Mysteries :  The Official GrahamHancock.com forums
For serious discussion of the controversies, approaches and enigmas surrounding the origins and development of the human species and of human civilization. (NB: for more ‘out there’ posts we point you in the direction of the ‘Paranormal & Supernatural’ Message Board). 
Welcome! Log InRegister
MDaines Wrote:
-------------------------------------------------------
> It was your statement about Harran being founded
> in the late 3rd millennium that needed
> substantiating – which I notice you have now
> backpedalled on.

Revising my earlier comment by a few centuries in light of more accurate information is hardly the stuff of "backpeddling", and regardless has no bearing on the point being made. Information I found of my own volition and offered voluntarily mind you. References that apparently do not rely on the Ebla tablets place the foundation of Harran at the end of the 3rd millennium and curiously newer sources still, like Graham, for some reason, ignore the Ebla tablets and cite the first mention of Harran in ancient texts being c. 2000BC as well. My interest is low regardless and no matter as the period offered by the archaeology for the founding of Harran at 2600-2400BC is just as well and accommodates the Ebla tablets.

> Perhaps because people travelled and traded, and
> Harran was a crossroads, a well-known trade
> route…. oh, I already said that, didn’t I?

But to the Egyptians...? Why and if so surely there must be some contemporary evidence to support this being true? Yes, it was a "crossroads", but at this time in particular for the Mediterranean and the Levant to Mesopotamia and Anatolia. Whatever connection between Egypt and the Harran area during the pyramid age (or earlier) would more than likely be indirect through Byblos by sea and southern Palestine by land- both proxies for a further connection with Northern Syria, which would include Ebla mind you.

In the 1st Dynasty in particular, for example, trade relations with Syria-Palestine are abundant. A relationship that abruptly ended at the end of the 1st Dynasty, but was apparently reestablished at the end of the 2nd Dynasty under Khasekhemwy. Before this even, pottery from northern Syria is found at Buto dating to the predynastic period. Of a more relevant note here is that artifacts with the catouches of Khafre and Pepi I were found at Ebla and Ebla is well attested in later times in Egypt.

Regardless, the Ubaid had a significant presence in Syria since nearly 6,000BC. Both waves of Uruk expansion in the 4th millennium pressed into Syria as well establishing and rejuvenating (preexisting Ubaid sites) several outposts there.


There is no evidence the AE came this far north and the connections between the two were by way of intermediary sites as I said throughout the greater Levant or as I (and others) have argued by way of Mesopotamians coming to Egypt from these outposts and perhaps around the Arabian Peninsula. As I have noted before, there is evidence of early Dynastic and Old Kingdom trade between Egypt and Anatolia though, again, it stands to reason this was indirect by way of the Levant.

> It seems to me that your desire for an
> impenetrable border between the two regions from
> 3000 BC until 700 BC is by far the greatest
> stretch - to what end?

This is nonsense. Even a cursory familiarity with my work says the exact opposite which I am focused on nothing greater than establishing these very connections. What I will not do, however, is make unwarranted leaps of faith to make connections that are not actually there to satisfy some "novel" idea I think I may have. If you want to make some connection between Egypt and Harran in the pyramid age, best of luck to you but for now the trail ends in the greater Levant.

> I don't know. As for the
> Sabians, once again and as you must have read, it
> was the result of my own translating that leads me
> to believe they were indeed around as early as
> 2600 BC.

Unless I missed something, what you said is that you believe you have found evidence of Harran, not the "Sabians", dating to this time:

Quote

The Sumerian name in full comprising three symbols, HAR-RA-AN, is attested from around 2500 BC and given as ‘route, passage, path’, a description that corresponds well. I have found meanings pertaining to commerce and financial operations connected to the name at around 3000 BC.

This is the stretch-equating the Sabians and Harran of the 3rd millennium as being one and the same. You seemed to agree with the wisdom of this so I am not sure what set you off.

> Never mind.

As you wish.

The connection between Harran and Ebla in the 3rd millennium is established by the Ebla texts. Ebla, and Syria at large, whether direct and/or indirect, had a significant known connection with both Egypt and Mesopotamia going back to and through the relevant periods of time, namely the 4th and 3rd millenniums. I would suggest what you are looking for is not a direct Egypt to Harran connection, but rather and indirect one with Ebla (Syria) as the intermediary between the two.



Edited 1 time(s). Last edit at 06-Mar-19 01:52 by Thanos5150.

