Mysteries :  The Official GrahamHancock.com forums
For serious discussion of the controversies, approaches and enigmas surrounding the origins and development of the human species and of human civilization. (NB: for more ‘out there’ posts we point you in the direction of the ‘Paranormal & Supernatural’ Message Board). 
Welcome! Log InRegister
Thanos5150 Wrote:
-------------------------------------------------------
> Hello Avry.
>
> R Avry Wilson Wrote:
> --------------------------------------------------
> -----
> > Hi Lee,
> >
> > Trying hard to agree with the suggestions made
> > using the results of the study. I would be
> remiss
> > not to say there was _some_ influence from the
> > Middle East region .. same for Sub-Saharan. But
> > the major formation of the ancient Egyptian
> > culture is Nilotic. QED.
>
> And where do you think this non-black African
> Nilotic stock originally came from?

Northeast Africa. Indigenous. Always there.

Curiously,
> human activity along the Nile between roughly
> 9,000-6,000BC was surprisingly sparse

On what do you base this sparseness? Under what circumstances do you propose the Nile valley was sparsely populated when we have a million-year hominid occupation and the form of a river which supplies a natural base of sustenance? Was it abandoned at some point, leaving a few hangers-on, only to be repopulated from external regions?

[snip]

I got to writing a lengthy reply, but realized it was turning into something I couldn't possibly contain to a few hours of research and memory popping - more like weeks. I thought better to cut to the chase and ask you:

Is it your position the ancient Egyptian culture (even pre-dynastic) is wholly influenced and generated from Mesopotamian people, i.e Fertile Crescent inhabitants? That nothing is indigenous to Nilotic peoples, and certainly not Sub-Saharan? The whole thing is actually Meso, QED?

