Mysteries :  The Official GrahamHancock.com forums
For serious discussion of the controversies, approaches and enigmas surrounding the origins and development of the human species and of human civilization. (NB: for more ‘out there’ posts we point you in the direction of the ‘Paranormal & Supernatural’ Message Board). 
Welcome! Log InRegister
Origyptian Wrote:
-------------------------------------------------------
> Martin Stower Wrote:
> --------------------------------------------------
> -----
> > Excuse me? Credibility by association? Meeting
> > the requirements of a leading university for the
> > award of a doctoral degree is credibility by
> > association?
> >
> > You’re complaining about this?
> >
> > This warrants guilt by association?
>
> I'm saying that complying with the scholarly
> requirements to earn an academic degree does not
> ensure ethical integrity. To claim a person's work
> is credible or honest by virtue of the academic
> institution they attended is illogical. Examples
> of that abound involving the highest scholarly
> accomplishments at the most prominent academic
> institutions around the world. This is not my
> opinion, it's documented fact.

This certainly applies to Osmanagić. Perhaps you should explain this to Audrey.

Unless someone can show that Pruitt has made claims as questionable as the ones Osmanagić has made, the point is an empty one.

And unless I’m missing something, the work cited met the scholarly requirements.

M.

Options: ReplyQuote


Subject Views Written By Posted
Why Does GH Denies the Bosnian Pyramids? 3556 Buildreps 30-Mar-16 09:51
Re: Why Does GH Denies the Bosnian Pyramids? 1494 Origyptian 30-Mar-16 13:11
Re: Why Does GH Denies the Bosnian Pyramids? 1397 OCaptain 30-Mar-16 13:35
Re: Why Does GH Denies the Bosnian Pyramids? 1281 carolb 30-Mar-16 13:44
Re: Why Does GH Denies the Bosnian Pyramids? 1203 Buildreps 30-Mar-16 14:23
Re: Why Does GH Denies the Bosnian Pyramids? 999 OCaptain 30-Mar-16 14:27
Re: Why Does GH Denies the Bosnian Pyramids? 1132 Origyptian 30-Mar-16 14:37
Re: Why Does GH Denies the Bosnian Pyramids? 1001 Buildreps 30-Mar-16 20:23
Re: Why Does GH Denies the Bosnian Pyramids? 994 Origyptian 30-Mar-16 20:49
Re: HERE IS EVIDENCE Why Does GH Denies the Bosnian Pyramids? 1142 Luminescence 01-Apr-16 01:56
Re: HERE IS EVIDENCE Why Does GH Denies the Bosnian Pyramids? 833 D-Archer 01-Apr-16 14:53
Re: HERE IS EVIDENCE Why Does GH Denies the Bosnian Pyramids? 905 Merrell 01-Apr-16 15:04
Re: HERE IS EVIDENCE Why Does GH Denies the Bosnian Pyramids? 843 D-Archer 03-Apr-16 10:33
Re: HERE IS EVIDENCE Why Does GH Denies the Bosnian Pyramids? 843 Origyptian 01-Apr-16 15:41
Re: HERE IS EVIDENCE Why Does GH Denies the Bosnian Pyramids? 806 Audrey 01-Apr-16 23:30
Re: Ancient Runic script 829 Thunderbird 02-Apr-16 01:28
Re: Ancient Runic script 831 Merrell 02-Apr-16 11:45
Re: Ancient Runic script 789 Thunderbird 02-Apr-16 20:13
Church tried to erase it and failed 727 Ratcho 03-Apr-16 06:51
