Mysteries :  The Official GrahamHancock.com forums
For serious discussion of the controversies, approaches and enigmas surrounding the origins and development of the human species and of human civilization. (NB: for more ‘out there’ posts we point you in the direction of the ‘Paranormal & Supernatural’ Message Board). 
Welcome! Log InRegister
cladking Wrote:

> I didn't make these statements. This came from
> the authors of the study. They are effectively
> saying that our concept of stinky footed bumpkins
> dragging stones up ramps is not in evidence at
> "Hatnub" and the same system could have been
> employed at Giza since these events took place
> concurrently or nearly so.

No they are saying they have evidence for a method to support or supplement the movement of stones up a ramp. What that might be is not known - until we see the study.
>
>
Quote

> ...changes our understanding of how the pyramids
> were built.
>
> Again the suggestion is that our concept of
> dragging tombs up ramps is not accurate (at least
> at Hatnub).

No one drags 'tombs' up ramps Cladking you've said that nearly a 1,000 times and it still makes no sense whatsoever. Why do you childishly substitute tombs for stones? It is just one of those strange little mysteries isn't it? lol
>
> I don't know if they really have a bombshell or
> not.

How would you? Within Egyptology this would be considered an interesting or minor piece of trivia about the Pyramids. Remember the real scientists don't obsess about the tombs at Gizah.

It will be a nice addition to the existing theories about how it pyramids were built.

We found the thermal anomaly and it was
> dropped like a hot potato like there was nothing
> there.

No as explained to you multiple times its a small part of a much larger set of questions. Since you know nothing about how large scale international organizations work. Nor how complex the interactions are between international groups over leadership, funding and who will do what when it is not surprising you don't understand the situation.

Maybe this will be dropped as well? But
> as things stand they have essentially said,
> implied, suggested, and stated that they didn't
> use "ramps" to build the Great Pyramid if their
> study is even applicable to the pyramids.

What? No they didn't go back and read it again and leave your intense bias behind.

This is what was said; "The moving system consists of the central ramp surrounded by two set of stairs contain poles holes which help lifting the alabaster stone block through at least 20% coarse ramp".

[luxortimesmagazine.blogspot.com]

Third Paragraph Cladking....

You see that magic phrase...........Central ramp

Cladking why do you try to tell whoppers about stuff other people can clearly see? Do you really think other people haven't read the link? Really?

Chuckle - and you wonder why you are not taken seriously!
>
> These are their words, not mine. I don't know
> what they found but there's a lot of information
> in those pictures that is being overlooked.

Yeah like you'd know something about AE construction techniques, archaeology or Egyptian geology.

Laughter

Hey why not email those fine folks and tell'm all the stuff they have gotten wrong. Keep us in the loop too.

