Mysteries :  The Official GrahamHancock.com forums
For serious discussion of the controversies, approaches and enigmas surrounding the origins and development of the human species and of human civilization. (NB: for more ‘out there’ posts we point you in the direction of the ‘Paranormal & Supernatural’ Message Board). 
Welcome! Log InRegister
Hi Andy,

I was waiting ...... and you came very quickly with your punctual well prepared with very well articulated
arguments and in an ineccepible (out of any reasonable doubt) time line !

You wrote:
Quote

Having grown up in farm lands when I first saw the pictures of Gobekli Tepe I immediately thought of grain storage despite the claims of mystical temples.
It is not a mistery that often the definition of Temple, Sanctuary or religious figurines or statuettes has
always been named as ""form of religious or sacrality"" words which in our present cultures brought to the
mind the Egyptian, Greek and Roman Mistic Temples......

In short words when we have no clear idea of what we have found, we identify then by what is familiar and at hand.

As you well know in AE the administration of the grains where left and handled by "Priests" who were the
keepers and the dispenser of grains which were stored inside what we called Temple.

If we get out of our "stereotypes" about Religion and Temples / Sanctuary, we can easily see the reality
of the things:

Grains are the source of primary necessity food which people can have during the ""dead season" where the
plants of Barley, Weath and all we identify generally as Cereals looks as they were dead......
So being food indispensable for the life, of course the place of grains storage were seen as "Sacre".

And if we realise that inside such "Temples" were sculptured / depicted on columns or walls images of what
was the life of farnmers, like cattles poultry, livestock along with the enemies of them.... with also
some astronomic indications about the period of seeds, plants growing and crops, it sounds logical that
such places were considered sacred by the populations.

Then the "keepers and dispensers" of grains were who were able to understand the coming and ending the Seasons.... so they were the "sacred specialists" which assured to the population the right time-table of seeding, plants growing and then subsequent crops..... till the storage in proper builded places.

More.... clima changes pushed movements ... let say migration ... of population in search of food.
Then the needs to have somekind of "Army" to defend the land from the "foreign invaders in search of food".

More... there is another question which taking into consideration your point of view, Andy, explains why the ..."Temples"..
were intentionally and properly buried: Repeated drought periods and the consequent radical change in climate pushed
that peoiple to migrate in search of new appropriate places and they "Buried" what was a huge effort of their
ancestors who during flow of times builded such Storeages ""Tamples""... to preserve them in a possible view
of a coming back periods.....

To understand it, needs to not forget that we, human being, do NOT have the capacity to predict of what will be by
the next 100 year, and so in the next millennium.....

Thank you Andy to have brought to the light another (what and for sure will be discussed and polemized)piece
of the big puzzle of our important and forgot past.

Of course that are just my weird toughs of a simple country man.

Nice and bright day

Ivano

_______________________________________________________________
You can not solve a problem with the same kind of thinking that you used to create it.
A.Einstein



Edited 1 time(s). Last edit at 05-Aug-18 14:03 by Vanya.

Options: ReplyQuote


Subject Views Written By Posted
Gobekli Tepe - No Mystery? 1256 AndyBlackard 04-Aug-18 16:27
Timeline of Gobekli Tepe 511 AndyBlackard 04-Aug-18 16:28
Balkan Neolithic 247 Spiros 12-Aug-18 09:11
Pre-Pottery Neolithic sites 308 Spiros 12-Aug-18 09:22
Re: Gobekli Tepe - No Mystery? 504 AndyBlackard 04-Aug-18 16:32
Re: Gobekli Tepe - No Mystery? 322 Notinham 05-Aug-18 08:37
Re: Gobekli Tepe - No Mystery? 211 AndyBlackard 05-Aug-18 13:12
Re: Gobekli Tepe - No Mystery? 272 Notinham 07-Aug-18 19:58
Re: Gobekli Tepe - No Mystery? 264 Susan Doris 05-Aug-18 04:43
Re: Gobekli Tepe - No Mystery? 297 Vanya 05-Aug-18 13:13
Re: Gobekli Tepe - No Mystery? 233 gulsbo 05-Aug-18 15:24
Re: Gobekli Tepe - No Mystery? 181 AndyBlackard 05-Aug-18 19:36
Re: Gobekli Tepe - No Mystery? 508 Thanos5150 05-Aug-18 16:38
Re: Gobekli Tepe - No Mystery? 238 AndyBlackard 05-Aug-18 20:03
Re: Gobekli Tepe - No Mystery? 232 Thanos5150 06-Aug-18 02:10
Gobekli Tepe - Granary and Pub 268 Race Jackson 06-Aug-18 01:07
Re: Gobekli Tepe - Granary and Pub 191 Thanos5150 07-Aug-18 00:15
Re: Gobekli Tepe - Granary and Pub 260 Thanos5150 07-Aug-18 00:46
Re: Gobekli Tepe - No Mystery? 194 Susan Doris 06-Aug-18 12:11
Re: Gobekli Tepe - No Mystery? 186 Jon Ellison 06-Aug-18 13:29
Re: Gobekli Tepe - No Mystery? 154 Thanos5150 07-Aug-18 00:24
Re: Gobekli Tepe - No Mystery? 163 Susan Doris 07-Aug-18 05:15
Re: Gobekli Tepe - No Mystery? 174 Thanos5150 07-Aug-18 05:51
Re: Gobekli Tepe - No Mystery? 163 Susan Doris 07-Aug-18 09:35
Re: Gobekli Tepe - No Mystery? Where is the grain? 151 Eddie Larry 07-Aug-18 13:48
Re: Gobekli Tepe - No Mystery? Where is the grain? 170 AndyBlackard 07-Aug-18 18:47
Re: Gobekli Tepe - No Mystery? Where is the grain? 223 Thanos5150 08-Aug-18 02:20
Re: Gobekli Tepe - No Mystery? 187 Thunderbird 06-Aug-18 14:11
Some practical considerations 181 AndyBlackard 07-Aug-18 13:27
Re: Some practical considerations 164 lalbee 07-Aug-18 15:54
Re: Some practical considerations 153 AndyBlackard 07-Aug-18 18:21
Re: Gobekli Tepe - No Mystery? - Some may be due clarifications IMHO 263 Vanya 07-Aug-18 14:23
Re: Gobekli Tepe - No Mystery? - Some may be due clarifications IMHO 159 Eddie Larry 07-Aug-18 15:00
Re: Gobekli Tepe - No Mystery? - Some may be due clarifications IMHO 158 AndyBlackard 07-Aug-18 18:37
Re: Gobekli Tepe - No Mystery? - Some may be due clarifications IMHO 168 Eddie Larry 07-Aug-18 18:55
Plato’s reconstruction of ancient corporate gatherings 163 Eddie Larry 07-Aug-18 21:06


Sorry, only registered users may post in this forum.