Re: Father Crespi 703 Thunderbird 03-Apr-16 17:44
Re: Ancient Runic script 718 Merrell 03-Apr-16 10:36
Re: Ancient Runic...Comparison between sign systems 712 Thunderbird 03-Apr-16 00:36
Re: Ancient Runic...Comparison between sign systems 673 Audrey 03-Apr-16 03:23
Re: Ancient Runic...Comparison between sign systems 667 Thunderbird 03-Apr-16 04:06
Re: Ancient Runic...Comparison between sign systems 647 D-Archer 03-Apr-16 10:42
Re: ROVAS - 30 years 641 Thunderbird 03-Apr-16 16:26
Re: HERE IS EVIDENCE Why Does GH Denies the Bosnian Pyramids? 672 D-Archer 03-Apr-16 10:34
Re: Why Does GH Denies the Bosnian Pyramids? 644 D-Archer 31-Mar-16 09:35
Re: Why Does GH Denies the Bosnian Pyramids? 763 gulsbo 30-Mar-16 21:27
Re: Why Does GH Denies the Bosnian Pyramids? 726 Merrell 30-Mar-16 21:37
Re: Why Does GH Denies the Bosnian Pyramids? 767 Yourconscience 01-Apr-16 00:27
Re: Why Does GH Denies the Bosnian Pyramids? 792 Merrell 01-Apr-16 08:27
Re: Why Does GH Denies the Bosnian Pyramids? 676 Audrey 01-Apr-16 17:09
Re: Why Does GH Denies the Bosnian Pyramids? 791 Merrell 02-Apr-16 09:54
Re: Why Does GH Denies the Bosnian Pyramids? 672 Thanos5150 02-Apr-16 15:39
Re: Why Does GH Denies the Bosnian Pyramids? 692 Audrey 02-Apr-16 17:34
Re: Why Does GH Denies the Bosnian Pyramids? 710 Merrell 03-Apr-16 22:04
Re: Why Does GH Denies the Bosnian Pyramids? 667 Audrey 04-Apr-16 00:57
Re: Why Does GH Denies the Bosnian Pyramids? 672 Origyptian 04-Apr-16 01:59
A volunteer archaeologist's view of the Bosnian "pyramids" 547 Merrell 08-Apr-16 12:05
Re: A volunteer archaeologist's view of the Bosnian "pyramids" 764 carolb 08-Apr-16 12:23
Re: A volunteer archaeologist's view of the Bosnian "pyramids" 695 Merrell 08-Apr-16 16:37
Re: Why Does GH Denies the Bosnian Pyramids? 718 Harte 31-Mar-16 10:04
Re: Why Does GH Denies the Bosnian Pyramids? 765 D-Archer 31-Mar-16 10:30
Re: Why Does GH Denies the Bosnian Pyramids? 740 Audrey 31-Mar-16 23:46
Re: Why Does GH Denies the Bosnian Pyramids? 692 Merrell 01-Apr-16 12:29
Re: Why Does GH Denies the Bosnian Pyramids? 653 Audrey 01-Apr-16 16:53
Re: Why Does GH Denies the Bosnian Pyramids? 647 Merrell 02-Apr-16 09:53
Re: Why Does GH Denies the Bosnian Pyramids? 684 Audrey 02-Apr-16 17:27
Re: Why Does GH Denies the Bosnian Pyramids? 680 Merrell 02-Apr-16 20:09
Re: Why Does GH Denies the Bosnian Pyramids? 660 Audrey 03-Apr-16 03:29
Re: Why Does GH Denies the Bosnian Pyramids? 702 D-Archer 03-Apr-16 10:48
Re: Why Does GH Denies the Bosnian Pyramids? 732 Origyptian 03-Apr-16 14:48
Re: Why Does GH Denies the Bosnian Pyramids? 589 Merrell 03-Apr-16 15:30
Re: Why Does GH Denies the Bosnian Pyramids? 638 Origyptian 03-Apr-16 16:19
Re: Why Does GH Denies the Bosnian Pyramids? 760 Thanos5150 03-Apr-16 16:27
Re: Why Does GH Denies the Bosnian Pyramids? 660 Merrell 03-Apr-16 16:44
Re: Why Does GH Denies the Bosnian Pyramids? 693 Origyptian 03-Apr-16 17:15
Re: Why Does GH Denies the Bosnian Pyramids? 743 Merrell 03-Apr-16 19:53
Re: Why Does GH Denies the Bosnian Pyramids? 675 D-Archer 03-Apr-16 20:51
