Mysteries :  The Official GrahamHancock.com forums
For serious discussion of the controversies, approaches and enigmas surrounding the origins and development of the human species and of human civilization. (NB: for more ‘out there’ posts we point you in the direction of the ‘Paranormal & Supernatural’ Message Board). 
Welcome! Log InRegister
LonelyAngel Wrote:
-------------------------------------------------------
> Latest edition of ATLANTIS RISING:
>
> [shop.atlantisrising.com]

The sampler is here:

http://www.atlantisrising.com/120Sampler.pdf

We may take as an example of Creighton’s nonsense this:

“. . . Prying open the lid of the granite container, Belzoni was astonished to find, not a king’s mummy, but a granite box filled with nothing more than ordinary earth.”

Compare this with Belzoni’s description of what happened:

https://books.google.co.uk/books?id=N38EAAAAYAAJ&pg=PA271&dq=belzoni+sarcophagus+earth+bones

Has Creighton represented this carefully and accurately? His statement scarcely matches even his own earlier account of this episode:

https://books.google.co.uk/books?id=hLLYBQAAQBAJ&pg=PT173&dq=belzoni+sarcophagus+earth+bones

Added 2020-12-04: Alternative URL (as that one is stale):

https://www.google.co.uk/search?tbm=bks&q=intitle:chamber+intitle:osiris+belzoni+%22he+found+earth+and+bones%22

M.

Edited 2020-12-04 to add URL.

Edited 2020-12-04 to fix the note above.



Edited 2 time(s). Last edit at 04-Dec-20 14:42 by Martin Stower.