Options: ReplyQuote


Subject Views Written By Posted
Khufu’s Hatnub Ramp 2299 Dr. Troglodyte 01-Nov-18 16:00
Re: Khufu’s Hatnub Ramp 401 cladking 01-Nov-18 16:08
Alabaster = Calcite = Travertine 346 Dr. Troglodyte 01-Nov-18 16:45
Re: Alabaster = Calcite = Travertine 320 cladking 01-Nov-18 17:02
Re: Alabaster = Calcite = Travertine 303 Dr. Troglodyte 01-Nov-18 17:13
Re: Alabaster = Calcite = Travertine 296 cladking 01-Nov-18 17:37
Re: Alabaster = Calcite = Travertine 297 cladking 01-Nov-18 18:14
Beware a deluge of denial 274 Hanslune 01-Nov-18 21:11
We're still waiting for you to publish YOUR research 302 Hanslune 01-Nov-18 21:07
YOU Need to Read More Closely. 290 cladking 01-Nov-18 21:53
You need to see the lovely ramp you said didn't exist... 275 Hanslune 01-Nov-18 22:24
Re: YOU Need to Read More Closely. 252 cladking 02-Nov-18 02:40
It's a ramp Cladking 273 Hanslune 02-Nov-18 04:58
Re: It's a ramp Cladking 230 cladking 02-Nov-18 13:22
It's STILL a ramp Cladking 242 Hanslune 02-Nov-18 17:10
Re: It's STILL a ramp Cladking 262 cladking 02-Nov-18 17:52
Cladking agrees that its a RAMP! 267 Hanslune 02-Nov-18 22:12
Nice ramp 273 Hanslune 01-Nov-18 21:05
Re: Khufu’s Hatnub Ramp 286 Thanos5150 02-Nov-18 01:57
Re: Khufu’s Hatnub Ramp 253 cladking 02-Nov-18 02:30
It still a ramp Cladking and no geysers in sight 196 Hanslune 02-Nov-18 05:08
Good stuff I look forward to the full report 324 Hanslune 02-Nov-18 05:16
Additional materials and images of the ramp and quarry 426 Hanslune 02-Nov-18 05:37
Re: Khufu’s Hatnub Ramp 262 cladking 02-Nov-18 13:34
“Large Stone” Location 303 Dr. Troglodyte 02-Nov-18 15:17
Re: “Large Stone” Location 254 cladking 02-Nov-18 15:39
What the authors actually said... 252 cladking 04-Nov-18 15:55
Re: What the autors actually said... 259 Martin Stower 04-Nov-18 16:07
Re: What the authors actually said... 268 cladking 04-Nov-18 18:57
The moving system consists of the central ramp 197 Hanslune 05-Nov-18 00:45
Re: The moving system consists of the central ramp 190 cladking 05-Nov-18 01:47
Central ramp 200 Hanslune 05-Nov-18 05:04
Re: What the authors actually said... 228 Martin Stower 05-Nov-18 00:47
Re: What the authors actually said... 219 Hanslune 05-Nov-18 00:53
Reading skills 175 Hanslune 05-Nov-18 00:49
Re: Reading skills 170 cladking 05-Nov-18 01:53
Why the delay Cladking? 229 Hanslune 05-Nov-18 04:41
Re: Why the delay Cladking? 245 eyeofhorus33 05-Nov-18 17:55
Re: Why the delay Cladking? 236 cladking 05-Nov-18 20:03
Why are you running from the questions Cladking? 227 Hanslune 05-Nov-18 20:50
Re: Why are you running from the questions Cladking? 220 cladking 05-Nov-18 22:38
You are simply not worth talking too 218 Hanslune 05-Nov-18 23:32
Proto-mega-metaphysical Ultra 215 Hanslune 05-Nov-18 20:45
Re: What the autors actually said... 244 cladking 05-Nov-18 02:05
making it easier to pull the sled up the ramp 226 Hanslune 05-Nov-18 13:13
Re: making it easier to pull the sled up the ramp 232 cladking 05-Nov-18 17:26
