul-20 15:36
Re: G1 Sarcophagus and Phi 31 Manu 11-Jul-20 16:31
Re: Why is the Kings Chamber the shape it is 39 DUNE 11-Jul-20 17:52
Re: Why is the Kings Chamber the shape it is 30 Manu 11-Jul-20 18:35
Re: Why is the Kings Chamber the shape it is 32 DUNE 11-Jul-20 19:25
Re: Why is the Kings Chamber the shape it is 35 Manu 11-Jul-20 20:17
Re: Why is the Kings Chamber the shape it is 34 thinkitover 11-Jul-20 22:28
Re: Subterranean Chamber 39 molder 13-Jul-20 21:59
Re: Why is the Kings Chamber the shape it is 31 SandyJesse 16-Jul-20 21:32
Re: Why is the Kings Chamber the shape it is 29 DUNE 16-Jul-20 22:08
Re: G1 Sarcophagus and Phi 25 PB Bytes 15-Jul-20 04:04
Re: G1 Sarcophagus and Phi 32 PB Bytes 14-Jul-20 04:59
Re: G1 Sarcophagus and Phi 47 DUNE 14-Jul-20 10:25
Re: G1 Sarcophagus and Phi 47 thinkitover 07-Jul-20 21:09
Coffer Overlapped Edges 46 Dr. Troglodyte 08-Jul-20 17:36
Re: Coffer Overlapped Edges 52 gjb 08-Jul-20 23:41
Re:Height of coffer and relationship with pyramid height. 45 molder 09-Jul-20 11:28
Re: Re:Height of coffer and relationship with pyramid height. 49 Sirfiroth 09-Jul-20 17:21
Re: Re:Height of coffer and relationship with pyramid height. 36 DUNE 09-Jul-20 18:26
Re: Re:Height of coffer and relationship with pyramid height. 30 Sirfiroth 09-Jul-20 20:01
Re: Re:Height of coffer and relationship with pyramid height. 37 DUNE 09-Jul-20 22:25
Re: Re:Height of coffer and relationship with pyramid height. 36 Manu 10-Jul-20 00:10
Re: Re:Height of coffer and relationship with pyramid height. 42 gjb 09-Jul-20 18:40
Re: Re:Height of coffer and relationship with pyramid height. 26 Sirfiroth 09-Jul-20 20:48
Re: Re:Height of coffer and relationship with pyramid height. 39 thinkitover 09-Jul-20 20:24
Re: Re:Height of coffer and relationship with pyramid height. 32 gjb 09-Jul-20 22:57
Re: Re:Height of coffer and relationship with pyramid height. 36 Sirfiroth 10-Jul-20 01:36
Re: Re:Height of coffer and relationship with pyramid height. 24 thinkitover 10-Jul-20 19:56
Re: Re:Height of coffer and relationship with pyramid height. 25 Sirfiroth 11-Jul-20 00:25
Re: Re:Height of coffer and relationship with pyramid height. 29 molder 09-Jul-20 22:06
Re: Re:Height of coffer and relationship with pyramid height. 32 DUNE 10-Jul-20 11:06
Reality 36 Sirfiroth 10-Jul-20 14:05
Re: Reality 32 DUNE 10-Jul-20 17:16
Re: Reality 26 Sirfiroth 10-Jul-20 18:26
Re: Re:Height of coffer and relationship with pyramid height. 38 SandyJesse 09-Jul-20 21:54
Re: Coffer Overlapped Edges 39 Dr. Troglodyte 09-Jul-20 20:56
Re: Coffer Overlapped Edges 43 gjb 09-Jul-20 22:14
Re: Coffer Overlapped Edges 43 Dr. Troglodyte 09-Jul-20 22:56
Do They Need To Overlap? 43 thinkitover 10-Jul-20 01:33
I Might Also Note 31 thinkitover 10-Jul-20 03:31
Re: Do They Need To Overlap? 31 Dr. Troglodyte 10-Jul-20 22:54
Re: Second and Third pyramid coffers 32 molder 11-Jul-20 00:04
Re: Second and Third pyramid coffers 44 gjb 11-Jul-20 02:40
Re: Second and Third pyramid coffers 39 molder 11-Jul-20 10:56
Re: Second and Third pyramid coffers 37 gjb 12-Jul-20 00:48
Re: What was the intended size of the sarcophagus 46 DUNE 12-Jul-20 11:52
Re: What was the intended size of the sarcophagus 35 DUNE 12-Jul-20 18:42
