Mysteries :  The Official GrahamHancock.com forums
For serious discussion of the controversies, approaches and enigmas surrounding the origins and development of the human species and of human civilization. (NB: for more ‘out there’ posts we point you in the direction of the ‘Paranormal & Supernatural’ Message Board). 
Welcome! Log InRegister
Sirfiroth Wrote:
-------------------------------------------------------
> you are so dead set on finding items like pi ... that simply do not exist in the Pyramids of Giza.
> Jacob

And dare one ask just how you intend to prove conclusively that pi is not present at all at Giza?

I fail to understand why there’s this big-end v little-end dispute about the presence of pi, or lack of it, in the design of G1. These are two competing hypotheses - neither is proven.

In fact, historically, the pi hypothesis has surely to be considered the prevailing hypothesis, the null hypothesis. It is therefore incumbent on naysayers to produce a compelling argument to reject it. Stating that the pi hypothesis is invalid because there is no written record of pi is far from compelling, because this is logically flawed. I repeat: absence of evidence is not evidence of absence.

The case against Phi is an entirely different matter. You seem to be on stronger ground in this and when arguing in favour of an Egyptian mathematical context.

I’m led to believe that the hypothesis that you’re developing demands that there be no trace of pi at G1. I hope this is not so, because you’d then be falling into the same trap as the posters here, starting with what you want to believe and attempting by hook or by crook to reinforce it.

I see little or no proof here of anything other than that it’s possible to do what’s being done. I could lambaste it, but I choose not to, because I'm hoping that something useful or perceptive might turn up, as I feel has happened in the past. I don’t find the pi hypothesis to be the anathema that you perceive it to be. It’s a hypothesis, it could be wrong, but the existence of competing hypotheses is not the problem with this and similar threads.

It’s not the validity of the pi hypothesis that’s cause for comment or concern, it’s the nature and content of the argument.



Edited 1 time(s). Last edit at 07-Feb-19 02:14 by gjb.

