Mysteries :  The Official GrahamHancock.com forums
For serious discussion of the controversies, approaches and enigmas surrounding the origins and development of the human species and of human civilization. (NB: for more ‘out there’ posts we point you in the direction of the ‘Paranormal & Supernatural’ Message Board). 
Welcome! Log InRegister
OK Martin.

Firstly me - my name is not John Smith or LonelyAngel. It is Sean Hunter. Why the pseudonym? I'm a Doctor Who fan, and both names are names used by or used to address the Doctor. Nerdy enough for you? Unlike you and Scott and others, I tend not to use or broadcast my own name on the Internet, as I have no particular agenda to promote, or axe to grind, or reputation to build or protect. Call it cowardice, but I was the victim of identity theft in 2011 and therefore put no private or personal details online (don't use Facebook or Twitter).

What right have I to express an opinion or question anything or anyone? No more or less than anyone else using a free Internet forum.

What authority or position do I hold? None.

What authority or position does Jason Colavito hold? No more than me.

He is called an "independent writer and researcher". Just like Scott Creighton. Yet every qualification (engineer? historian? writer? researcher?) of Scott's is questioned and denied on here, yet this Jason fellow's right to judge and review Scott's book is unquestioned by you and loveritus and everyone else on here.

So because Jason Nobody expresses an opinion you agree with, he is an authority. Big man on campus? really? You expect to get away with this hogwash unchallenged?

Martin, on my own experience alone, I would regard YOU as the foremost expert in the defence of Vyse. No doubt about that. i could be wrong, but I hold you in that regard. You could be wrong, but you know your stuff, you have done your research, and you believe passionately in your orthodoxy. This Jason Nobody is just another Internet hack out to trash someone's book.

Who is this guy? An absolute nobody, just like me.

The difference is, I know what I am and I don't expect intelligent people to quote me just because I dress my opinions up in a blog.

