Mysteries :  The Official GrahamHancock.com forums
For serious discussion of the controversies, approaches and enigmas surrounding the origins and development of the human species and of human civilization. (NB: for more ‘out there’ posts we point you in the direction of the ‘Paranormal & Supernatural’ Message Board). 
Welcome! Log InRegister
Atul Seth writes “I tried to find the MAN-TAR combination in the oxford online corpus but no result. However, there are quite decent occurrences of NAM-TAR which is interesting since it is an obvious reverse sound (MAN-NAM)”


The symbol NAM is an extraordinarily interesting one – a bird symbol. It’s also the origin of later words, of which Latin nam. It appears a lot in my translation as “for”, “in order to”. It’s used to designate the purpose of someone or something; the bird that moves things forward and introduces purpose. Sumerian NAM has other phonetic forms, and I’ve linked it to both alchemy and to the Persian Simurgh. The subject is vast, endless.

NAM-TAR refers to fate, where there is an end to progression, destiny cut short. It appears in my translation in connection with the disappearance of the beer. But then, this is a comedy. I also considered that beer swirling around the sky, no longer present on Earth, was a metaphor for a lack of light in the sky and a lack of resources below. There are echoes of catastrophe in the story.

“Of crows between mountains, of stones circling the sky, his tablet speaks. That beer, its fate cut short on Earth, flowing around Ara it will be.” (line 170 of the The Instructions of Shuruppak/The Story of Sukurru)

And you’re right to suggest the inversion with “man” as important. It's tempting to mention the possibility that this is the origin of our word “man”, unexplained as to its etymology by any dictionary. I daresay you thought of that too. Any word that has “from PIE root” as its origin is unexplained. Try breaking MAN down into two symbols by looking for it in the lexical entries. Then look for those meanings and see if they help.

Congratulations. You’ve got the general idea. The only word of caution is that context is all important. Without the context of a long translation or, at the very least, building a solid, reasonable web of meanings, it has no real value. And the meanings have multiple levels, spiritual but not only.

Madeleine

Options: ReplyQuote


Subject Views Written By Posted
The Wisdom of Hermes on Sumerian Clay Tablets 1161 MDaines 03-Jun-18 11:01
Re: The Wisdom of Hermes on Sumerian Clay Tablets 184 atul.seth 03-Jun-18 12:26
Re: The Wisdom of Hermes on Sumerian Clay Tablets 139 MDaines 04-Jun-18 10:31
Re: The Wisdom of Hermes on Sumerian Clay Tablets 100 atul.seth 05-Jun-18 12:10
Re: The Wisdom of Hermes on Sumerian Clay Tablets 87 MDaines 06-Jun-18 08:13
Re: The Wisdom of Hermes on Sumerian Clay Tablets 91 atul.seth 06-Jun-18 10:18
Re: The Wisdom of Hermes on Sumerian Clay Tablets 92 MDaines 07-Jun-18 08:26
Re: The Wisdom of Hermes on Sumerian Clay Tablets 69 atul.seth 10-Jun-18 12:44
Re: The Wisdom of Hermes on Sumerian Clay Tablets 105 MDaines 11-Jun-18 07:50
MAN-TRA the Sanskrit connection 83 MDaines 09-Jun-18 09:21
Re: MAN-TRA the Sanskrit connection 65 atul.seth 10-Jun-18 13:06
Re: MAN-TRA the Sanskrit connection 66 MDaines 11-Jun-18 07:44
Re: The Wisdom of Hermes on Sumerian Clay Tablets 93 MDaines 05-Jun-18 07:55
Re: The Wisdom of Hermes on Sumerian Clay Tablets 98 SallyA 07-Jun-18 04:26
Re: The Wisdom of Hermes on Sumerian Clay Tablets 106 MDaines 08-Jun-18 08:13
The Narmer Palette, an Egypto-Sumerian message 68 MDaines 25-Aug-18 10:12
Re: The Narmer Palette, an Egypto-Sumerian message 48 SallyA 25-Aug-18 23:26
Re: The Narmer Palette, an Egypto-Sumerian message 45 MDaines 31-Aug-18 07:26
Re: Timelines, feats really not impossible, and a new view on mythos? 45 SallyA 31-Aug-18 19:44
Re: The Wisdom of Hermes on Sumerian Clay Tablets 49 Cyrusapollo 07-Sep-18 04:49
Re: The Wisdom of Hermes on Sumerian Clay Tablets 39 MDaines 08-Sep-18 07:25
Re: The Wisdom of Hermes on Sumerian Clay Tablets 28 SallyA 11-Sep-18 20:45
Re: The Wisdom of Hermes on Sumerian Clay Tablets 45 MDaines 12-Sep-18 10:56
The Asclepius 25 MDaines 18-Sep-18 18:25
Re: The Asclepius . . . ;-) 23 SallyA 18-Sep-18 19:05
Hermes and the Ring of Truth 23 MDaines 20-Sep-18 14:29
Re: Hermes and the Ring of Truth 25 Thunderbird 20-Sep-18 20:14
Re: Hermes and the Ring of Truth 19 MDaines 21-Sep-18 07:56


Sorry, only registered users may post in this forum.