Of Scott and his warmly awaited publication, you commented:
"Otherwise, if he says "trust me, my experts know what they're talking about" I simply take that into advisement until I verify."
Funny how you never seem to say this in respect of mainstream Egyptology.
Having not seen the cartouche with your own eyes, and by Jon's own admission that, to his knowledge, no-one else has analysed the cartouche using his preferred methodology - then no-one can yet "verify" or challenge his opinion.
For this reason, I think the matter on both sides of this debate ought to rest.