Options: ReplyQuote


Subject Views Written By Posted
Diodorus measures pyramids 2293 molder 10-Jan-19 22:33
Re: Diodorus measures pyramids 298 engbren 10-Jan-19 23:00
Re: Diodorus measures pyramids 326 molder 11-Jan-19 21:37
Re: Diodorus/Herodotus measures pyramids 248 molder 12-Jan-19 23:36
Misinformation 315 Dr. Troglodyte 13-Jan-19 01:16
Re: Misinformation 227 molder 13-Jan-19 04:14
Re: The Duplication of a cube 219 molder 13-Jan-19 21:46
/Herodotus gets 3rd pyramid measure right 172 molder 02-Feb-19 10:44
Re: Diodorus measures pyramids 269 Spiros 13-Jan-19 17:42
Re: Diodorus measures pyramids 188 molder 13-Jan-19 21:24
Re: Diodorus measures pyramids 179 DavidK 30-Jan-19 10:19
Re: Diodorus measures pyramids 234 Sirfiroth 30-Jan-19 18:54
Re: Diodorus measures pyramids 179 DavidK 31-Jan-19 11:45
Re: Diodorus measures pyramids 162 DavidK 31-Jan-19 19:33
Re: Diodorus measures pyramids 184 Sirfiroth 01-Feb-19 03:09
Re: Diodorus measures pyramids 160 DavidK 01-Feb-19 08:26
Re: Diodorus measures pyramids 177 Sirfiroth 01-Feb-19 14:00
Re: Diodorus measures pyramids 205 rodz111 02-Feb-19 08:27
Re: Diodorus measures pyramids 209 Sirfiroth 02-Feb-19 15:27
Re: Diodorus measures pyramids 179 gjb 02-Feb-19 18:37
Re: Diodorus measures pyramids 184 Sirfiroth 03-Feb-19 01:00
Re: Diodorus measures pyramids 194 DavidK 03-Feb-19 11:12
Re: Diodorus measures pyramids 179 Sirfiroth 03-Feb-19 14:56
Re: Diodorus measures pyramids 147 DavidK 03-Feb-19 23:51
Re: Diodorus measures pyramids 182 gjb 03-Feb-19 23:54
Re: Diodorus measures pyramids 158 Sirfiroth 04-Feb-19 20:45
Re: Diodorus measures pyramids 152 Warwick 04-Feb-19 20:48
Re: Diodorus measures pyramids 148 rodz111 05-Feb-19 04:00
Re: Diodorus measures pyramids 166 Sirfiroth 05-Feb-19 05:04
Re: Diodorus measures pyramids 159 rodz111 05-Feb-19 17:16
Re: Diodorus measures pyramids 178 Sirfiroth 05-Feb-19 19:11
Re: Diodorus measures pyramids 144 rodz111 05-Feb-19 23:13
Re: Diodorus measures pyramids 189 DavidK 04-Feb-19 11:01
Re: Diodorus measures pyramids 204 Sirfiroth 04-Feb-19 15:59
There is one rod with 7 palms 28 digits 20 34/55 in length 186 DavidK 04-Feb-19 13:39
Re: There is one rod with 7 palms 28 digits 20 34/55 in length 158 Sirfiroth 04-Feb-19 19:41
Re: There is one rod with 7 palms 28 digits 20 34/55 in length 168 Warwick 04-Feb-19 19:53
Re: There is one rod with 7 palms 28 digits 20 34/55 in length 140 DavidK 05-Feb-19 09:15
Re: There is one rod with 7 palms 28 digits 20 34/55 in length 144 Sirfiroth 06-Feb-19 13:29
Re: There is one rod with 7 palms 28 digits 20 34/55 in length 142 DavidK 06-Feb-19 15:19
Re: There is one rod with 7 palms 28 digits 20 34/55 in length 167 gjb 06-Feb-19 19:15
Re: There is one rod with 7 palms 28 digits 20 34/55 in length 157 Sirfiroth 06-Feb-19 21:23
Re: Diodorus measures pyramids 193 Spiros 03-Feb-19 13:26
Re: Diodorus measures pyramids 159 DavidK 04-Feb-19 14:39
the photon foot 165 Spiros 10-Feb-19 18:58
Re: Diodorus measures pyramids Herodotus seems to confirm 275 molder 23-Jan-19 03:33
Re: Diodorus measures pyramids Herodotus seems to confirm 248 DavidK 23-Jan-19 09:32
Re: Diodorus measures pyramids Herodotus seems to confirm 256 molder 23-Jan-19 11:40
Re: Diodorus measures pyramids Herodotus seems to confirm 200 DavidK 23-Jan-19 12:08