Options: ReplyQuote


Subject Views Written By Posted
Creighton v Vyse : Court Resumes 3157 loveritas 25-Sep-16 10:45
Re: Creighton v Vyse : Court Resumes 859 cladking 25-Sep-16 13:25
Re: Creighton v Vyse : Court Resumes 932 Martin Stower 25-Sep-16 13:47
Re: Creighton v Vyse : Court Resumes 860 cladking 25-Sep-16 13:57
Re: Creighton v Vyse : Court Resumes 762 D-Archer 26-Sep-16 13:40
"The book is downright uninteresting" yet he couldn't wait to write lengthy hatchet job review 914 LonelyAngel 25-Sep-16 16:52
My Lord, I call a surprise witness: SCOTT CREIGHTON 946 LonelyAngel 25-Sep-16 16:54
Re: My Lord, I call a surprise witness: SCOTT CREIGHTON 920 Martin Stower 25-Sep-16 18:52
Re: My Lord, I call a surprise witness: SCOTT CREIGHTON 751 LonelyAngel 26-Sep-16 14:37
Re: My Lord, I call a surprise witness: SCOTT CREIGHTON 849 Martin Stower 26-Sep-16 19:36
Re: My Lord, I call a surprise witness: SCOTT CREIGHTON 828 Martin Stower 25-Sep-16 19:42
Re: My Lord, I call a surprise witness: SCOTT CREIGHTON 794 Thanos5150 25-Sep-16 21:05
Re: My Lord, I call a surprise witness: SCOTT CREIGHTON 754 Martin Stower 25-Sep-16 23:11
Re: "The book is downright uninteresting" yet he couldn't wait to write lengthy hatchet job review 781 Martin Stower 25-Sep-16 17:48
Re: "The book is downright uninteresting" yet he couldn't wait to write lengthy hatchet job review 742 LonelyAngel 25-Sep-16 18:05
Re: "The book is downright uninteresting" yet he couldn't wait to write lengthy hatchet job review 774 Martin Stower 25-Sep-16 18:19
Re: "The book is downright uninteresting" yet he couldn't wait to write lengthy hatchet job review 804 LonelyAngel 25-Sep-16 19:35
Re: "The book is downright uninteresting" yet he couldn't wait to write lengthy hatchet job review 725 Martin Stower 25-Sep-16 19:53
Re: "The book is downright uninteresting" yet he couldn't wait to write lengthy hatchet job review 688 LonelyAngel 25-Sep-16 20:00
Re: "The book is downright uninteresting" yet he couldn't wait to write lengthy hatchet job review 754 Martin Stower 25-Sep-16 20:16
Re: "The book is downright uninteresting" yet he couldn't wait to write lengthy hatchet job review 802 LonelyAngel 25-Sep-16 20:50
Re: "The book is downright uninteresting" yet he couldn't wait to write lengthy hatchet job review 701 Martin Stower 25-Sep-16 23:07
Right To Review. 708 DScribr 26-Sep-16 13:31
Re: Right To Review. 742 Martin Stower 26-Sep-16 20:23
Re: Right To Review. 717 DScribr 27-Sep-16 03:34
Re: "The book is downright uninteresting" yet he couldn't wait to write lengthy hatchet job review 814 R Avry Wilson 25-Sep-16 21:24
Re: "The book is downright uninteresting" yet he couldn't wait to write lengthy hatchet job review 791 LonelyAngel 25-Sep-16 21:33
Re: "The book is downright uninteresting" yet he couldn't wait to write lengthy hatchet job review 805 R Avry Wilson 26-Sep-16 01:17
Re: "The book is downright uninteresting" yet he couldn't wait to write lengthy hatchet job review 867 cladking 26-Sep-16 02:03
Re: "The book is downright uninteresting" yet he couldn't wait to write lengthy hatchet job review 793 Martin Stower 26-Sep-16 09:26
Re: "The book is downright uninteresting" yet he couldn't wait to write lengthy hatchet job review 746 cladking 26-Sep-16 13:52
Re: "The book is downright uninteresting" yet he couldn't wait to write lengthy hatchet job review 764 Martin Stower 30-Sep-16 00:06
Re: "The book is downright uninteresting" yet he couldn't wait to write lengthy hatchet job review 774 cladking 30-Sep-16 01:33
Re: "The book is downright uninteresting" yet he couldn't wait to write lengthy hatchet job review 781 LonelyAngel 26-Sep-16 14:21
Re: "The book is downright uninteresting" yet he couldn't wait to write lengthy hatchet job review 608 cladking 26-Sep-16 15:04
Re: "The book is downright uninteresting" yet he couldn't wait to write lengthy hatchet job review 743 LonelyAngel 26-Sep-16 13:48
Re: "The book is downright uninteresting" yet he couldn't wait to write lengthy hatchet job review 734 Martin Stower 26-Sep-16 20:12
Re: "The book is downright uninteresting" yet he couldn't wait to write lengthy hatchet job review 739 R Avry Wilson 26-Sep-16 21:36
Re: "The book is downright uninteresting" yet he couldn't wait to write lengthy hatchet job review 680 cladking 26-Sep-16 21:43
