Mysteries :  The Official GrahamHancock.com forums
For serious discussion of the controversies, approaches and enigmas surrounding the origins and development of the human species and of human civilization. (NB: for more ‘out there’ posts we point you in the direction of the ‘Paranormal & Supernatural’ Message Board). 
Welcome! Log InRegister
Origyptian Wrote:
-------------------------------------------------------
> Martin Stower Wrote:
> --------------------------------------------------
> -----
> > Excuse me? Credibility by association? Meeting
> > the requirements of a leading university for the
> > award of a doctoral degree is credibility by
> > association?
> >
> > You’re complaining about this?
> >
> > This warrants guilt by association?
>
> I'm saying that complying with the scholarly
> requirements to earn an academic degree does not
> ensure ethical integrity. To claim a person's work
> is credible or honest by virtue of the academic
> institution they attended is illogical. Examples
> of that abound involving the highest scholarly
> accomplishments at the most prominent academic
> institutions around the world. This is not my
> opinion, it's documented fact.

This certainly applies to Osmanagić. Perhaps you should explain this to Audrey.

Unless someone can show that Pruitt has made claims as questionable as the ones Osmanagić has made, the point is an empty one.

And unless I’m missing something, the work cited met the scholarly requirements.

M.

Options: ReplyQuote


Subject Views Written By Posted
Why Does GH Denies the Bosnian Pyramids? 3066 Buildreps 30-Mar-16 09:51
Re: Why Does GH Denies the Bosnian Pyramids? 1306 Origyptian 30-Mar-16 13:11
Re: Why Does GH Denies the Bosnian Pyramids? 1214 OCaptain 30-Mar-16 13:35
Re: Why Does GH Denies the Bosnian Pyramids? 1093 carolb 30-Mar-16 13:44
Re: Why Does GH Denies the Bosnian Pyramids? 1031 Buildreps 30-Mar-16 14:23
Re: Why Does GH Denies the Bosnian Pyramids? 840 OCaptain 30-Mar-16 14:27
Re: Why Does GH Denies the Bosnian Pyramids? 929 Origyptian 30-Mar-16 14:37
Re: Why Does GH Denies the Bosnian Pyramids? 829 Buildreps 30-Mar-16 20:23
Re: Why Does GH Denies the Bosnian Pyramids? 849 Origyptian 30-Mar-16 20:49
Re: HERE IS EVIDENCE Why Does GH Denies the Bosnian Pyramids? 1002 Luminescence 01-Apr-16 01:56
Re: HERE IS EVIDENCE Why Does GH Denies the Bosnian Pyramids? 701 D-Archer 01-Apr-16 14:53
Re: HERE IS EVIDENCE Why Does GH Denies the Bosnian Pyramids? 770 Merrell 01-Apr-16 15:04
Re: HERE IS EVIDENCE Why Does GH Denies the Bosnian Pyramids? 688 D-Archer 03-Apr-16 10:33
Re: HERE IS EVIDENCE Why Does GH Denies the Bosnian Pyramids? 722 Origyptian 01-Apr-16 15:41
Re: HERE IS EVIDENCE Why Does GH Denies the Bosnian Pyramids? 690 Audrey 01-Apr-16 23:30
Re: Ancient Runic script 665 Thunderbird 02-Apr-16 01:28
Re: Ancient Runic script 665 Merrell 02-Apr-16 11:45
Re: Ancient Runic script 670 Thunderbird 02-Apr-16 20:13
Church tried to erase it and failed 565 Ratcho 03-Apr-16 06:51