Re: Diodorus measures pyramids Herodotus seems to confirm 255 molder 24-Jan-19 11:00
Re: Diodorus measures pyramids Herodotus seems to confirm 185 DavidK 24-Jan-19 23:13
Re: Diodorus measures pyramids Herodotus seems to confirm 199 molder 26-Jan-19 01:26
Re: Diodorus measures pyramids Herodotus seems to confirm 245 engbren 26-Jan-19 03:05
Re: Diodorus measures pyramids Herodotus seems to confirm 244 Sirfiroth 26-Jan-19 04:04
Re: Diodorus measures pyramids Herodotus seems to confirm 214 DavidK 26-Jan-19 11:09
Re: Diodorus measures pyramids Herodotus seems to confirm 171 molder 28-Jan-19 01:03
Re: Diodorus measures pyramids Herodotus seems to confirm 225 DavidK 28-Jan-19 12:09
Re: Diodorus measures pyramids Herodotus seems to confirm 189 molder 28-Jan-19 12:50
Re: Diodorus measures pyramids Herodotus seems to confirm 159 cloister 28-Jan-19 13:26
Re: Diodorus measures pyramids Herodotus seems to confirm 151 DavidK 28-Jan-19 15:03
Re: Diodorus measures pyramids Herodotus seems to confirm 201 Sirfiroth 28-Jan-19 14:42
Re: Diodorus measures pyramids Herodotus seems to confirm 165 DavidK 28-Jan-19 15:48
Re: Diodorus measures pyramids Herodotus seems to confirm 245 Sirfiroth 28-Jan-19 17:42
Re: Diodorus measures pyramids Herodotus seems to confirm 164 engbren 29-Jan-19 13:39
Re: Diodorus measures pyramids Herodotus seems to confirm 187 Sirfiroth 29-Jan-19 17:36
Re: Diodorus measures pyramids Herodotus seems to confirm 186 engbren 29-Jan-19 21:39
Re: Diodorus measures pyramids Herodotus seems to confirm 244 Sirfiroth 30-Jan-19 00:03
Re: Diodorus measures pyramids Herodotus seems to confirm 205 engbren 30-Jan-19 02:28
Re: Diodorus measures pyramids Herodotus seems to confirm 206 Sirfiroth 30-Jan-19 19:28
Re: Diodorus measures pyramids Herodotus seems to confirm 182 engbren 30-Jan-19 20:24
Re: Diodorus measures pyramids Herodotus seems to confirm 217 Sirfiroth 31-Jan-19 00:41
Re: Diodorus measures pyramids Herodotus seems to confirm 157 engbren 31-Jan-19 05:38
Re: Diodorus measures pyramids Herodotus seems to confirm 199 Sirfiroth 31-Jan-19 15:38
Re: Turin cubit rods 163 molder 03-Feb-19 22:43
Re: Turin cubit rods 145 DavidK 06-Feb-19 10:18
Re: Diodorus measures pyramids Herodotus seems to confirm 213 molder 28-Jan-19 12:35
Re: Herodotus Works of Amasis 229 molder 30-Jan-19 22:32
Re:Aubrey holes 104 molder 01-Apr-19 00:55
Re: Re:Aubrey holes 94 DavidK 01-Apr-19 20:27
Re: Re:Aubrey holes 103 molder 01-Apr-19 21:31
Re: Stonehenge Sarsen circle synodic month 145 molder 03-Apr-19 22:36
Re: Diodorus measures pyramids 277 DavidK 30-Jan-19 19:01
Re: Diodorus measures pyramids The Pi argument 178 DavidK 05-Feb-19 11:34
Re: Diodorus measures pyramids The Pi argument 172 molder 06-Feb-19 05:13
Re: Diodorus measures pyramids The Pi argument 218 Sirfiroth 06-Feb-19 18:22
Re: Diodorus measures pyramids The Pi argument 160 DavidK 06-Feb-19 22:46
Re: Diodorus measures pyramids The Pi argument 150 Sirfiroth 07-Feb-19 01:43
Re: Diodorus measures pyramids The Pi argument 157 engbren 08-Feb-19 06:55
Re: Diodorus measures pyramids The Pi argument 148 Sirfiroth 08-Feb-19 14:35
Re: Diodorus measures pyramids The Pi argument 128 engbren 08-Feb-19 20:29