Options: ReplyQuote


Subject Views Written By Posted
Creighton v Vyse : Court Resumes 3265 loveritas 25-Sep-16 10:45
Re: Creighton v Vyse : Court Resumes 916 cladking 25-Sep-16 13:25
Re: Creighton v Vyse : Court Resumes 981 Martin Stower 25-Sep-16 13:47
Re: Creighton v Vyse : Court Resumes 913 cladking 25-Sep-16 13:57
Re: Creighton v Vyse : Court Resumes 810 D-Archer 26-Sep-16 13:40
"The book is downright uninteresting" yet he couldn't wait to write lengthy hatchet job review 977 LonelyAngel 25-Sep-16 16:52
My Lord, I call a surprise witness: SCOTT CREIGHTON 1010 LonelyAngel 25-Sep-16 16:54
Re: My Lord, I call a surprise witness: SCOTT CREIGHTON 973 Martin Stower 25-Sep-16 18:52
Re: My Lord, I call a surprise witness: SCOTT CREIGHTON 806 LonelyAngel 26-Sep-16 14:37
Re: My Lord, I call a surprise witness: SCOTT CREIGHTON 898 Martin Stower 26-Sep-16 19:36
Re: My Lord, I call a surprise witness: SCOTT CREIGHTON 884 Martin Stower 25-Sep-16 19:42
Re: My Lord, I call a surprise witness: SCOTT CREIGHTON 852 Thanos5150 25-Sep-16 21:05
Re: My Lord, I call a surprise witness: SCOTT CREIGHTON 808 Martin Stower 25-Sep-16 23:11
Re: "The book is downright uninteresting" yet he couldn't wait to write lengthy hatchet job review 832 Martin Stower 25-Sep-16 17:48
Re: "The book is downright uninteresting" yet he couldn't wait to write lengthy hatchet job review 797 LonelyAngel 25-Sep-16 18:05
Re: "The book is downright uninteresting" yet he couldn't wait to write lengthy hatchet job review 825 Martin Stower 25-Sep-16 18:19
Re: "The book is downright uninteresting" yet he couldn't wait to write lengthy hatchet job review 858 LonelyAngel 25-Sep-16 19:35
Re: "The book is downright uninteresting" yet he couldn't wait to write lengthy hatchet job review 778 Martin Stower 25-Sep-16 19:53
Re: "The book is downright uninteresting" yet he couldn't wait to write lengthy hatchet job review 741 LonelyAngel 25-Sep-16 20:00
Re: "The book is downright uninteresting" yet he couldn't wait to write lengthy hatchet job review 845 Martin Stower 25-Sep-16 20:16
Re: "The book is downright uninteresting" yet he couldn't wait to write lengthy hatchet job review 871 LonelyAngel 25-Sep-16 20:50
Re: "The book is downright uninteresting" yet he couldn't wait to write lengthy hatchet job review 767 Martin Stower 25-Sep-16 23:07
Right To Review. 760 DScribr 26-Sep-16 13:31
Re: Right To Review. 796 Martin Stower 26-Sep-16 20:23
Re: Right To Review. 767 DScribr 27-Sep-16 03:34
Re: "The book is downright uninteresting" yet he couldn't wait to write lengthy hatchet job review 864 R Avry Wilson 25-Sep-16 21:24
Re: "The book is downright uninteresting" yet he couldn't wait to write lengthy hatchet job review 841 LonelyAngel 25-Sep-16 21:33
Re: "The book is downright uninteresting" yet he couldn't wait to write lengthy hatchet job review 866 R Avry Wilson 26-Sep-16 01:17
Re: "The book is downright uninteresting" yet he couldn't wait to write lengthy hatchet job review 919 cladking 26-Sep-16 02:03
Re: "The book is downright uninteresting" yet he couldn't wait to write lengthy hatchet job review 847 Martin Stower 26-Sep-16 09:26
Re: "The book is downright uninteresting" yet he couldn't wait to write lengthy hatchet job review 797 cladking 26-Sep-16 13:52
Re: "The book is downright uninteresting" yet he couldn't wait to write lengthy hatchet job review 815 Martin Stower 30-Sep-16 00:06
Re: "The book is downright uninteresting" yet he couldn't wait to write lengthy hatchet job review 830 cladking 30-Sep-16 01:33
Re: "The book is downright uninteresting" yet he couldn't wait to write lengthy hatchet job review 833 LonelyAngel 26-Sep-16 14:21
Re: "The book is downright uninteresting" yet he couldn't wait to write lengthy hatchet job review 658 cladking 26-Sep-16 15:04
Re: "The book is downright uninteresting" yet he couldn't wait to write lengthy hatchet job review 799 LonelyAngel 26-Sep-16 13:48
Re: "The book is downright uninteresting" yet he couldn't wait to write lengthy hatchet job review 788 Martin Stower 26-Sep-16 20:12
Re: "The book is downright uninteresting" yet he couldn't wait to write lengthy hatchet job review 790 R Avry Wilson 26-Sep-16 21:36
Re: "The book is downright uninteresting" yet he couldn't wait to write lengthy hatchet job review 727 cladking 26-Sep-16 21:43