Re: Father Crespi 586 Thunderbird 03-Apr-16 17:44
Re: Ancient Runic script 609 Merrell 03-Apr-16 10:36
Re: Ancient Runic...Comparison between sign systems 565 Thunderbird 03-Apr-16 00:36
Re: Ancient Runic...Comparison between sign systems 565 Audrey 03-Apr-16 03:23
Re: Ancient Runic...Comparison between sign systems 549 Thunderbird 03-Apr-16 04:06
Re: Ancient Runic...Comparison between sign systems 542 D-Archer 03-Apr-16 10:42
Re: ROVAS - 30 years 533 Thunderbird 03-Apr-16 16:26
Re: HERE IS EVIDENCE Why Does GH Denies the Bosnian Pyramids? 576 D-Archer 03-Apr-16 10:34
Re: Why Does GH Denies the Bosnian Pyramids? 507 D-Archer 31-Mar-16 09:35
Re: Why Does GH Denies the Bosnian Pyramids? 622 gulsbo 30-Mar-16 21:27
Re: Why Does GH Denies the Bosnian Pyramids? 599 Merrell 30-Mar-16 21:37
Re: Why Does GH Denies the Bosnian Pyramids? 612 Yourconscience 01-Apr-16 00:27
Re: Why Does GH Denies the Bosnian Pyramids? 667 Merrell 01-Apr-16 08:27
Re: Why Does GH Denies the Bosnian Pyramids? 546 Audrey 01-Apr-16 17:09
Re: Why Does GH Denies the Bosnian Pyramids? 681 Merrell 02-Apr-16 09:54
Re: Why Does GH Denies the Bosnian Pyramids? 569 Thanos5150 02-Apr-16 15:39
Re: Why Does GH Denies the Bosnian Pyramids? 575 Audrey 02-Apr-16 17:34
Re: Why Does GH Denies the Bosnian Pyramids? 582 Merrell 03-Apr-16 22:04
Re: Why Does GH Denies the Bosnian Pyramids? 526 Audrey 04-Apr-16 00:57
Re: Why Does GH Denies the Bosnian Pyramids? 550 Origyptian 04-Apr-16 01:59
A volunteer archaeologist's view of the Bosnian "pyramids" 435 Merrell 08-Apr-16 12:05
Re: A volunteer archaeologist's view of the Bosnian "pyramids" 604 carolb 08-Apr-16 12:23
Re: A volunteer archaeologist's view of the Bosnian "pyramids" 574 Merrell 08-Apr-16 16:37
Re: Why Does GH Denies the Bosnian Pyramids? 615 Harte 31-Mar-16 10:04
Re: Why Does GH Denies the Bosnian Pyramids? 639 D-Archer 31-Mar-16 10:30
Re: Why Does GH Denies the Bosnian Pyramids? 640 Audrey 31-Mar-16 23:46
Re: Why Does GH Denies the Bosnian Pyramids? 576 Merrell 01-Apr-16 12:29
Re: Why Does GH Denies the Bosnian Pyramids? 538 Audrey 01-Apr-16 16:53
Re: Why Does GH Denies the Bosnian Pyramids? 529 Merrell 02-Apr-16 09:53
Re: Why Does GH Denies the Bosnian Pyramids? 569 Audrey 02-Apr-16 17:27
Re: Why Does GH Denies the Bosnian Pyramids? 559 Merrell 02-Apr-16 20:09
Re: Why Does GH Denies the Bosnian Pyramids? 538 Audrey 03-Apr-16 03:29
Re: Why Does GH Denies the Bosnian Pyramids? 576 D-Archer 03-Apr-16 10:48
Re: Why Does GH Denies the Bosnian Pyramids? 617 Origyptian 03-Apr-16 14:48
Re: Why Does GH Denies the Bosnian Pyramids? 482 Merrell 03-Apr-16 15:30
Re: Why Does GH Denies the Bosnian Pyramids? 517 Origyptian 03-Apr-16 16:19
Re: Why Does GH Denies the Bosnian Pyramids? 611 Thanos5150 03-Apr-16 16:27
Re: Why Does GH Denies the Bosnian Pyramids? 550 Merrell 03-Apr-16 16:44
Re: Why Does GH Denies the Bosnian Pyramids? 549 Origyptian 03-Apr-16 17:15
Re: Why Does GH Denies the Bosnian Pyramids? 566 Merrell 03-Apr-16 19:53
Re: Why Does GH Denies the Bosnian Pyramids? 564 D-Archer 03-Apr-16 20:51