Re: Diodorus measures pyramids The Pi argument 175 gjb 07-Feb-19 01:57
Re: Diodorus measures pyramids The Pi argument 179 Sirfiroth 07-Feb-19 02:22
Re: Diodorus measures pyramids The Pi argument 164 DavidK 07-Feb-19 13:04
Re: Diodorus measures pyramids The Pi argument 147 Sirfiroth 07-Feb-19 17:04
Re: Diodorus measures pyramids The Pi argument 141 DavidK 07-Feb-19 18:07
Re: Diodorus measures pyramids The Pi argument 193 Sirfiroth 07-Feb-19 18:27
Re: Diodorus measures pyramids The Pi argument 172 molder 07-Feb-19 22:22
Re: Diodorus measures pyramids The Pi argument 149 molder 07-Feb-19 22:34
Re: Diodorus measures pyramids The Pi argument 167 molder 09-Feb-19 00:49
Re: Diodorus measures pyramids The Pi argument 181 molder 09-Feb-19 21:17
Re: Diodorus measures pyramids The Pi argument 157 Sirfiroth 10-Feb-19 03:32
Re: Diodorus measures pyramids The Pi argument 161 DavidK 10-Feb-19 10:25
Re: Diodorus measures pyramids The Pi argument 182 molder 10-Feb-19 11:48
Re: Diodorus measures pyramids The Pi argument 188 Sirfiroth 10-Feb-19 20:57
The Pyramid Proofs. - Base 7 per Diodorus 177 DavidK 11-Feb-19 09:45
Re: The Pyramid Proofs. - Base 10000 per Thom 147 DavidK 11-Feb-19 11:21
Re: The Pyramid Proofs. - Base 64 132 DavidK 11-Feb-19 11:35
Re: The Pyramid Proofs. - The Modern Metre 179 DavidK 11-Feb-19 11:49
Re: The Pyramid Proofs. - The Stade Alternative 139 DavidK 11-Feb-19 11:57
Re: The Pyramid Proofs. - Reconciliation to Petrie 137 DavidK 11-Feb-19 13:08
LOL 196 Sirfiroth 11-Feb-19 14:50
Re: LOL 146 DavidK 11-Feb-19 15:55
Re: LOL 157 Sirfiroth 11-Feb-19 16:51
Re: LOL 146 DavidK 11-Feb-19 20:44
Re: LOL 157 Sirfiroth 11-Feb-19 21:49
Re: LOL 161 DavidK 11-Feb-19 22:21
Re: LOL 202 Sirfiroth 11-Feb-19 23:40
Re: The Pyramid Proofs. - Base 64 172 engbren 11-Feb-19 11:55
Re: The Pyramid Proofs. - Base 64 153 DavidK 11-Feb-19 12:16
Re: The Pyramid Proofs. - Base 64 163 engbren 11-Feb-19 21:59
Re: The Pyramid Proofs. - Base 64 202 DavidK 11-Feb-19 22:25
Re: The Pyramid Proofs. - Base 64 168 DavidK 11-Feb-19 22:49
Re: The Pyramid Proofs. - working papers 245 DavidK 12-Feb-19 15:18
Re: The Pyramid Proofs. - working papers 190 engbren 13-Feb-19 11:58
Re: The Pyramid Proofs. - working papers 138 DavidK 22-Feb-19 11:03
The Pyramid Proofs?????????? Not really! 178 Sirfiroth 22-Feb-19 14:46
Re: The Pyramid Proofs?????????? Not really! 155 DavidK 23-Feb-19 10:37
Re: The Pyramid Proofs?????????? Not really! 177 Sirfiroth 23-Feb-19 15:09
Re: The Pyramid Proofs the Plethora 163 DavidK 25-Feb-19 14:26
Re: The Pyramid Proofs the Plethora 178 Sirfiroth 25-Feb-19 16:21
Re: The Pyramid Proofs 360 degrees and the solar year 168 DavidK 25-Feb-19 20:04
Re: The Pyramid Proofs - Tangible and intangible design 153 DavidK 26-Feb-19 08:37
Re: The Pyramid Proofs. - Base 64 221 molder 13-Feb-19 12:10
Re: The Pyramid Proofs. - Base 64 145 DavidK 26-Feb-19 20:30
Re: Diodorus measures pyramids 135 molder 06-Mar-19 21:36
Mod Note > Double Posting 162 Dr. Troglodyte 06-Mar-19 22:10
Re: Diodorus measures pyramids 177 molder 07-Mar-19 10:22
Re: Diodorus measures pyramids 132 DavidK 13-Mar-19 14:18
Re: Diodorus measures pyramids 110 rodz111 14-Mar-19 03:45
Re: Diodorus measures pyramids 183 molder 14-Mar-19 10:53


Sorry, only registered users may post in this forum.