Mysteries :  The Official GrahamHancock.com forums
For serious discussion of the controversies, approaches and enigmas surrounding the origins and development of the human species and of human civilization. (NB: for more ‘out there’ posts we point you in the direction of the ‘Paranormal & Supernatural’ Message Board). 
Welcome! Log InRegister
Barbelo Wrote:
-------------------------------------------------------
>
Quote
Almost 3 years ago I suggested the
> opposite sequence of G3 > G2 > G1 on the basis of
> the physical evidence. Skip to the end of this
> post for that comment.

>
>
>
> I did as you suggested and read through the OP,
> your comments and the lively discussion which
> followed. Please keep in mind that this thread is
> not about the order of construction of the
> pyramids. That is an entirely separate discussion.
> I am proposing that there may be no
> contemporaniety between the temples and the
> pyramids.
>
> The temples may have existed pre pyramids and that
> their purpose was not funerary which calls into
> question the widely held belief that, a priori,
> the pyramids were constructed solely for that same
> reason. Of course, if this were the case it
> further consolidates the suggestion that the
> causeways are also pre pyramids and therefore not
> pavements for the transportation of heavy
> materials nor processional ways for the funerals
> of kings, but must have served some other
> purpose.
>
> The absence of any megalithic construction at G1
> surely throws some doubt over the accepted
> paradigm.
>
> PWH

Thanks. Understood. My only point was to suggest that there are many other enigmas that also support your observation that things don't add up in the traditional Giza narrative. I totally agree that different proposals regarding the construction sequence of Mortuary Temple, Valley Temple, and causeway have different implications not only on the pyramid construction sequence but also on the original function of each of those structures. And when you further consider the Sphinx Enclosure, Wall of the Crow, Boat Pits, quarries, cemeteries, evidence of adapation and salvage, topography, etc., the traditional Dynastic funerary narrative becomes even more of a stretch.

Regarding your comment about the causeway construction sequence, I agree that if it came first it might not have been originally intended to be used as a monolith transport system. But that doesn't preclude the possibility that the causeways were eventually adapted for that purpose when the decision was made to construct the pyramids at the upper end of those causeways, just as I don't doubt that the pyramids were considered to have been adapted for a funerary purpose by the Dynastics long after the pyramids were constructed in pre-Dynastic times.

Do you have any detailed information about any structure that might have existed where we see G1's basalt patio today? We are told there was a Mortuary Temple there and that nothing remains from that structure today other than some indication of its foundation in the bedrock, but I haven't been able to locate any report which describes that foundation.

______________________________________________________________
How can any of us ever know, when all we can do is think?



Edited 1 time(s). Last edit at 12-Jun-18 10:59 by Origyptian.

Options: ReplyQuote


Subject Views Written By Posted
The Temples of Giza 826 Barbelo 11-Jun-18 01:13
Re: The Temples of Giza 222 Thunderbird 11-Jun-18 16:09
Re: The Temples of Giza 133 Thunderbird 11-Jun-18 18:22
Re: The Temples of Giza 144 Origyptian 11-Jun-18 22:23
Re: The Temples of Giza 134 Barbelo 12-Jun-18 04:23
Re: The Temples of Giza 153 DUNE 12-Jun-18 07:14
Re: The Temples of Giza 147 Barbelo 12-Jun-18 11:38
Re: The Temples of Giza 183 DUNE 12-Jun-18 12:07
Re: The Temples of Giza 122 Barbelo 12-Jun-18 21:56
Re: The Temples of Giza 128 Origyptian 12-Jun-18 22:13
Re: The Temples of Giza 108 Barbelo 12-Jun-18 23:40
Re: The Temples of Giza 105 Origyptian 13-Jun-18 22:08
Re: The Temples of Giza 120 Barbelo 13-Jun-18 22:39
Re: The Temples of Giza 98 Origyptian 14-Jun-18 14:11
Re: The Temples of Giza 178 Barbelo 14-Jun-18 21:08
Re: The Temples of Giza 141 Origyptian 12-Jun-18 10:57
Re: The Temples of Giza 144 Barbelo 12-Jun-18 11:57
Re: The Temples of Giza 185 Thanos5150 12-Jun-18 23:33
Re: The Temples of Giza 159 Thanos5150 13-Jun-18 00:21
Re: The Temples of Giza 152 Barbelo 13-Jun-18 02:54
Re: The Temples of Giza 246 Thanos5150 13-Jun-18 05:03
Re: The Temples of Giza 98 Thanos5150 13-Jun-18 05:23
Re: The Temples of Giza 89 Barbelo 13-Jun-18 05:29
Re: The Temples of Giza 113 Thanos5150 13-Jun-18 05:54
Re: The Temples of Giza 104 Origyptian 13-Jun-18 14:42
The Mortuary Temple of Menkaure 275 Barbelo 13-Jun-18 11:19


Sorry, only registered users may post in this forum.