Mysteries :  The Official GrahamHancock.com forums
For serious discussion of the controversies, approaches and enigmas surrounding the origins and development of the human species and of human civilization. (NB: for more ‘out there’ posts we point you in the direction of the ‘Paranormal & Supernatural’ Message Board). 
Welcome! Log InRegister
Steve Clayton Wrote:
-------------------------------------------------------
> Cladking wrote:
>
> >Logic says that on a gargantuan project that a
> highly efficient means must be used.
>
> OK Cladking, you have been telling me they lifted
> the stones one step at a time for years. Herodotus
> said they used levers, one step at a time. I have
> tried many different designs how that could be
> done. None of them worked, until now. My latest
> Sketchup design is quick and fool prof. No water
> involved. Before I exhibit this design for
> scrutiny, do you have the passage where Herodotus
> mentioned levers. I have read that here on the
> blog, though I do not know how accurate the word
> lever is.
>
> I have a little more to clean up in my model. If
> you have something, please let me know. I am
> excited to show this off. No ramps. For once, it
> musta been done this way... will have some
> meaning.

There are various translations and interpretations of Herodotus. I don't believe he ever used the word 'lever" though many people interpret "short timbers" or short pieces of wood" as "levers". Some people interpret the "machines that can be carried to other levels" as "levers" and I have seen "levers' appear in translations.

You certainly don't need water to lift stones 80' at a time. Men hauling on ropes from the tops of these "mounds" would be very efficient. However a great deal of work is required no matter how efficient they could be unless they had water at 80' and then there would be no work at all for humans since the natural phenomenon which lifted the water to 80' would do all the work.

I believe it's within the realm of reason to hypothesize men dragged the stones straight up the side 80' at a time but that the evidence suggests this didn't happen either and that it was water that lifted them.

There would have needed to have been about 8,000 men just to pull these stones up and there's no evidence for so many. There probably would have been "Overseers of Stone Lifters" and similar such occupations that are not in evidence.

I look forward to your drawings and thinking.

Man fears the pyramid, time fears man.

Options: ReplyQuote


Subject Views Written By Posted
Giza Water Canals? 1040 Steve Clayton 18-Feb-17 05:21
Re: Giza Water Canals? 286 Steve Clayton 18-Feb-17 17:46
Re: Giza Water Canals? 389 Dr. Troglodyte 21-Feb-17 20:55
Re: Giza Water Canals? 230 Warwick 21-Feb-17 21:08
Re: Giza Water Canals? 195 cladking 21-Feb-17 21:33
Re: Giza Water Canals? 299 Dr. Troglodyte 21-Feb-17 23:16
Re: Giza Water Canals? 401 cladking 22-Feb-17 04:20
Re: Giza Water Canals? 247 Steve Clayton 22-Feb-17 15:36
Re: Giza Water Canals? 229 cladking 22-Feb-17 20:32
Re: Giza Water Canals? 293 Hanslune 22-Feb-17 21:39
Re: Giza Water Canals? 277 cladking 23-Feb-17 01:22
Cladking makes up stuff - come see 329 Hanslune 23-Feb-17 01:30
Re: Cladking makes up stuff - come see 278 cladking 23-Feb-17 01:45
Re: Cladking makes up stuff - come see 272 Hanslune 23-Feb-17 19:01
Re: Cladking makes up stuff - come see 357 eyeofhorus33 23-Feb-17 20:15
Re: Cladking makes up stuff - come see 228 Hanslune 23-Feb-17 20:48
Re: Cladking makes up stuff - come see 350 cladking 23-Feb-17 21:10
Re: Cladking makes up stuff - come see 276 Hanslune 23-Feb-17 21:15
Re: Cladking makes up stuff - come see 275 cladking 23-Feb-17 21:55
Re: Cladking makes up stuff - come see 265 Hanslune 23-Feb-17 22:12
Re: Cladking makes up stuff - come see 276 cladking 23-Feb-17 22:26
Re: Cladking makes up stuff - come see 279 Hanslune 23-Feb-17 22:31
Re: Cladking makes up stuff - come see 291 cladking 24-Feb-17 16:49
Re: Cladking makes up stuff - come see 260 cladking 24-Feb-17 17:05
Re: Cladking makes up stuff - come see 284 cladking 23-Feb-17 20:44
Re: Cladking makes up stuff - come see 352 Hanslune 23-Feb-17 21:56
Re: Cladking makes up stuff - come see 323 cladking 23-Feb-17 22:18
Re: Cladking makes up stuff - come see 204 cladking 23-Feb-17 22:22
Re: Cladking makes up stuff - come see 203 Hanslune 23-Feb-17 22:45
Re: Cladking makes up stuff - come see 270 Hanslune 23-Feb-17 22:44
Re: Cladking makes up stuff - come see 282 cladking 23-Feb-17 23:13
Re: Cladking makes up stuff - come see 291 Steve Clayton 23-Feb-17 20:45
Re: Cladking makes up stuff - come see 266 Hanslune 23-Feb-17 20:59
Re: Cladking makes up stuff - come see 257 Steve Clayton 23-Feb-17 23:02
Re: Cladking makes up stuff - come see 278 Hanslune 23-Feb-17 23:10
Re: Cladking makes up stuff - come see 377 Steve Clayton 24-Feb-17 00:21
Re: Cladking makes up stuff - come see 310 cladking 23-Feb-17 21:21
abstract plus. 316 cladking 23-Feb-17 21:06
Re: abstract plus. 502 Hanslune 23-Feb-17 22:05
Re: abstract plus. 234 cladking 23-Feb-17 22:47
Re: abstract plus. 277 Hanslune 23-Feb-17 22:59
Re: abstract plus. 253 cladking 23-Feb-17 23:26
Re: abstract plus. 264 eyeofhorus33 24-Feb-17 19:19
Re: abstract plus. 308 cladking 24-Feb-17 21:52
One step at a time... 446 Steve Clayton 24-Feb-17 22:56
Re: One step at a time... 305 cladking 25-Feb-17 00:16
Re: One step at a time... 204 Steve Clayton 25-Feb-17 02:00
Re: Giza Water Canals? 268 Hanslune 22-Feb-17 04:27
Re: Giza Water Canals? 269 Dr. Troglodyte 22-Feb-17 15:27
Re: Giza Water Canals? 228 cladking 22-Feb-17 20:36
Re: Giza Water Canals? 243 Hanslune 22-Feb-17 21:28
Re: Giza Water Canals? 390 Steve Clayton 22-Feb-17 13:07
Re: Giza Water Canals? 512 Steve Clayton 22-Feb-17 14:11
Re: Giza Water Canals? 385 SandyJesse 26-Feb-17 00:07


Sorry, only registered users may post in this forum.