Re: "The book is downright uninteresting" yet he couldn't wait to write lengthy hatchet job review 760 Martin Stower 26-Sep-16 01:40
Re: "The book is downright uninteresting" yet he couldn't wait to write lengthy hatchet job review 860 cladking 25-Sep-16 21:49
Re: "The book is downright uninteresting" yet he couldn't wait to write lengthy hatchet job review 832 LonelyAngel 25-Sep-16 22:07
Re: "The book is downright uninteresting" yet he couldn't wait to write lengthy hatchet job review 782 cladking 25-Sep-16 22:18
Re: "The book is downright uninteresting" yet he couldn't wait to write lengthy hatchet job review 855 Martin Stower 25-Sep-16 22:45
Re: "The book is downright uninteresting" yet he couldn't wait to write lengthy hatchet job review 862 LonelyAngel 26-Sep-16 10:31
Re: "The book is downright uninteresting" yet he couldn't wait to write lengthy hatchet job review 753 Origyptian 26-Sep-16 15:29
Re: "The book is downright uninteresting" yet he couldn't wait to write lengthy hatchet job review 865 LonelyAngel 26-Sep-16 15:44
Re: "The book is downright uninteresting" yet he couldn't wait to write lengthy hatchet job review 832 Martin Stower 27-Sep-16 13:13
Re: "The book is downright uninteresting" yet he couldn't wait to write lengthy hatchet job review 908 Martin Stower 26-Sep-16 18:11
Re: The New Inquisition 929 Thunderbird 26-Sep-16 20:35
Re: The New Inquisition 737 Martin Stower 26-Sep-16 20:43
Re: The New Inquisition 698 cladking 26-Sep-16 21:24
Re: The New Inquisition 782 Martin Stower 26-Sep-16 21:53
Re: The New Inquisition 810 cladking 26-Sep-16 23:27
Re: The New Inquisition 763 Thanos5150 26-Sep-16 23:31
Re: The New Inquisition 759 cladking 27-Sep-16 01:25
The old copy/paste trick....... 868 DScribr 28-Sep-16 00:28
Re: The Conspiracy 732 Thunderbird 27-Sep-16 00:58
Is Jason Colavito a credible expert witness? 1272 drrayeye 26-Sep-16 17:01
Re: Is Jason Colavito a credible expert witness? 1049 eyeofhorus33 26-Sep-16 19:54
Re: Is Jason Colavito a credible expert witness? 856 drrayeye 26-Sep-16 20:26
Re: Is Jason Colavito a credible expert witness? 786 M. J. Thomas 26-Sep-16 20:20
Re: Is Jason Colavito a credible expert witness? 798 cladking 26-Sep-16 21:31
Lover's premise 885 drrayeye 26-Sep-16 22:18
Re: Lover's premise 768 Martin Stower 26-Sep-16 22:20
Jason Colavito IS a credible expert witness! 882 DScribr 27-Sep-16 18:39
Re: Jason Colavito IS a credible expert witness! 1004 Martin Stower 27-Sep-16 19:16
Re: Jason Colavito IS a credible expert witness! (I swear it!!!) 989 DScribr 28-Sep-16 00:21
Re: Is Jason Colavito a credible expert witness? 845 Barbelo 26-Sep-16 20:38
Re: Is Jason Colavito a credible expert witness? 800 Martin Stower 26-Sep-16 20:47
Oh Oh 884 drrayeye 26-Sep-16 22:20
Re: Oh Oh 725 Martin Stower 26-Sep-16 22:25
Re: Oh Oh 857 Barbelo 26-Sep-16 22:26
Re: Oh Oh 763 drrayeye 27-Sep-16 06:33
You're Not On The Same Page 835 Barbelo 27-Sep-16 10:19
You've got a lot to learn 859 drrayeye 29-Sep-16 05:36
Re: You've got a lot to learn 870 Barbelo 29-Sep-16 07:04
Re: You've got a lot to learn 769 Martin Stower 29-Sep-16 14:13
Re: You've got a lot to learn 803 DScribr 29-Sep-16 18:23
Re: You've got a lot to learn 715 Origyptian 29-Sep-16 14:58
Re: You've got a lot to learn 933 Martin Stower 29-Sep-16 15:16
Can anyone be a credible expert witness? 766 cladking 27-Sep-16 04:10
Re: Can anyone be a credible expert witness? 861 Thanos5150 27-Sep-16 06:02
Re: Can anyone be a credible expert witness? 772 Barbelo 27-Sep-16 10:23
Re: Can anyone be a credible expert witness? 826 cladking 27-Sep-16 15:14
Re: Can anyone be a credible expert witness? 768 Barbelo 27-Sep-16 21:11
Living in the dark ages. 752 cladking 27-Sep-16 14:00
Re: Living in the dark ages. 808 Origyptian 27-Sep-16 14:35
Re: Living in the dark ages. 815 cladking 27-Sep-16 14:51
Re: Living in the dark ages. 814 Origyptian 27-Sep-16 15:33
Re: Living in the dark ages. 783 cladking 27-Sep-16 16:11
Re: Living in the dark ages. 763 Barbelo 27-Sep-16 21:16
Re: Living in the dark ages. 759 Origyptian 27-Sep-16 21:36
Re: Living in the dark ages. 725 Martin Stower 29-Sep-16 14:16
Re: Living in the dark ages. 803 Origyptian 29-Sep-16 14:31
Re: Living in the dark ages. 765 Martin Stower 29-Sep-16 15:33