Re: "The book is downright uninteresting" yet he couldn't wait to write lengthy hatchet job review 710 Martin Stower 26-Sep-16 01:40
Re: "The book is downright uninteresting" yet he couldn't wait to write lengthy hatchet job review 809 cladking 25-Sep-16 21:49
Re: "The book is downright uninteresting" yet he couldn't wait to write lengthy hatchet job review 780 LonelyAngel 25-Sep-16 22:07
Re: "The book is downright uninteresting" yet he couldn't wait to write lengthy hatchet job review 730 cladking 25-Sep-16 22:18
Re: "The book is downright uninteresting" yet he couldn't wait to write lengthy hatchet job review 801 Martin Stower 25-Sep-16 22:45
Re: "The book is downright uninteresting" yet he couldn't wait to write lengthy hatchet job review 814 LonelyAngel 26-Sep-16 10:31
Re: "The book is downright uninteresting" yet he couldn't wait to write lengthy hatchet job review 698 Origyptian 26-Sep-16 15:29
Re: "The book is downright uninteresting" yet he couldn't wait to write lengthy hatchet job review 801 LonelyAngel 26-Sep-16 15:44
Re: "The book is downright uninteresting" yet he couldn't wait to write lengthy hatchet job review 773 Martin Stower 27-Sep-16 13:13
Re: "The book is downright uninteresting" yet he couldn't wait to write lengthy hatchet job review 829 Martin Stower 26-Sep-16 18:11
Re: The New Inquisition 874 Thunderbird 26-Sep-16 20:35
Re: The New Inquisition 683 Martin Stower 26-Sep-16 20:43
Re: The New Inquisition 643 cladking 26-Sep-16 21:24
Re: The New Inquisition 730 Martin Stower 26-Sep-16 21:53
Re: The New Inquisition 760 cladking 26-Sep-16 23:27
Re: The New Inquisition 712 Thanos5150 26-Sep-16 23:31
Re: The New Inquisition 708 cladking 27-Sep-16 01:25
The old copy/paste trick....... 818 DScribr 28-Sep-16 00:28
Re: The Conspiracy 677 Thunderbird 27-Sep-16 00:58
Is Jason Colavito a credible expert witness? 1171 drrayeye 26-Sep-16 17:01
Re: Is Jason Colavito a credible expert witness? 987 eyeofhorus33 26-Sep-16 19:54
Re: Is Jason Colavito a credible expert witness? 803 drrayeye 26-Sep-16 20:26
Re: Is Jason Colavito a credible expert witness? 731 M. J. Thomas 26-Sep-16 20:20
Re: Is Jason Colavito a credible expert witness? 747 cladking 26-Sep-16 21:31
Lover's premise 805 drrayeye 26-Sep-16 22:18
Re: Lover's premise 717 Martin Stower 26-Sep-16 22:20
Jason Colavito IS a credible expert witness! 828 DScribr 27-Sep-16 18:39
Re: Jason Colavito IS a credible expert witness! 944 Martin Stower 27-Sep-16 19:16
Re: Jason Colavito IS a credible expert witness! (I swear it!!!) 930 DScribr 28-Sep-16 00:21
Re: Is Jason Colavito a credible expert witness? 792 Barbelo 26-Sep-16 20:38
Re: Is Jason Colavito a credible expert witness? 748 Martin Stower 26-Sep-16 20:47
Oh Oh 831 drrayeye 26-Sep-16 22:20
Re: Oh Oh 675 Martin Stower 26-Sep-16 22:25
Re: Oh Oh 806 Barbelo 26-Sep-16 22:26
Re: Oh Oh 710 drrayeye 27-Sep-16 06:33
You're Not On The Same Page 776 Barbelo 27-Sep-16 10:19
You've got a lot to learn 792 drrayeye 29-Sep-16 05:36
Re: You've got a lot to learn 816 Barbelo 29-Sep-16 07:04
Re: You've got a lot to learn 715 Martin Stower 29-Sep-16 14:13
Re: You've got a lot to learn 747 DScribr 29-Sep-16 18:23
Re: You've got a lot to learn 664 Origyptian 29-Sep-16 14:58
Re: You've got a lot to learn 866 Martin Stower 29-Sep-16 15:16
Can anyone be a credible expert witness? 714 cladking 27-Sep-16 04:10
Re: Can anyone be a credible expert witness? 802 Thanos5150 27-Sep-16 06:02
Re: Can anyone be a credible expert witness? 721 Barbelo 27-Sep-16 10:23
Re: Can anyone be a credible expert witness? 772 cladking 27-Sep-16 15:14
Re: Can anyone be a credible expert witness? 718 Barbelo 27-Sep-16 21:11
Living in the dark ages. 698 cladking 27-Sep-16 14:00
Re: Living in the dark ages. 757 Origyptian 27-Sep-16 14:35
Re: Living in the dark ages. 761 cladking 27-Sep-16 14:51
Re: Living in the dark ages. 750 Origyptian 27-Sep-16 15:33
Re: Living in the dark ages. 728 cladking 27-Sep-16 16:11
Re: Living in the dark ages. 708 Barbelo 27-Sep-16 21:16
Re: Living in the dark ages. 707 Origyptian 27-Sep-16 21:36
Re: Living in the dark ages. 674 Martin Stower 29-Sep-16 14:16
Re: Living in the dark ages. 748 Origyptian 29-Sep-16 14:31
Re: Living in the dark ages. 712 Martin Stower 29-Sep-16 15:33