Re: Why Does GH Denies the Bosnian Pyramids? 616 Martin Stower 04-Apr-16 01:44
Re: Why Does GH Denies the Bosnian Pyramids? 644 Origyptian 03-Apr-16 22:42
Re: Why Does GH Denies the Bosnian Pyramids? 630 Martin Stower 04-Apr-16 02:03
Re: Why Does GH Denies the Bosnian Pyramids? 670 Origyptian 04-Apr-16 02:09
Re: Why Does GH Denies the Bosnian Pyramids? 632 Martin Stower 04-Apr-16 02:40
Re: Why Does GH Denies the Bosnian Pyramids? 767 gulsbo 11-Apr-16 14:31
Re: Why Does GH Denies the Bosnian Pyramids? 706 Audrey 03-Apr-16 18:37
Re: Why Does GH Denies the Bosnian Pyramids? 703 Martin Stower 04-Apr-16 01:27
Re: Why Does GH Denies the Bosnian Pyramids? 573 Martin Stower 04-Apr-16 02:24
Re: Why Does GH Denies the Bosnian Pyramids? 676 Audrey 04-Apr-16 04:42
Re: Why Does GH Denies the Bosnian Pyramids? 684 D-Archer 01-Apr-16 14:55
Re: Why Does GH Denies the Bosnian Pyramids? 685 Buildreps 01-Apr-16 16:30
Re: Why Does GH Denies the Bosnian Pyramids? 657 Harte 01-Apr-16 23:48
Re: Why Does GH Denies the Bosnian Pyramids? 622 Audrey 02-Apr-16 00:15
Re: Why Does GH Denies the Bosnian Pyramids? 691 Audrey 02-Apr-16 02:36
Powerful stuff in that vid Audrey 606 Ratcho 02-Apr-16 06:23
Re: Why Does GH Denies the Bosnian Pyramids? 590 Merrell 02-Apr-16 10:02
Re: Why Does GH Denies the Bosnian Pyramids? 624 Merrell 02-Apr-16 10:48
Re: Why Does GH Denies the Bosnian Pyramids? 696 Harte 02-Apr-16 13:07
Re: Why Does GH Denies the Bosnian Pyramids? 683 Audrey 03-Apr-16 04:14
Re: Why Does GH Denies the Bosnian Pyramids? 630 Harte 03-Apr-16 15:56
Re: Why Does GH Denies the Bosnian Pyramids? 639 Audrey 04-Apr-16 01:16
Re: Why Does GH Denies the Bosnian Pyramids? 675 carolb 02-Apr-16 12:17
Visočica Flatiron 644 Dr. Troglodyte 02-Apr-16 22:36
Re: Why Does GH Denies the Bosnian Pyramids? 744 D-Archer 31-Mar-16 09:28
Re: Why Does GH Denies the Bosnian Pyramids? 916 Buildreps 07-Apr-16 15:29
Re: Why Does GH Denies the Bosnian Pyramids? 721 carolb 07-Apr-16 16:07
Re: Why Does GH Denies the Bosnian Pyramids? 650 Brian Patterson 07-Apr-16 16:40
Re: Why Does GH Denies the Bosnian Pyramids? 515 carolb 07-Apr-16 17:36
Re: Why Does GH Denies the Bosnian Pyramids? 659 D-Archer 08-Apr-16 09:43
Re: Why Does GH Denies the Bosnian Pyramids? 763 Harte 08-Apr-16 09:55
Re: Why Does GH Denies the Bosnian Pyramids? 683 D-Archer 08-Apr-16 10:00
Re: Why Does GH Denies the Bosnian Pyramids? 705 carolb 08-Apr-16 11:56
Re: Why Does GH Denies the Bosnian Pyramids? 695 D-Archer 08-Apr-16 14:31
Re: Why Does GH Denies the Bosnian Pyramids? 719 carolb 08-Apr-16 15:25
Re: Why Does GH Denies the Bosnian Pyramids? 810 Buildreps 08-Apr-16 14:02
Re: Why Does GH Denies the Bosnian Pyramids? 1223 carolb 08-Apr-16 17:42
Re: Why Does GH Denies the Bosnian Pyramids? 739 Richard Fusniak 08-Apr-16 21:41
Re: Why Does GH Denies the Bosnian Pyramids? 669 UninterestedObserver 18-Apr-17 21:56
Re: Why Does GH Denies the Bosnian Pyramids? 473 Albert Mag 10-Jan-18 07:52


Sorry, only registered users may post in this forum.