'making it easier to pull the sled up the ramp' 224 Hanslune 05-Nov-18 21:00
Re: What the autors actually said... 293 Martin Stower 05-Nov-18 13:50
Re: What the autors actually said... 214 cladking 05-Nov-18 17:19
Re: What the autors actually said... 239 Martin Stower 05-Nov-18 20:38
He needs help Martin 224 Hanslune 05-Nov-18 20:54
Re: What the autors actually said... 238 cladking 05-Nov-18 22:43
Martin just sit back and watch him talk - its funny 230 Hanslune 05-Nov-18 23:35
Re: Martin just sit back and watch him talk - its funny 233 Brian Patterson 06-Nov-18 00:34
Re: Martin just sit back and watch him talk - its funny 227 cladking 06-Nov-18 01:25
Yeah canning - you see ancient cans all over Egypt! 244 Hanslune 06-Nov-18 05:13
Re: Yeah canning - you see ancient cans all over Egypt! 238 Brian Patterson 06-Nov-18 13:45
Re: Yeah canning - you see ancient cans all over Egypt! 222 cladking 06-Nov-18 14:33
Re: Yeah canning - you see ancient cans all over Egypt! 219 Hanslune 06-Nov-18 15:03
Hey Brian you might like this Cladking gets schooled 244 Hanslune 06-Nov-18 15:21
Re: Hey Brian you might like this Cladking gets schooled 243 cladking 06-Nov-18 19:57
Re: Martin just sit back and watch him talk - its funny 253 Thanos5150 06-Nov-18 17:14
Re: Martin just sit back and watch him talk - its funny 229 Hanslune 06-Nov-18 18:13
Re: Martin just sit back and watch him talk - its funny 225 cladking 06-Nov-18 19:14
Re: What the autors actually said... 234 Martin Stower 07-Nov-18 00:45
Re: What the autors actually said... 269 cladking 07-Nov-18 01:15
Re: What the autors actually said... 228 Martin Stower 07-Nov-18 01:44
Re: What the autors actually said... 224 cladking 07-Nov-18 04:28
Re: What the autors actually said... 190 Martin Stower 07-Nov-18 10:19
Re: What the autors actually said... 171 cladking 07-Nov-18 14:47
Re: What the autors actually said... 181 Martin Stower 07-Nov-18 14:59
Re: What the autors actually said... 177 cladking 07-Nov-18 16:37
Re: What the autors actually said... 169 Martin Stower 07-Nov-18 17:17
Re: What the autors actually said... 284 cladking 07-Nov-18 17:39
New half baked idea? 265 cladking 07-Nov-18 15:48
Opinions on claimed finding of ramp for building pyramids 188 enki64 09-Nov-18 15:28
Mod Note > Duplicate Topic Merged 310 Dr. Troglodyte 09-Nov-18 16:31
Re: Opinions on claimed finding of ramp for building pyramids 220 forumfan 12-Nov-18 05:05
Re: Opinions on claimed finding of ramp for building pyramids 221 cladking 12-Nov-18 06:48
Re: Opinions on claimed finding of ramp for building pyramids 219 forumfan 12-Nov-18 09:53
Re: Opinions on claimed finding of ramp for building pyramids 228 cladking 12-Nov-18 14:13
The Real Purpose of the Posts and stairs. 399 cladking 12-Nov-18 15:57
Re: The Real Purpose of the Posts and stairs. 78 cladking 02-Aug-19 15:19
Re: The Real Purpose of the Posts and stairs. 85 Corpuscles 03-Aug-19 00:36
Re: The Real Purpose of the Posts and stairs. 116 cladking 03-Aug-19 02:13