Re: Living in the dark ages. 819 Thanos5150 27-Sep-16 16:54
Re: Living in the dark ages. 798 cladking 27-Sep-16 17:22
Re: Living in the dark ages. 712 Thanos5150 27-Sep-16 18:02
Re: Living in the dark ages. 719 cladking 27-Sep-16 18:14
Oooohh... touchy 864 LonelyAngel 05-Oct-16 19:03
Re: Oooohh... touchy 684 Martin Stower 05-Oct-16 19:24
Re: Oooohh... touchy 888 LonelyAngel 05-Oct-16 19:37
Re: Oooohh... touchy 783 Martin Stower 05-Oct-16 21:08
Re: Oooohh... touchy 759 LonelyAngel 05-Oct-16 21:35
Re: Oooohh... touchy 562 Martin Stower 05-Oct-16 21:37
Re: Oooohh... touchy 761 LonelyAngel 05-Oct-16 21:41
Re: Oooohh... touchy 691 Martin Stower 05-Oct-16 22:00
Re: Oooohh... touchy 831 LonelyAngel 06-Oct-16 09:43
Re: Oooohh... touchy 736 Martin Stower 06-Oct-16 11:56
Re: Oooohh... touchy 750 LonelyAngel 06-Oct-16 13:44
Re: Oooohh... touchy 611 earllt 06-Oct-16 14:33
Re: Oooohh... touchy 651 Martin Stower 06-Oct-16 15:22
Re: Oooohh... touchy 719 Martin Stower 06-Oct-16 15:19
Re: Oooohh... touchy 700 LonelyAngel 06-Oct-16 15:28
Re: Oooohh... touchy 819 Martin Stower 06-Oct-16 20:18
Re: Oooohh... touchy 723 LonelyAngel 07-Oct-16 10:00
Re: Oooohh... touchy 636 Martin Stower 07-Oct-16 10:37
Re: Oooohh... touchy 616 LonelyAngel 07-Oct-16 10:40
Re: Oooohh... touchy 655 Martin Stower 07-Oct-16 11:26
Re: Oooohh... touchy 709 LonelyAngel 07-Oct-16 11:58
Re: Oooohh... touchy 671 Martin Stower 07-Oct-16 12:10
Re: Oooohh... touchy 715 LonelyAngel 07-Oct-16 12:45
Re: Oooohh... touchy 701 Martin Stower 07-Oct-16 13:05
Re: Oooohh... touchy 686 LonelyAngel 07-Oct-16 13:35
Re: Oooohh... touchy 689 Martin Stower 07-Oct-16 13:42
Re: Oooohh... touchy 698 LonelyAngel 07-Oct-16 13:48
Re: Oooohh... touchy 618 Martin Stower 07-Oct-16 13:55
Re: Oooohh... touchy 674 LonelyAngel 07-Oct-16 14:00
Re: Oooohh... touchy 726 Martin Stower 07-Oct-16 14:47
Re: Oooohh... touchy 705 LonelyAngel 07-Oct-16 15:01
Re: Oooohh... touchy 691 Martin Stower 07-Oct-16 15:22
Re: Oooohh... touchy 573 LonelyAngel 07-Oct-16 15:47
Re: Oooohh... touchy 668 Martin Stower 07-Oct-16 16:37
Re: Oooohh... touchy 691 Jon Ellison 07-Oct-16 17:12
Re: Oooohh... touchy 679 Martin Stower 07-Oct-16 18:22
Re: Oooohh... touchy 699 Jon Ellison 07-Oct-16 18:41
Re: Oooohh... touchy 698 Martin Stower 07-Oct-16 19:02
Re: Oooohh... touchy 642 LonelyAngel 07-Oct-16 20:01
Re: Oooohh... touchy 637 Martin Stower 07-Oct-16 20:58
Re: Oooohh... touchy 664 LonelyAngel 07-Oct-16 21:52
Re: Oooohh... touchy 897 Martin Stower 07-Oct-16 22:35
Re: Oooohh... touchy 754 LonelyAngel 08-Oct-16 10:29
Re: Oooohh... touchy 670 Morten 08-Oct-16 15:36
Re: Oooohh... touchy 612 LonelyAngel 08-Oct-16 17:35
Re: Oooohh... touchy 703 LonelyAngel 08-Oct-16 17:41
Re: Oooohh... touchy 857 Martin Stower 08-Oct-16 20:01
Gottfried Wilhelm Leibniz 598 LonelyAngel 08-Oct-16 20:14
Re: Gottfried Wilhelm Leibniz 668 Martin Stower 08-Oct-16 20:35
Philosophy: Schrödinger's cat 611 LonelyAngel 08-Oct-16 21:03
Re: Philosophy: Schrödinger's cat 728 Martin Stower 08-Oct-16 21:50
Re: Philosophy: Schrödinger's cat 626 LonelyAngel 09-Oct-16 09:22
Re: Philosophy: Schrödinger's cat 670 Martin Stower 09-Oct-16 16:46
Re: Philosophy: Schrödinger's cat 714 LonelyAngel 10-Oct-16 10:27
Re: Philosophy: Schrödinger's cat 890 Martin Stower 10-Oct-16 17:12
Re: Philosophy: Schrödinger's cat 582 LonelyAngel 11-Oct-16 13:32
Re: Philosophy: Schrödinger's cat 696 Martin Stower 11-Oct-16 16:54
Re: Philosophy: Schrödinger's cat 634 LonelyAngel 11-Oct-16 16:59
Re: Philosophy: Schrödinger's cat 705 Martin Stower 11-Oct-16 17:36
Re: Philosophy: Schrödinger's cat 634 randompHactor 11-Oct-16 17:38
Re: Philosophy: Schrödinger's cat 655 eyeofhorus33 11-Oct-16 18:10
The Three Stooges 807 LonelyAngel 11-Oct-16 19:52
Re: The Three Stooges 765 eyeofhorus33 11-Oct-16 19:55
Re: The Three Stooges 826 Martin Stower 11-Oct-16 23:02
Re: The Three Stooges 778 Luminescence 12-Oct-16 01:03
Re: Oooohh... touchy 726 Thunderbird 06-Oct-16 17:59
Racing for the Cliffs. 756 cladking 06-Oct-16 14:10
Re: Racing for the Cliffs. 643 LonelyAngel 06-Oct-16 14:33
Re: Racing for the Cliffs. 651 Jon Ellison 06-Oct-16 14:39
Re: Racing for the Cliffs. 715 LonelyAngel 06-Oct-16 14:41
Re: Racing for the Cliffs. 750 Jon Ellison 06-Oct-16 14:48


Sorry, only registered users may post in this forum.