Re: Living in the dark ages. 923 Thanos5150 27-Sep-16 16:54
Re: Living in the dark ages. 852 cladking 27-Sep-16 17:22
Re: Living in the dark ages. 767 Thanos5150 27-Sep-16 18:02
Re: Living in the dark ages. 770 cladking 27-Sep-16 18:14
Oooohh... touchy 979 LonelyAngel 05-Oct-16 19:03
Re: Oooohh... touchy 737 Martin Stower 05-Oct-16 19:24
Re: Oooohh... touchy 959 LonelyAngel 05-Oct-16 19:37
Re: Oooohh... touchy 845 Martin Stower 05-Oct-16 21:08
Re: Oooohh... touchy 811 LonelyAngel 05-Oct-16 21:35
Re: Oooohh... touchy 614 Martin Stower 05-Oct-16 21:37
Re: Oooohh... touchy 812 LonelyAngel 05-Oct-16 21:41
Re: Oooohh... touchy 739 Martin Stower 05-Oct-16 22:00
Re: Oooohh... touchy 881 LonelyAngel 06-Oct-16 09:43
Re: Oooohh... touchy 795 Martin Stower 06-Oct-16 11:56
Re: Oooohh... touchy 804 LonelyAngel 06-Oct-16 13:44
Re: Oooohh... touchy 666 earllt 06-Oct-16 14:33
Re: Oooohh... touchy 704 Martin Stower 06-Oct-16 15:22
Re: Oooohh... touchy 769 Martin Stower 06-Oct-16 15:19
Re: Oooohh... touchy 752 LonelyAngel 06-Oct-16 15:28
Re: Oooohh... touchy 873 Martin Stower 06-Oct-16 20:18
Re: Oooohh... touchy 774 LonelyAngel 07-Oct-16 10:00
Re: Oooohh... touchy 690 Martin Stower 07-Oct-16 10:37
Re: Oooohh... touchy 670 LonelyAngel 07-Oct-16 10:40
Re: Oooohh... touchy 707 Martin Stower 07-Oct-16 11:26
Re: Oooohh... touchy 762 LonelyAngel 07-Oct-16 11:58
Re: Oooohh... touchy 725 Martin Stower 07-Oct-16 12:10
Re: Oooohh... touchy 769 LonelyAngel 07-Oct-16 12:45
Re: Oooohh... touchy 753 Martin Stower 07-Oct-16 13:05
Re: Oooohh... touchy 741 LonelyAngel 07-Oct-16 13:35
Re: Oooohh... touchy 751 Martin Stower 07-Oct-16 13:42
Re: Oooohh... touchy 751 LonelyAngel 07-Oct-16 13:48
Re: Oooohh... touchy 671 Martin Stower 07-Oct-16 13:55
Re: Oooohh... touchy 727 LonelyAngel 07-Oct-16 14:00
Re: Oooohh... touchy 778 Martin Stower 07-Oct-16 14:47
Re: Oooohh... touchy 758 LonelyAngel 07-Oct-16 15:01
Re: Oooohh... touchy 741 Martin Stower 07-Oct-16 15:22
Re: Oooohh... touchy 619 LonelyAngel 07-Oct-16 15:47
Re: Oooohh... touchy 713 Martin Stower 07-Oct-16 16:37
Re: Oooohh... touchy 745 Jon Ellison 07-Oct-16 17:12
Re: Oooohh... touchy 726 Martin Stower 07-Oct-16 18:22
Re: Oooohh... touchy 748 Jon Ellison 07-Oct-16 18:41
Re: Oooohh... touchy 743 Martin Stower 07-Oct-16 19:02
Re: Oooohh... touchy 718 LonelyAngel 07-Oct-16 20:01
Re: Oooohh... touchy 696 Martin Stower 07-Oct-16 20:58
Re: Oooohh... touchy 710 LonelyAngel 07-Oct-16 21:52
Re: Oooohh... touchy 1060 Martin Stower 07-Oct-16 22:35
Re: Oooohh... touchy 802 LonelyAngel 08-Oct-16 10:29
Re: Oooohh... touchy 720 Morten 08-Oct-16 15:36
Re: Oooohh... touchy 662 LonelyAngel 08-Oct-16 17:35
Re: Oooohh... touchy 748 LonelyAngel 08-Oct-16 17:41
Re: Oooohh... touchy 916 Martin Stower 08-Oct-16 20:01
Gottfried Wilhelm Leibniz 643 LonelyAngel 08-Oct-16 20:14
Re: Gottfried Wilhelm Leibniz 716 Martin Stower 08-Oct-16 20:35
Philosophy: Schrödinger's cat 657 LonelyAngel 08-Oct-16 21:03
Re: Philosophy: Schrödinger's cat 790 Martin Stower 08-Oct-16 21:50
Re: Philosophy: Schrödinger's cat 693 LonelyAngel 09-Oct-16 09:22
Re: Philosophy: Schrödinger's cat 721 Martin Stower 09-Oct-16 16:46
Re: Philosophy: Schrödinger's cat 759 LonelyAngel 10-Oct-16 10:27
Re: Philosophy: Schrödinger's cat 938 Martin Stower 10-Oct-16 17:12
Re: Philosophy: Schrödinger's cat 631 LonelyAngel 11-Oct-16 13:32
Re: Philosophy: Schrödinger's cat 745 Martin Stower 11-Oct-16 16:54
Re: Philosophy: Schrödinger's cat 679 LonelyAngel 11-Oct-16 16:59
Re: Philosophy: Schrödinger's cat 754 Martin Stower 11-Oct-16 17:36
Re: Philosophy: Schrödinger's cat 679 randompHactor 11-Oct-16 17:38
Re: Philosophy: Schrödinger's cat 697 eyeofhorus33 11-Oct-16 18:10
The Three Stooges 853 LonelyAngel 11-Oct-16 19:52
Re: The Three Stooges 810 eyeofhorus33 11-Oct-16 19:55
Re: The Three Stooges 874 Martin Stower 11-Oct-16 23:02
Re: The Three Stooges 822 Luminescence 12-Oct-16 01:03
Re: Oooohh... touchy 773 Thunderbird 06-Oct-16 17:59
Racing for the Cliffs. 804 cladking 06-Oct-16 14:10
Re: Racing for the Cliffs. 690 LonelyAngel 06-Oct-16 14:33
Re: Racing for the Cliffs. 698 Jon Ellison 06-Oct-16 14:39
Re: Racing for the Cliffs. 769 LonelyAngel 06-Oct-16 14:41
Re: Racing for the Cliffs. 859 Jon Ellison 06-Oct-16 14:48


Sorry, only registered users may post in this forum.