Options: ReplyQuote


Subject Views Written By Posted
DNA Study Reveals AE Closely Related to Levant and Anatolian Populations 2435 Thanos5150 02-Jun-17 15:42
Re: DNA Study Reveals AE Closely Related to Levant and Anatolian Populations 676 Laird Scranton 02-Jun-17 15:53
Re: DNA Study Reveals AE Closely Related to Levant and Anatolian Populations 606 Thanos5150 02-Jun-17 18:08
Re: DNA Study Reveals AE Closely Related to Levant and Anatolian Populations 637 Laird Scranton 02-Jun-17 20:08
Re: DNA Study Reveals AE Closely Related to Levant and Anatolian Populations 644 Thanos5150 02-Jun-17 23:19
Re: DNA Study Reveals AE Closely Related to Levant and Anatolian Populations 618 Laird Scranton 03-Jun-17 03:56
Re: DNA Study Reveals AE Closely Related to Levant and Anatolian Populations 575 Notinham 03-Jun-17 05:04
Re: DNA Study Reveals AE Closely Related to Levant and Anatolian Populations 549 Thanos5150 03-Jun-17 14:49
Re: DNA Study Reveals AE Closely Related to Levant and Anatolian Populations 535 Notinham 03-Jun-17 16:00
Re: DNA Study Reveals AE Closely Related to Levant and Anatolian Populations 791 Eddie Larry 04-Jun-17 00:38
Re: DNA Study Reveals AE Closely Related to Levant and Anatolian Populations 374 Heliograph 29-Jun-17 11:06
Re: DNA Study Reveals AE Closely Related to Levant and Anatolian Populations 464 Eddie Larry 29-Jun-17 14:16
Re: DNA Study Reveals AE Closely Related to Levant and Anatolian Populations 470 Thanos5150 29-Jun-17 16:33
Re: DNA Study Reveals AE Closely Related to Levant and Anatolian Populations 607 Notinham 02-Jun-17 16:06
Ancient Egyptians were closely related to people who lived along the eastern Mediterranean 594 HH Holmes 26-Jun-17 19:38
Mod Note > Duplicate Topic Merged 466 Dr. Troglodyte 27-Jun-17 12:39
Re: DNA Study Reveals AE Closely Related to Levant and Anatolian Populations 496 Heliograph 29-Jun-17 10:53
Re: DNA Study Reveals AE Closely Related to Levant and Anatolian Populations 495 MDaines 29-Jun-17 14:06
Re: DNA Study Reveals AE Closely Related to Levant and Anatolian Populations 555 Thanos5150 29-Jun-17 16:25
Re: DNA Study Reveals AE Closely Related to Levant and Anatolian Populations 494 MDaines 30-Jun-17 10:56
Re: DNA Study Reveals AE Closely Related to Levant and Anatolian Populations 537 Thanos5150 30-Jun-17 13:56
Egyptian Style Head? 486 Dr. Troglodyte 30-Jun-17 14:30
Re: Egyptian Style Head? 539 Eddie Larry 30-Jun-17 14:36
Re: DNA Study Reveals AE Closely Related to Levant and Anatolian Populations 473 MDaines 01-Jul-17 07:53
Re: DNA Study Reveals AE Closely Related to Levant and Anatolian Populations 549 Thanos5150 01-Jul-17 17:28
Re: DNA Study Reveals AE Closely Related to Levant and Anatolian Populations 454 Eddie Larry 01-Jul-17 18:17
Re: DNA Study Reveals AE Closely Related to Levant and Anatolian Populations 570 Thanos5150 01-Jul-17 18:38
Re: DNA Study Reveals AE Closely Related to Levant and Anatolian Populations 558 MDaines 01-Jul-17 19:58
Re: DNA Study Reveals AE Closely Related to Levant and Anatolian Populations 575 Thanos5150 03-Jul-17 14:05
Re: DNA Study Reveals AE Closely Related to Levant and Anatolian Populations 484 Thanos5150 29-Jun-17 16:39
Re: DNA Study Reveals AE Closely Related to Levant and Anatolian Populations 402 R Avry Wilson 29-Jun-17 17:10
Cuneiform vs Hieroglyph 568 Dr. Troglodyte 29-Jun-17 18:22
Re: Cuneiform vs Hieroglyph 479 Thanos5150 01-Jul-17 20:19
Re: Cuneiform vs Hieroglyph 521 Thanos5150 08-Jul-17 16:12
Re: Cuneiform vs Hieroglyph 279 Eddie Larry 08-Jul-17 18:04
Re: Cuneiform vs Hieroglyph 429 Thanos5150 08-Jul-17 19:30
Re: DNA Study Reveals AE Closely Related to Levant and Anatolian Populations 375 Thanos5150 30-Jun-17 20:09
Re: DNA Study Reveals AE Closely Related to Levant and Anatolian Populations 425 R Avry Wilson 01-Jul-17 01:55
Re: DNA Study Reveals AE Closely Related to Levant and Anatolian Populations 421 Thanos5150 01-Jul-17 03:15
Re: DNA Study Reveals AE Closely Related to Levant and Anatolian Populations 536 R Avry Wilson 02-Jul-17 22:02
Re: DNA Study Reveals AE Closely Related to Levant and Anatolian Populations 436 MDaines 03-Jul-17 08:04
Re: DNA Study Reveals AE Closely Related to Levant and Anatolian Populations 472 Thanos5150 03-Jul-17 14:10
Re: DNA Study Reveals AE Closely Related to Levant and Anatolian Populations 413 Thanos5150 03-Jul-17 16:58
Re: DNA Study Reveals AE Closely Related to Levant and Anatolian Populations 506 R Avry Wilson 03-Jul-17 22:56
Re: DNA Study Reveals AE Closely Related to Levant and Anatolian Populations 352 Thanos5150 04-Jul-17 21:55
The scientific study 360 drrayeye 04-Jul-17 11:09
Re: DNA Study Reveals AE Closely Related to Levant and Anatolian Populations 494 Notinham 03-Jul-17 14:17
Re: DNA Study Reveals AE Closely Related to Levant and Anatolian Populations 500 Brian Patterson 04-Jul-17 17:58
The genetic evidence 554 drrayeye 04-Jul-17 19:48
Re: The genetic evidence 386 Brian Patterson 05-Jul-17 12:45
Re: The genetic evidence 412 drrayeye 05-Jul-17 15:40
Re: DNA Study Reveals AE Closely Related to Levant and Anatolian Populations 586 lostsheep 04-Jul-17 22:34


Sorry, only registered users may post in this forum.