Re: Solution. 26 molder 12-Jul-20 22:03
Re: What was the intended size of the sarcophagus 34 thinkitover 12-Jul-20 22:22
Re: G1 Sarcophagus and Phi 43 Manu 11-Jul-20 01:13
Re: G1 Sarcophagus and Phi 35 Manu 11-Jul-20 01:49
Re: G1 Sarcophagus and Phi 35 Sirfiroth 11-Jul-20 20:23
Re: G1 Sarcophagus and Phi 38 Manu 11-Jul-20 21:45
Re: G1 Numbers of importance 32 molder 11-Jul-20 22:32
Re: G1 Sarcophagus and Phi 24 Sirfiroth 13-Jul-20 19:53
Re: G1 Sarcophagus and Phi 23 thinkitover 13-Jul-20 20:09
Re: G1 Sarcophagus and Phi 20 Sirfiroth 13-Jul-20 20:52
Re: G1 Sarcophagus and Phi 27 thinkitover 11-Jul-20 22:45
Re: G1 Sarcophagus and Phi 29 PB Bytes 15-Jul-20 04:31
Re: G2's Sarcophagus 41 DUNE 15-Jul-20 10:18
Re: G2's Sarcophagus 26 thinkitover 17-Jul-20 07:42
Re: G2's Sarcophagus 22 DUNE 17-Jul-20 08:10
Re: G2's Sarcophagus 29 DUNE 17-Jul-20 09:06
Re: G2's Sarcophagus 30 thinkitover 17-Jul-20 19:45
Re: G1 Sarcophagus and Phi 28 thinkitover 17-Jul-20 08:01
Re: G1 Sarcophagus and Phi 23 PB Bytes 17-Jul-20 15:47
Re: G2's Sarcophagus , it's inner volume, Petrie 27 DUNE 17-Jul-20 16:24
Re: G2's Sarcophagus , it's inner volume, Petrie 20 PB Bytes 17-Jul-20 17:08
Re: G2's Sarcophagus , it's inner volume, Petrie 22 PB Bytes 17-Jul-20 17:09
Re: G2's Sarcophagus , it's inner volume, Petrie 24 DUNE 17-Jul-20 17:26
Re: G2's Sarcophagus , it's inner volume, Petrie 25 molder 18-Jul-20 00:08
Re: G2's Sarcophagus , it's inner volume, Petrie 28 DUNE 18-Jul-20 07:28
Re: G2's Sarcophagus , it's inner volume, Petrie 26 molder 18-Jul-20 22:07
Re: G2's Sarcophagus , it's inner volume, Petrie 25 DUNE 19-Jul-20 09:03
Re: G2's Sarcophagus , it's inner volume, Petrie 23 molder 19-Jul-20 12:31
Re: G2's Sarcophagus , it's inner volume, Petrie 37 DUNE 19-Jul-20 14:16
Re: G2's Sarcophagus , it's inner volume, Petrie 22 molder 20-Jul-20 07:37
Re: G2's Sarcophagus , it's inner volume, Petrie 38 DUNE 20-Jul-20 09:50
Re: G2's Sarcophagus , it's inner volume, Petrie 31 SandyJesse 21-Jul-20 22:09
Re: G2's Sarcophagus , it's inner volume, Petrie 27 thinkitover 22-Jul-20 06:04
for the spiritual contemplation of those who are esteemed worthy to understand? 28 Mercurial 25-Jul-20 08:47
The Root of the OP 40 gjb 13-Jul-20 10:21
Re: The Root of the OP 29 thinkitover 13-Jul-20 20:59
"Blueprint" (fixed) 39 thinkitover 13-Jul-20 21:12
What Am I Bid For This Lovely Cubit? (fixed) 38 thinkitover 14-Jul-20 03:51
Re: "Blueprint" (fixed) 65 gjb 17-Jul-20 09:41
Re: "Blueprint" (fixed) 33 DUNE 17-Jul-20 10:08
Re: "Blueprint" (fixed) 25 thinkitover 17-Jul-20 21:09
Re: "Blueprint" (fixed) 23 DUNE 17-Jul-20 22:08
Re: "Blueprint" (fixed) 37 thinkitover 18-Jul-20 01:18
Re: "Blueprint" (fixed) 26 thinkitover 18-Jul-20 07:33
Re: "Blueprint" (fixed) 28 gjb 18-Jul-20 13:05
Re: "Blueprint" (fixed) 18 thinkitover 18-Jul-20 19:53
Re: "Blueprint" (fixed) 26 thinkitover 18-Jul-20 04:33
Re: "Blueprint" (fixed) 71 gjb 17-Jul-20 11:05
Re: G1 Sarcophagus and Piazzi Smyth 34 M. J. Thomas 16-Jul-20 16:30
Back to the Drawing Board 33 gjb 19-Jul-20 22:02
Re: Back to the Drawing Board 22 gjb 20-Jul-20 04:11
Re: Back to the Drawing Board 24 thinkitover 20-Jul-20 04:44
Tallying Error? 23 gjb 20-Jul-20 09:21


Sorry, only registered users may post in this forum.