Options: ReplyQuote


Subject Views Written By Posted
The Three Stone Ships from the East - of the Giza Plateau 3445 MDaines 22-Feb-19 09:52
Re: The Three Stone Ships from the East - of the Giza Plateau 469 Thanos5150 22-Feb-19 16:15
Re: The Three Stone Ships from the East - of the Giza Plateau 335 MDaines 23-Feb-19 18:01
Re: The Three Stone Ships from the East - of the Giza Plateau 302 Thanos5150 24-Feb-19 03:06
Re: The Three Stone Ships from the East - of the Giza Plateau 324 Eddie Larry 22-Feb-19 18:39
Re: The Three Stone Ships from the East - of the Giza Plateau 311 cladking 22-Feb-19 20:12
Re: The Three Stone Ships from the East - of the Giza Plateau 293 MDaines 23-Feb-19 07:40
Re: The Three Stone Ships from the East - of the Giza Plateau 262 cladking 23-Feb-19 14:28
Re: The Three Stone Ships from the East - of the Giza Plateau 270 MDaines 23-Feb-19 15:23
Re: The Three Stone Ships from the East - of the Giza Plateau 214 cladking 02-Mar-19 16:31
Re: The Three Stone Ships from the East - of the Giza Plateau 250 Eddie Larry 23-Feb-19 16:24
Re: The Three Stone Ships from the East - of the Giza Plateau 259 Spiros 25-Feb-19 00:41
On the subject of Zechariah Sitchin 294 MDaines 25-Feb-19 14:49
Re: On the subject of Zechariah Sitchin 229 Spiros 04-Mar-19 01:11
The Exalted Sumero-Greek EN 226 MDaines 04-Mar-19 18:24
A Big Ask 295 Dr. Troglodyte 26-Feb-19 01:27
Re: A Big Ask 236 MDaines 26-Feb-19 14:25
Re: A Big Ask 304 Dr. Troglodyte 26-Feb-19 17:14
Re: A Big Ask 206 MDaines 26-Feb-19 19:30
Re: A Big Ask 229 Barbelo 26-Feb-19 20:23
Re: A Big Ask 237 MDaines 27-Feb-19 12:13
Re: A Big Ask 189 Barbelo 27-Feb-19 20:28
Re: A Big Ask 188 MDaines 28-Feb-19 14:05
Re: A Big Ask 219 Barbelo 28-Feb-19 19:59
Re: A Big Ask 231 Thanos5150 01-Mar-19 00:46
Re: A Big Ask 229 Barbelo 01-Mar-19 01:19
Re: A Big Ask 242 Thanos5150 01-Mar-19 05:20
Re: A Weird Ask 209 Barbelo 01-Mar-19 11:13
Re: A Weird Ask 216 Thanos5150 02-Mar-19 05:12
Re: A Weird Ask 222 Barbelo 02-Mar-19 07:06
Re: A Big Ask 210 MDaines 01-Mar-19 18:35
Re: A Big Ask 207 Barbelo 01-Mar-19 21:42
Re: A Big Ask 220 Thanos5150 28-Feb-19 03:33
Re: A Big Ask 202 Thanos5150 28-Feb-19 17:11
Re: A Big Ask 208 MDaines 28-Feb-19 18:08
Heliopolis 224 Barbelo 28-Feb-19 20:18
Midpoint Sunrise-Sunset 257 Dr. Troglodyte 04-Mar-19 23:56
Re: Midpoint Sunrise-Sunset 223 MDaines 10-Mar-19 14:41
Re: Midpoint Sunrise-Sunset 222 Dr. Troglodyte 12-Mar-19 00:17
Re: Midpoint Sunrise-Sunset 198 MDaines 15-Mar-19 07:17
Re: Midpoint Sunrise-Sunset 233 Dr. Troglodyte 15-Mar-19 16:41
Re: The Three Stone Ships from the East - of the Giza Plateau 263 molder 26-Feb-19 21:23
Re: The Three Stone Ships from the East - of the Giza Plateau 234 MDaines 27-Feb-19 12:06
Three Wise Men 208 MDaines 02-Mar-19 15:31
Re: Three Wise Men 213 Thanos5150 02-Mar-19 17:05
Harran and the Sabians 222 MDaines 03-Mar-19 08:33
Re: Harran and the Sabians 220 Thanos5150 03-Mar-19 16:40
Re: Harran and the Sabians 228 MDaines 03-Mar-19 19:24
Re: Harran and the Sabians 180 Thanos5150 06-Mar-19 01:50
Re: Harran and the Sabians 203 MDaines 06-Mar-19 08:22
Re: Harran and the Sabians 187 Thanos5150 07-Mar-19 02:09
Re: Harran and the Sabians 199 MDaines 07-Mar-19 08:20
On the subject of Ebla and the Feather of Truth 204 MDaines 08-Mar-19 08:57
Re: The Three Stone Ships from the East - of the Giza Plateau 223 Broker 14-Mar-19 03:25
Re: The Three Stone Ships from the East - of the Giza Plateau 199 MDaines 17-Mar-19 09:11
Re: The Three Stone Ships from the East - of the Giza Plateau 196 SandyJesse 18-Apr-19 04:33
Celestial navigation and the ship 181 MDaines 23-Apr-19 07:21
Re: Celestial navigation and the ship 164 SandyJesse 25-Apr-19 01:50
Re: Celestial navigation and the ship 166 SandyJesse 30-Apr-19 05:16
Re: The Three Stone Ships from the East - of the Giza Plateau 165 seasmith 03-May-19 22:24