Re: The Real Purpose of the Posts and stairs. 75 Warwick 03-Aug-19 20:21
Re: The Real Purpose of the Posts and stairs. 69 cladking 03-Aug-19 20:34
Re: The Real Purpose of the Posts and stairs. 66 Warwick 03-Aug-19 21:03
Re: Khufu’s Hatnub Ramp 172 cladking 28-Jul-19 20:23
Question/s 81 Warwick 29-Jul-19 16:59
Re: Question/s 78 cladking 29-Jul-19 17:35
The Smell of Burning Denim 77 Warwick 29-Jul-19 18:19
Re: The Smell of Burning Denim 76 cladking 29-Jul-19 18:34
Nailing Jello to the Wall..... 79 Warwick 29-Jul-19 19:30
Re: Nailing Jello to the Wall..... 81 Thanos5150 29-Jul-19 20:29
Re: Nailing Jello to the Wall..... 67 Warwick 30-Jul-19 18:28
So What Is Egyptology? 82 cladking 29-Jul-19 20:46
Re: So What Is Egyptology? 79 Corpuscles 29-Jul-19 21:43
Re: So What Is Egyptology? 75 cladking 29-Jul-19 22:14
Re: So What Is Egyptology? 68 Warwick 30-Jul-19 18:31
Re: So What Is Egyptology? 66 cladking 30-Jul-19 18:58
Re: So What Is Egyptology? 72 Warwick 30-Jul-19 19:11
Re: So What Is Egyptology? 75 cladking 30-Jul-19 19:20
Re: So What Is Egyptology? 64 Warwick 30-Jul-19 19:27
Re: So What Is Egyptology? 60 cladking 30-Jul-19 19:51
Re: So What Is Egyptology? 71 Warwick 30-Jul-19 20:06
Re: So What Is Egyptology? 68 cladking 30-Jul-19 21:19
Re: Khufu’s Hatnub Ramp 89 Martin Stower 29-Jul-19 19:41
Re: Khufu’s Hatnub Ramp 79 Warwick 29-Jul-19 19:52
Re: Khufu’s Hatnub Ramp 76 cladking 29-Jul-19 20:41
Re: Khufu’s Hatnub Ramp 82 Corpuscles 29-Jul-19 21:09
Re: Khufu’s Hatnub Ramp 72 cladking 29-Jul-19 21:32
Re: Khufu’s Hatnub Ramp 82 Corpuscles 29-Jul-19 21:48
Re: Khufu’s Hatnub Ramp 77 cladking 29-Jul-19 22:04
Re: Khufu’s Hatnub Ramp 79 Corpuscles 29-Jul-19 22:27
Re: Khufu’s Hatnub Ramp 94 cladking 30-Jul-19 00:29
Re: Khufu’s Hatnub Ramp 90 Corpuscles 30-Jul-19 02:01
Re: Khufu’s Hatnub Ramp 103 Thanos5150 30-Jul-19 03:03
But 69 Warwick 30-Jul-19 19:29
Re: Khufu’s Hatnub Ramp 78 Corpuscles 30-Jul-19 23:05
Re: Khufu’s Hatnub Ramp 79 cladking 31-Jul-19 01:10
Re: Khufu’s Hatnub Ramp 66 cladking 31-Jul-19 13:33
Re: Khufu’s Hatnub Ramp 75 cladking 31-Jul-19 14:00
True Confession? 70 Warwick 31-Jul-19 16:06
Re: True Confession? 73 cladking 31-Jul-19 17:25
Re: True Confession? 68 Warwick 31-Jul-19 19:09
Re: True Confession? 70 cladking 31-Jul-19 20:55
Sancho says... 63 Warwick 01-Aug-19 17:08
ROFL Re: "inclined plane technology" 66 cladking 01-Aug-19 20:12
Re: ROFL Re: "inclined plane technology" 66 Warwick 01-Aug-19 20:25
Why Can't They Read Their Own Translation? 70 cladking 01-Aug-19 20:41
Re: Why Can't They Read Their Own Translation? 72 Corpuscles 01-Aug-19 23:12
Re: Why Can't They Read Their Own Translation? 62 cladking 02-Aug-19 00:40
Re: Why Can't They Read Their Own Translation? 61 Corpuscles 02-Aug-19 01:11
Re: Why Can't They Read Their Own Translation? 65 cladking 02-Aug-19 01:58
Re: Why Can't They Read Their Own Translation? 72 Warwick 02-Aug-19 16:48
Re: Why Can't They Read Their Own Translation? 63 cladking 02-Aug-19 19:32