Re: Why Does GH Denies the Bosnian Pyramids? 499 Martin Stower 04-Apr-16 01:44
Re: Why Does GH Denies the Bosnian Pyramids? 537 Origyptian 03-Apr-16 22:42
Re: Why Does GH Denies the Bosnian Pyramids? 516 Martin Stower 04-Apr-16 02:03
Re: Why Does GH Denies the Bosnian Pyramids? 553 Origyptian 04-Apr-16 02:09
Re: Why Does GH Denies the Bosnian Pyramids? 522 Martin Stower 04-Apr-16 02:40
Re: Why Does GH Denies the Bosnian Pyramids? 618 gulsbo 11-Apr-16 14:31
Re: Why Does GH Denies the Bosnian Pyramids? 554 Audrey 03-Apr-16 18:37
Re: Why Does GH Denies the Bosnian Pyramids? 567 Martin Stower 04-Apr-16 01:27
Re: Why Does GH Denies the Bosnian Pyramids? 470 Martin Stower 04-Apr-16 02:24
Re: Why Does GH Denies the Bosnian Pyramids? 510 Audrey 04-Apr-16 04:42
Re: Why Does GH Denies the Bosnian Pyramids? 565 D-Archer 01-Apr-16 14:55
Re: Why Does GH Denies the Bosnian Pyramids? 543 Buildreps 01-Apr-16 16:30
Re: Why Does GH Denies the Bosnian Pyramids? 548 Harte 01-Apr-16 23:48
Re: Why Does GH Denies the Bosnian Pyramids? 526 Audrey 02-Apr-16 00:15
Re: Why Does GH Denies the Bosnian Pyramids? 571 Audrey 02-Apr-16 02:36
Powerful stuff in that vid Audrey 518 Ratcho 02-Apr-16 06:23
Re: Why Does GH Denies the Bosnian Pyramids? 493 Merrell 02-Apr-16 10:02
Re: Why Does GH Denies the Bosnian Pyramids? 507 Merrell 02-Apr-16 10:48
Re: Why Does GH Denies the Bosnian Pyramids? 581 Harte 02-Apr-16 13:07
Re: Why Does GH Denies the Bosnian Pyramids? 572 Audrey 03-Apr-16 04:14
Re: Why Does GH Denies the Bosnian Pyramids? 519 Harte 03-Apr-16 15:56
Re: Why Does GH Denies the Bosnian Pyramids? 535 Audrey 04-Apr-16 01:16
Re: Why Does GH Denies the Bosnian Pyramids? 570 carolb 02-Apr-16 12:17
Visočica Flatiron 537 Dr. Troglodyte 02-Apr-16 22:36
Re: Why Does GH Denies the Bosnian Pyramids? 609 D-Archer 31-Mar-16 09:28
Re: Why Does GH Denies the Bosnian Pyramids? 779 Buildreps 07-Apr-16 15:29
Re: Why Does GH Denies the Bosnian Pyramids? 587 carolb 07-Apr-16 16:07
Re: Why Does GH Denies the Bosnian Pyramids? 509 Brian Patterson 07-Apr-16 16:40
Re: Why Does GH Denies the Bosnian Pyramids? 407 carolb 07-Apr-16 17:36
Re: Why Does GH Denies the Bosnian Pyramids? 553 D-Archer 08-Apr-16 09:43
Re: Why Does GH Denies the Bosnian Pyramids? 634 Harte 08-Apr-16 09:55
Re: Why Does GH Denies the Bosnian Pyramids? 578 D-Archer 08-Apr-16 10:00
Re: Why Does GH Denies the Bosnian Pyramids? 594 carolb 08-Apr-16 11:56
Re: Why Does GH Denies the Bosnian Pyramids? 555 D-Archer 08-Apr-16 14:31
Re: Why Does GH Denies the Bosnian Pyramids? 564 carolb 08-Apr-16 15:25
Re: Why Does GH Denies the Bosnian Pyramids? 617 Buildreps 08-Apr-16 14:02
Re: Why Does GH Denies the Bosnian Pyramids? 958 carolb 08-Apr-16 17:42
Re: Why Does GH Denies the Bosnian Pyramids? 607 Richard Fusniak 08-Apr-16 21:41
Re: Why Does GH Denies the Bosnian Pyramids? 528 UninterestedObserver 18-Apr-17 21:56
Re: Why Does GH Denies the Bosnian Pyramids? 343 Albert Mag 10-Jan-18 07:52


Sorry, only registered users may post in this forum.