Re: The Three Stone Ships from the East - of the Giza Plateau 158 MDaines 04-May-19 08:28
Re: The Three Stone Ships from the East - of the Giza Plateau 151 seasmith 05-May-19 01:39
BEFORE BABEL The Crystal Tongue 158 MDaines 09-May-19 09:46
Re: BEFORE BABEL The Crystal Tongue 147 SandyJesse 12-May-19 09:58
Re: BEFORE BABEL The Crystal Tongue 145 MDaines 12-May-19 10:22
Re: BEFORE BABEL The Crystal Tongue 126 SandyJesse 14-May-19 05:21
Re: BEFORE BABEL The Crystal Tongue 134 MDaines 14-May-19 07:46
Re: BEFORE BABEL The Crystal Tongue 131 SandyJesse 16-May-19 03:19
Re: The Three Stone Ships from the East - of the Giza Plateau 131 drew 15-May-19 01:21
Re: The Three Stone Ships from the East - of the Giza Plateau 125 Barbelo 15-May-19 10:48
Re: The Three Stone Ships from the East - of the Giza Plateau 140 drew 15-May-19 23:59
Re: The Three Stone Ships from the East - of the Giza Plateau 129 Barbelo 16-May-19 01:45
Re: The Three Stone Ships from the East - of the Giza Plateau 91 drew 18-Jun-19 02:15
Re: The Three Stone Ships from the East - of the Giza Plateau 96 Barbelo 18-Jun-19 02:43
Re: The Three Stone Ships from the East - of the Giza Plateau 134 hendrik dirker 18-Jun-19 06:59
movement of Sun along horizon 105 hendrik dirker 19-Jun-19 16:23
Solstice & the epoch1250 BC 191 hendrik dirker 20-Jun-19 07:02
Re: The Three Stone Ships from the East - of the Giza Plateau 130 MDaines 15-May-19 11:00
Re: The Three Stone Ships from the East - of the Giza Plateau 147 Horatech 15-May-19 12:10
To Easter Island? 142 MDaines 15-May-19 18:10
Re: To Easter Island? 129 Horatech 16-May-19 06:56
Re: To Easter Island? 131 Horatech 16-May-19 23:48
Re: To Easter Island? 139 Horatech 17-May-19 06:25
Re: To Easter Island? 115 Barbelo 17-May-19 10:53
Re: To Easter Island? 148 MDaines 17-May-19 11:41
What A Shame 125 Barbelo 17-May-19 21:14
Re: What A Shame 140 MDaines 18-May-19 07:57
Great Circles and Small Circles 133 Dr. Troglodyte 18-May-19 17:34
Re: Great Circles and Small Circles and Easter Island 159 MDaines 18-May-19 19:09
Re: Great Circles and Small Circles and Easter Island 135 Dr. Troglodyte 19-May-19 17:07
Going Round in Circles and then to Easter Island? 152 MDaines 19-May-19 18:10
Re: Going Round in Circles and then to Easter Island? 143 Horatech 25-May-19 10:53
Re: Great Circles and Small Circles and Easter Island 152 Horatech 20-May-19 07:33
Re: Great Circles and Small Circles and Easter Island 132 Horatech 21-May-19 09:52
Re: Great Circles and Small Circles and Easter Island 147 Dr. Troglodyte 21-May-19 18:30
Re: Great Circles, Small Circles, Easter Island 167 MDaines 23-May-19 07:51
Re: Great Circles, Small Circles, Easter Island 154 Horatech 23-May-19 10:48
Re: Great Circles, Small Circles, Easter Island 135 MDaines 23-May-19 17:07
Re: Great Circles, Small Circles, Easter Island 149 Horatech 24-May-19 08:12
Re: Great Circles, Small Circles, Easter Island 174 Dr. Troglodyte 23-May-19 16:05
Re: Great Circles, Small Circles, Easter Island 147 MDaines 23-May-19 17:05
Re: Great Circles, Small Circles, Easter Island 150 Dr. Troglodyte 23-May-19 17:31
Re: Great Circles and Small Circles and Easter Island 157 Horatech 27-May-19 10:30
Re: What A Shame 130 Barbelo 19-May-19 20:48
Re: To Easter Island? 127 Horatech 18-May-19 09:28
Re: To Easter Island? 115 Eddie Larry 17-May-19 15:11
Re: To Easter Island? 121 Horatech 18-May-19 14:58
Re: The Three Stone Ships from the East - of the Giza Plateau 139 drew 15-May-19 23:57
Re: The Three Stone Ships from the East - of the Giza Plateau 128 MDaines 16-May-19 06:14
Re: The Three Stone Ships from the East - of the Giza Plateau 126 drew 16-May-19 06:42
ps 119 drew 16-May-19 07:22
Re: ps 117 Barbelo 16-May-19 11:11
Re: ps 135 MDaines 16-May-19 12:10
Re: ps 153 Thanos5150 16-May-19 16:06
Re: ps 152 Barbelo 16-May-19 21:00
Sometimes I go the long way round… 165 drew 17-May-19 00:59


Sorry, only registered users may post in this forum.