Re: Khufu’s Hatnub Ramp 71 Corpuscles 31-Jul-19 23:29
Re: Khufu’s Hatnub Ramp 59 cladking 01-Aug-19 00:35
Re: Khufu’s Hatnub Ramp 75 Corpuscles 01-Aug-19 01:13
Re: Khufu’s Hatnub Ramp 91 cladking 01-Aug-19 02:50
Re: Khufu’s Hatnub Ramp 77 cladking 01-Aug-19 16:24
NO!!!! 70 Warwick 01-Aug-19 17:26
They Have Ramps in Their Eyes. 61 cladking 01-Aug-19 20:00
Re: They Have Ramps in Their Eyes. 66 Warwick 01-Aug-19 20:07
Re: They Have Ramps in Their Eyes. 67 cladking 01-Aug-19 20:29
The Holy Pail 71 Warwick 01-Aug-19 17:16
Re: The Holy Pail 70 cladking 01-Aug-19 19:39
Re: The Holy Pail 74 Corpuscles 02-Aug-19 00:41
Re: The Holy Pail 59 cladking 02-Aug-19 00:53
Re: The Holy Pail 66 Corpuscles 02-Aug-19 01:31
Re: The Holy Pail 65 cladking 02-Aug-19 02:16
Re: The Holy Pail 73 Corpuscles 02-Aug-19 02:40
Re: The Holy Pail 61 Warwick 02-Aug-19 16:38
Re: The Holy Pail 66 cladking 02-Aug-19 01:04
Re: The Holy Pail 65 Warwick 02-Aug-19 16:52
Re: The Holy Pail 63 cladking 02-Aug-19 19:30
Re: The Holy Pail 57 Warwick 03-Aug-19 20:09
Insanity 81 Warwick 30-Jul-19 19:19
Re: Khufu’s Hatnub Ramp 99 cladking 29-Jul-19 20:23
Re: Khufu’s Hatnub Ramp 104 Martin Stower 30-Jul-19 10:27
Re: Khufu’s Hatnub Ramp 82 cladking 30-Jul-19 21:35
Re: Khufu’s Hatnub Ramp 78 cladking 30-Jul-19 21:43
Re: Khufu’s Hatnub Ramp 128 cladking 02-Aug-19 03:04
Re: Khufu’s Hatnub Ramp 70 cladking 02-Aug-19 03:27
Re: Khufu’s Hatnub Ramp 75 Corpuscles 02-Aug-19 04:44
Re: Khufu’s Hatnub Ramp 71 cladking 02-Aug-19 13:51
Re: Khufu’s Hatnub Ramp 67 Warwick 02-Aug-19 16:57
Re: Khufu’s Hatnub Ramp 56 cladking 02-Aug-19 19:23
Re: Khufu’s Hatnub Ramp 60 Warwick 03-Aug-19 20:14
Re: Khufu’s Hatnub Ramp 62 cladking 03-Aug-19 20:59
Re: Khufu’s Hatnub Ramp 60 Warwick 03-Aug-19 21:08
Re: Khufu’s Hatnub Ramp 73 Corpuscles 02-Aug-19 04:32
Re: Khufu’s Hatnub Ramp 73 cladking 02-Aug-19 14:07
Re: Khufu’s Hatnub Ramp 81 Warwick 02-Aug-19 17:00
Brichieri-Colombi’s HATNUB QUARRY Opposition Paper 108 Dr. Troglodyte 03-Aug-19 22:21
Re: Brichieri-Colombi’s HATNUB QUARRY Opposition Paper 103 cladking 04-Aug-19 13:40
Re: Brichieri-Colombi’s HATNUB QUARRY Opposition Paper 137 Dr. Troglodyte 05-Aug-19 00:58
Re: Brichieri-Colombi’s HATNUB QUARRY Opposition Paper 89 cladking 05-Aug-19 02:00
Re: Brichieri-Colombi’s HATNUB QUARRY Opposition Paper 71 Warwick 05-Aug-19 17:21
Re: Brichieri-Colombi’s HATNUB QUARRY Opposition Paper 65 cladking 05-Aug-19 18:34
Re: Brichieri-Colombi’s HATNUB QUARRY Opposition Paper 63 Warwick 05-Aug-19 18:46
Re: Brichieri-Colombi’s HATNUB QUARRY Opposition Paper 94 cladking 06-Aug-19 00:47
Re: Brichieri-Colombi’s HATNUB QUARRY Opposition Paper 63 Warwick 06-Aug-19 15:40
Re: Brichieri-Colombi’s HATNUB QUARRY Opposition Paper 61 cladking 06-Aug-19 18:22
Re: Brichieri-Colombi’s HATNUB QUARRY Opposition Paper 62 Warwick 06-Aug-19 18:44
Re: Brichieri-Colombi’s HATNUB QUARRY Opposition Paper 81 Corpuscles 07-Aug-19 10:00
Re: Brichieri-Colombi’s HATNUB QUARRY Opposition Paper 60 cladking 08-Aug-19 14:38
Re: Brichieri-Colombi’s HATNUB QUARRY Opposition Paper 82 Warwick 08-Aug-19 16:24
Update 69 Warwick 13-Aug-19 17:55
Re: Update 83 cladking 13-Aug-19 20:04
Flim Flam Sam 57 Warwick 13-Aug-19 21:10
Re: Flim Flam Sam 69 cladking 13-Aug-19 21:34
Re: Flim Flam Sam 56 Warwick 14-Aug-19 01:30
Re: Flim Flam Sam 75 cladking 14-Aug-19 02:11
Re: Flim Flam Sam 72 Warwick 14-Aug-19 15:13
What Sam is making stuff up? 58 Hanslune 14-Aug-19 16:33
Re: What Sam is making stuff up? 61 Warwick 14-Aug-19 16:54
Re: What Sam is making stuff up? 62 Hanslune 14-Aug-19 16:59
Re: What Sam is making stuff up? 59 cladking 14-Aug-19 17:29
Read the following carefully 57 Warwick 14-Aug-19 17:38
Re: Read the following carefully 52 cladking 14-Aug-19 17:45
Re: Read the following carefully 65 Warwick 14-Aug-19 17:52
Re: Read the following carefully 59 cladking 14-Aug-19 18:41
Re: Read the following carefully 62 Warwick 14-Aug-19 19:31
Lets see the evidence that supports you assumptions Cladking - where is your published data and research? 59 Hanslune 14-Aug-19 23:02
Re: Read the following carefully 68 cladking 15-Aug-19 00:12
I can see why you refuse to publish your research and data 59 Hanslune 15-Aug-19 04:51
Your opinions are evidence Sam? Really? 60 Hanslune 15-Aug-19 00:08
Re: Your opinions are evidence Sam? Really? 73 Corpuscles 15-Aug-19 00:37
Re: Your opinions are evidence Sam? Really? 56 Hanslune 15-Aug-19 04:56
Re: Your opinions are evidence Sam? Really? 76 Corpuscles 15-Aug-19 05:35
Corpuscles not to worry 57 Hanslune 15-Aug-19 15:27
Re: Corpuscles not to worry 76 Warwick 15-Aug-19 16:07
Re: Corpuscles not to worry 70 Hanslune 17-Aug-19 18:07
3, I mean 4, I mean 5 reasons 55 Warwick 15-Aug-19 16:01
Re: Brichieri-Colombi’s HATNUB QUARRY Opposition Paper 96 Dr. Troglodyte 05-Aug-19 19:21
Re: Brichieri-Colombi’s HATNUB QUARRY Opposition Paper 120 cladking 06-Aug-19 00:31
Re: Brichieri-Colombi’s HATNUB QUARRY Opposition Paper 79 Warwick 06-Aug-19 15:44
What Lehner actually said...... 74 Hanslune 14-Aug-19 16:48
Re: What Lehner actually said...... 69 cladking 14-Aug-19 17:36
Re: What Lehner actually said...... 60 Warwick 14-Aug-19 17:44
Re: What Lehner actually said...... 58 cladking 14-Aug-19 18:35
Re: What Lehner actually said...... 69 Warwick 14-Aug-19 19:37
Re: What Lehner actually said...... 62 cladking 14-Aug-19 20:21
The part you just do not get 61 Warwick 14-Aug-19 21:00
Re: The part you just do not get 57 Hanslune 14-Aug-19 22:53
Cladking still wrong 60 Hanslune 14-Aug-19 22:52
Nope still wrong 51 Hanslune 14-Aug-19 22:49
Well done Dr. 69 Hanslune 14-Aug-19 16:51
Re: Brichieri-Colombi’s HATNUB QUARRY Opposition Paper 74 Mike D 17-Aug-19 20:12
Re: Brichieri-Colombi’s HATNUB QUARRY Opposition Paper 101 Warwick 18-Aug-19 17:20
Re: Khufu’s Hatnub Ramp 64 Mike D 17-Aug-19 18:28
Re: Khufu’s Hatnub Ramp 74 Dr. Troglodyte 17-Aug-19 18:56


Sorry, only registered users may post in this forum.